StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name of student: Topic: Lecturer: Date of Presentation: Introduction There are many theories advanced by various philosophers and political theorists regarding freedom and equality and governance. The classical liberalists emphasize on moral equality and freedom means non interference of the state on private interests…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism"

Download file to see previous pages

Rousseau on the other hand, emphasizes on democratic political interdependence and economic self-sufficiency whereby all human beings are free and also tries to explain the origin of inequalities and how to resolve them. Just like Rousseau, Marx hates inequalities hence much of his work is criticism of the capitalist state and goes beyond political democracy to emancipation of the human race. The paper will discuss Rousseau and Marx approaches to critique of classical liberalism. Classical liberalism puts emphasis on securing the freedom of individual by limiting the power of the state and this freedom is referred as liberty.

In this case, ownership of private property is encouraged and protected by the law and exchange of the property with a willing buyer is voluntary. It also advocates for the need to separate the church from the state hence freedom of religion and also free trade. This is in the belief that people have inalienable rights to life, liberty and pursuit of happiness and the role of the state is to safeguard these rights (Fremont-Barnes, 225). It is also based on the idea that people aim at maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain and that people engage in labor voluntarily to get a reward or due to fear of hunger.

Much emphasis is placed on the individual since the society is a sum of individual members thus discourages formation of unions or group associations (Epstein, 1-12). Contrary to classical liberalism which emphasizes negative freedom whereby others should refrain from interfering with other’s rights, Rousseau views freedom as positive whereby individuals are enabled to realize higher goods. On the discourse on the origin and basis of inequality (1755), Rousseau acknowledges the existence of primitive societies who lived under the natural state and directed to act by their passions and desire.

Under the natural state, all men are equal and inequality is brought about by men through civilization (Rousseau 1987, 26). Each society member has a task to perform and no one is forced to share tasks with others and the sovereign and the people have same interests. Contrary to classical liberalism, under this democratic government no one is above the law and if a government proves not fit for the society, the society has the right to overthrow it and form a new government. Such was the case with the French revolution which led to overthrow of the monarch.

The government envisioned by Rousseau is a direct and not representative democracy where the people are sovereign with a general will and legislative power with the government being distinct from the sovereign (Rousseau 2008, 25). The government neither engages in conquest of its neighbors since it is self-sufficient nor expects to be conquered but instead it expects the neighbors to be of assistance in time of need hence political interdependence (Rousseau 1987, 27). On his second discourse, Rousseau points out two types of inequalities; natural inequality such as age, health and bodily strength; Moral or political inequality which is consented by men such as being more powerful, richer and more honored.

He argues that the development of inequalities was as a result of evolution from natural to moral inequality. The formation of language was important in the evolution as it enabled the ideas to be spread widely otherwise in the state of nature, any

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism Essay”, n.d.)
Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1439916-rousseau-marx-and-the-critique-of-classical
(Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism Essay)
Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1439916-rousseau-marx-and-the-critique-of-classical.
“Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1439916-rousseau-marx-and-the-critique-of-classical.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism

What Did Marx Learn From Rousseau and How Did He Shift the Political Thought

This report "What Did marx Learn From Rousseau and How Did He Shift the Political Thought?... In The Communist Manifesto, marx argues that the bourgeois reason requires a steady and incomplete change in capital materials and, ultimately, society itself.... marx writes, “The bourgeoisie cannot live with no continually revolutionizing the instruments of manufacture, and thus the relations of manufacture, and with them the entire relations of society”....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

Western vision and American values. Western notions of freedom and democracy

y discussion explores the position vis a vis the two great democratic nations which have led the world in their quest for human rights … It has often been said that the modern American Constitution along with the Declaration of Independence is a result of Lockean Ideals of liberalism(that is John Locke's Concepts based on liberty, freedom, instituting government, and the right to alter that government.... t has often been said that the modern American Constitution along with the Declaration of Independence is a result of Lockean Ideals of liberalism(that is John Locke's Concepts based on liberty, freedom, instituting government, and the right to alter that government....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Rousseau and Marx Can Be Seen as Critics of the Disenchantment

As Rousseau and marx can be seen as critics of the disenchantment of the world so how would they propose to re-enchant the world.... It was on this, finally, although possibly differently phrased, that the great proto-sociologists, Rousseau and marx, as well as the founding fathers of the discipline, paid attention to.... The experience of disenchantment becomes critical for marx when he is able to see within it the seeds of our capacity to experience a restraint that cannot be surmounted....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Classical and Modern Liberals and the Role of the State

The value of freedom “has its roots not only in Rousseau's and Kant's political theory, but also in John Stuart Mill's On Liberty… [and is still] a dominant strain in liberalism” (SEP, 2007).... liberalism prefers a limited role of the state because the state is perceived to be abusive of individual liberties, which leads to tensions between the individual and the state.... classical liberals favour religious tolerance over a religious monopoly....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

What Did Marx Learn from Rousseau and How Did He Shift the Political Thought

Does he offer the voice of enlightenment's own self-critique or that of a proto-romantic who methodically disavowed as cold and germ-free the disillusioned worldview of his former peers?... The author identifies what marx learned from Rousseau.... The author states that limiting the powers of government is the only way to defend personal rights, and Constant is worried that rousseau fails to do this.... rousseau goes so far as to create the error of granting total power to the sovereign....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Classical vs. Welfare Liberalism Analysis

hellip; classical liberalism focuses on property, liberty, and life and argues that the government should not interfere in the lives of citizens as they pursue their goals.... Welfare liberalism, on the other hand, focuses on the same rights, but unlike classical liberalism, it supports government interference in the lives of citizens.... classical liberalism was formulated by John Locke (Noddings, 2002).... Welfare liberalism Analysis" focuses on a discussion of both political philosophies and at the end of the paper, welfare liberalism is chosen as the most preferable political philosophy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Jean Jacques Rousseau and Theodor Adorno in the Development of Social Thought

In fact, as liberalism representative, he stressed on individual rights and freedoms during one's existence in a state.... This paper "Jean Jacques rousseau and Theodor Adorno in the Development of Social Thought" focuses on the fact that in the development of social thought a crucial issue of man's position in the society has always appeared.... In this context, Jean Jacques rousseau proposed a concept of the general will, meaning that each person acted independently but together with others while establishing a state....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Liberalism Has Proved the Most Successful Ideology

This paper "Liberalism Has Proved the Most Successful Ideology" will critically evaluate problems in classical liberalism and neo-liberalism and will examine the background and reasons for the success of liberalism as a political ideology and system.... There are different kinds of liberalism such as classical liberalism, neoliberalism, and social liberalism.... hellip; A number of scholars hold the view that liberalism as a political ideology has left a significant impact on our society and has successfully maintained its political hegemony....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us