StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

World Trade Organization Dispute Settlement - Essay Example

Summary
From the paper "World Trade Organization Dispute Settlement" it is clear that the WTO dispute settlement process is grounded on various fundamental jurisprudence principles which contribute to maintaining and establishing a predictable and stable trading relationship among members of WTO…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "World Trade Organization Dispute Settlement"

Download file to see previous pages

WTO was formulated from the Uruguay Round table negotiation of 1947 under the framework of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT).

Without a mechanism of dispute settlement, a system based on rules would not be fruitful since enforcing rules, would seem difficult. This particular paper seeks to evaluate the WTO dispute settlement mechanism. The scope of the analysis will cover the process of dispute settlement, the preparation procedure of dispute settlement, the WTO jurisprudence principles, and lastly the role played by the WTO dispute settlement system. The dispute settlement processThe mechanism for dispute settlement initiated by the World Trade Organization (WTO) during the year 1995 has been the basis of the organization.

It has been able to offer all the 144 members of the World Trade Organization an assurance that the obligations, as well as the commitments negotiated, will be respected. It, therefore, does not enforce new obligations, but it enforces those that have already been agreed upon. The dispute settlement process is founded on explicitly defined rules having timetables through which a case is completed. The priority or the main concern is to resolve disputes by way of consultations wherever possible. According to Jackson (2009), by the end of July 2003, 32 out of the 203 cases had already been settled out of court without following the complete panel process.

In the same way as the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (now WTO) of 1994, practice under the World Trade Organization shows that parties can negotiate mutually decided solutions to various disputes without deciding on a third-party intervention, particularly in the past eighteen years, however, a large part of the disputes have also resulted into creation of a panel. Steps in the Dispute Settlement Process According to Jackson (2000) etal, the WTO dispute settlement process has basic steps which include; Consultation, Panel formation, and the Panel process.

ConsultationsThe dispute resolution process begins with consultation among the various parties involved in the dispute. Before any kind of action is taken, countries involved in a given dispute have to discuss their issues with each other to find out if they can solve their differences on their own. If talks do not succeed, they can ask for assistance from the World Trade Organization director-general to act as a mediator or to help them in any other way. The consultations offer an opportunity for a given nation to evaluate the merits of the other party’s case and as a result clarify the various facts (World Trade Organization, 2010).

To make easier the process, the country complaining can submit various written questions that the defending country is expected to answer during consultation. The countries can have more than one consultation in case the process is more informative or if they feel they can reach an agreement. Consultations are however not followed by requests from the panel. This is because at times the threat of action tends to be more compelling than the action itself. On the other hand, consultations can provide information as well as influence negotiations that eventually result in a successful settlement of disputes.

From time to time, a complaining party has an opportunity to learn through the consultation process the various weaknesses surrounding its arguments or the damaging facts which may result in a conclusion not to push the issue.

...Download file to see next pages Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF World Trade Organization Dispute Settlement

REPORT TOPIC LAW

The World Trade Organization Dispute Settlement Body (WTO-DSB) resolves trade disputes between states.... Instead, International Law is enforced by agreement between parties to a treaty, convention or international organization.... The UN Security Council can also be considered an international quasi-court in the sense that it can determine if there is a threat to world peace and decide the appropriate course of action against that threat....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

World Trade Organisation Law

"Issue relating to the World Trade Organization Dispute Settlement Procedure Burden of Proof" paper focuses on the notion of Burden of Proof in the WTO Settlement Procedure.... When we look closer at the rules that define the World Trade Organization Dispute Settlement system, we may have the feeling that they are unclear.... The paper explains the notion of the Burden of Proof and explains who has to bear it in a dispute settlement.... his is the usual conduct of the dispute settlement procedure....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Dispute Settlement in the World Trade Organisation

"dispute settlement in the World Trade Organisation" paper argues that by bringing back an element of consultation and diplomacy the WTO may be able to pull in the alienated poorer countries while at the same time pulling apart the organization's most powerful members.... Yet many question the viability of the dispute settlement system of the WTO.... of the WTO Agreement states, "'The dispute settlement system of the WTO is a central element in providing security and predictability to the multilateral trading system....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

World Trade Organizations Dispute Settlement Mechanism

This thesis explains how developing countries have more power in the world trade organization's Dispute Settlement Mechanism and are influencing the developing countries.... WTO dispute settlement Understanding (DSU) is regarded as one of the central pillars of today's multilateral trading regime.... This paper will begin with the statement that the dispute settlement mechanism controls the trade conflicts between different member's countries and due to unequal distribution of influence between the developing and developed countries in multilateral trade negotiations and the changing of power relations over time....
11 Pages (2750 words) Thesis

Background of World Trade Organization

This paper "Background of world trade organization" focuses on the only legislative body after GATT that works between countries forming trade ties in order to help importers exporters, etc.... The world trade organization has approximately 153 member countries which represent more than ninety-seven per cent of the globe's trade networks.... There are over 30 countries which are seeking membership in the world trade organization.... The world trade organization is headed by the ministerial conference....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Standards for Reformulated and Convention Gasoline

On 20th May 1996, the newly formed world trade organization (WTO) Appellate body presided over its first case in which the Brazilian and Venezuelan governments had presented a case against environmental regulations presented by the American government, and more specifically the US Clean Air Act that dealt with the formulation of conventional gasoline.... The decision to coalesce the two panels was reached in accordance with Article 9 of the dispute settlement Understanding (DSU)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

WTO as a Dispute Settlement Body

The World Trade Organization Dispute Settlement system became such a mechanism.... The author of the paper "WTO as a dispute settlement Body" states that the development of trade worldwide led to the need for the establishment of a mechanism, which would resolve the disputes appear in the particular sector....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

Diverse Regulatory Approaches

he US, Canada, and Argentina challenged the EU's de facto moratorium before the world trade organization approving new agricultural biotechnology products.... The world trade organization created a dispute settlement panel to investigate the EU's moratorium – the demand of them for labeling all the GM products.... (Nicholas Perdikis, 2000) (7)The WTO dispute settlement panel in 2006 and hearing US claim and EU's defense ruled in favor of compliance and removed the bans that existed till then....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us