StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Imperialism from a Theoretical Perspective - Report Example

Cite this document
Summary
The report "Imperialism from a Theoretical Perspective" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in imperialism from a theoretical perspective. Though the term “Imperialism” was first used to refer to the expansionist policies of Napoleon I…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER99% of users find it useful
Imperialism from a Theoretical Perspective
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Imperialism from a Theoretical Perspective"

Critical Analysis of Imperialism from a Theoretical Perspective Introduction Though the term “Imperialism” was first usedto refer to the expansionist policies of Napoleon I, and is frequently associated with the colonial rule of the European states over other countries, ‘imperialism’ is as old as Empire is. Referring to its long history D. K. Lake says, “It is one of the oldest known political institutions, characterizing relations between peoples in ancient Mesopotamia, China, and Rome through modern Europe” (7232). While defining imperialism, scholars often are found to be blindfolded by its negative impacts. For an instance, Michael Parenti depends on the economic exploitations of imperialism as the basis of his definition, as he says, “By imperialism I mean the process whereby the dominant politico-economic interests of one nation expropriate for their own enrichment the land, labor, raw materials, and markets of another people” (24). Different Trends in the Definitions of Imperialism A true impartial tone about the core nature of imperialism is Lake’s definition, as he says, “Imperialism is a form of international hierarchy in which one political unit, or polity, effectively governs or controls another polity” (7232). Since Lake’s political perspective focuses on the core political aspect of imperialism, it, though implicitly, implicates other aspects also through the two terms “effectively governs or control” and “another polity”. The term “effective control” refers to suppressions in various economic and cultural forms because the dominant polity in imperialism cannot assimilate “another polity” within itself by obliterating the otherness and the distance that prevails between the dominant and the dominated. Lake refers to this failure of the imperialistic dominant to shed the otherness as a primary cause of suppression in the following quote: “Exploitation of the weak by the strong is not essential to imperialism, but it is an often natural outgrowth of effective domination. The affinity between domination and exploitation explains the typically pejorative status of the term.” (7232) In fact, the definition of imperialism is such that it cannot shed off its oppressive and repressive apparels. Difference between Imperialism and the First Stage of European Colonialism The existential basis of Imperialism essentially lies in the early European Colonialism. Though the overall concept of imperialism is different from early European colonialism, the underlying motif to rule the weaker people is existent at the core of these two forms of dominance. Indeed the later one is more associated with the political systems of ruling the people of an area than the colonialism is. Whereas imperialism depends on the systemic ruling to prolong the rule and maximize the output from it, colonialism tends to extract the benefits from an area irrespective of its welfare. This indifference to the wellbeing of the area as well as the people evolves from the mercantilist policies of the first stage of European Colonialism. Mercantilist policy of the early European colonialism was depended the search of resources that were intended to feed the growing need for raw materials of the newly emerging mills and factories during the industrial revolution. But during the increasing defeat of the British Colonial power in America and the growth of trade -among the existing colonialist European state and the colonies under their control- rendered a new twist on the old mercantilist policies of the early colonialism. Soon the direct exploitation of the areas and the nations took a more disguised form of power that was exercised through a systematic ruling. Shadow authority of the government of ruling countries replaced the economic interest groups in the colonies. Thus at the end of the first stage of colonialism, Imperialism strengthened its hold on their colonies. Through the whole history of Imperialism tends to disguise itself in subtler but more effective form of power in the face of increasing uprising and awareness of the people in their subjugated area. Industrial Revolution and the Emergence of Imperialism Industrial Revolution was one, but not the only, reason that provided the foundation of the Empires, as Fieldhouse says, “Modern empires were not artificially constructed economic machines. [it]…..was a complex historical process in which political, social and emotional forces in Europe and on the periphery were more influential than calculated imperialism” (281). During the later half of the 18th century, Industrial Revolution, both directly and indirectly, contributed to the rise of Imperialism. Being backed by the knowledge of science and the inventions of new technology, innumerous industries, mills and factories started to bloom all over Europe. Consequently the local resources ran short to feed these industries. Also due to the expansion of trade and commerce, the European countries needed to find new resources as well as new markets for the products. During the same period, technology based transport system contribute to the mobility of goods and people. Consequently the industry-based economy in industrialized Europe functioned as incentives to conquer the weaker nations and to capture their resources. The tendency of the industrialized countries behind capturing the overseas resources was to be the direct owner rather than paying for what they needed for their industries. It is widely accepted that Britain and France were the two colonial powers that initiated the imperial expansion and captures of the weaker countries by force. Elaborating the British interests in the imperialist expansion, Gareth Austin says, “Industrial-Revolution technology enabled British firms not only to take over the overseas markets….to make great inroads into the domestic markets of handicraft industries in Asia and Africa” (5). The technology-blessed military power also inspired to go into warfare with the weaker nations and subjugate them. Another factor that contributed to turn the colonial authorities into imperial power was the competition among the countries for strengthening hold on the world economy and market. One of the prerequisites to win the competition was prolong their rule through systematic and effective control. The emergence of Capitalism is considered as one of the crucial factors that contributed to the Imperialistic expansion of trade and business. In fact, capitalism itself is based on the idea of expansion, as Parenti says, “A central imperative of capitalism is expansion. Investors will not put their money into business ventures unless they can extract more than they invest…The capitalist ceaselessly searches for ways of making more money in order to make still more money. …Given its expansionist nature, capitalism has little inclination to stay home” (49). American, British and French Models of Imperialism The commonality among the American, British and French Imperialisms is that all these three were motivated by an intention to hold markets and to feed the demand for cheap labor. But American imperialism stands alone because of some of its dominants features that the British and the French imperialism lack. Along with the economic interests, a moral and civilizing tone underlies the American imperialism. That Christianity is “god’s chosen” path of life and it should be spread over the heathen nations motivated the American Frontiers during the later half of the 19th century. Regarding the moral tone of American Imperialism Michael Streich says, “As a “Christian” nation that saw itself as “God’s chosen,” many Americans viewed imperialism as a way of spreading the Christian Gospel to so-called “heathen nations.” This motive was a part of President William McKinley’s decision to keep the Philippines. The United States had a moral duty to uplift peoples in lands considered uncivilized”. (3) Indeed this moralizing motivation prevented the Frontiers of the 1890s from being mere economic plunderer and exploiter, and to differentiate themselves from other Imperialists along this line. In this sense, the American Empires emerged as an Expansionist power that was morally willing to assimilate the captured area within its own ruling body as well as to provide the dominants with the scope to decide about own wellbeing, though such American morals behind its expansionist view took time to be fully actualized. But the British as well as the French Imperialisms were devoid of any morality that motivated them to establish their empires on economic premises. This commercial perspective of the two empires perpetually contributed to the distance between the dominant and the dominated. Now though the age of British and French types of imperialism ended, a new era of economic imperialism has begun. Merits and Demerits of Imperialism Imperial rule in an area has both merits and demerits. But the merits are essentially the legacies of imperialism. An imperial state, even if it is not motivated by any moral zeal like some of the empires, would develop the infrastructures, such as buildings, roads, communications systems, etc in the captured areas. As well, in order to employ, cheap labor available in those areas the imperialist trained people to create skilled manpower. Thus the people receive both knowledge and infrastructural properties from the dominants. Also being in touch with the people of superior culture, the dominated culture is changed towards a better end. During the first half of the 20th century, the imperialists had an attempt to justify their imperialistic presence in different areas of the world. Such a trend for justification was a common characteristic of modern imperialists, Winston Churchill was found to justify the British Imperialism: “[The aim of British Empire is] to give peace to warring tribes, to administer justice where all was violence, to strike the chains off the slave, to draw the richness from the soil, to place the earliest seeds of commerce and learning” (Churchill 149). But there has always been a question as to whether these promises of an Empire are real or to what extent the Empire can adhere to these promises. But the negative impacts of imperialism on the subjugated area simply outweigh the positive ones. Torture, poverty, illiteracy, exploitation etc are often associated with imperial power (Hobson 39-47). Conclusion The term ‘Imperialism’ along with its historical connotation has been defined by different scholars in different ways, but the underlying commonality of the definitions refer to a form of domination of one political, socio-cultural and economic unit of geographical area over the others as one of the primary characteristics of imperialism. Necessarily the definitions of imperialism often include the cross-national implications of the dominations such economic, social, cultural and political implications. The connotation of ‘Imperialism’ is impregnated with the historical implications of the subjugation of various geographical areas by the powerful nations at different periods. Works Cited Austin, Gareth. “Economic Imperialism”, November 21, 2010. Available at Churchill, Winston. The River War. London: Kissinger Publishing. 2004 Fieldhouse, Michael. “The Myth of Economic Exploitation”, Historical problems of imperial Africa. (Eds. Robert O. Collins, James McDonald Burns). London: Markus Weiner. 1994. Hobson, A. John. Imperialism: A Study. London: Ben Pub.1902 Lake, D. Kelly. “Imperialism: Political Aspects”, International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences. 2001. 20 November, 2010. Available at Parenti, Michael. Against Empire. New York: City Light Books. 1995. Streich, Michael. “American Imperialism in the 1890s”, January 10, 2010. November 21, 2010. available at Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Imperialism Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Imperialism Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/politics/1572659-imperialism
(Imperialism Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Imperialism Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/politics/1572659-imperialism.
“Imperialism Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/politics/1572659-imperialism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Imperialism from a Theoretical Perspective

Three Theories of the Multinational Firm

Chapter 2 – theoretical Framework 2.... Capitalist economies tend to accumulate a large volume of resources at home which they are restricted from making use of at home due to restrictions imposed over their employment.... However, they also emphasize that the latter are usually the ones who are exploited by the former so that there is a continued outflow of surplus resources from the reserves of developing nations to the already burgeoning stock of the developed nations....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Policies and Practices of European Empires during New Imperialism

Some viewed imperialistic aspirations from a secular perspective, while some followed Darwinian concepts in upholding their biologically designed imperialistic fate.... hus, the working definition for imperialism from here on out is the combination of two previous definitions, which goes as follows: the policy, practice, or advocacy of extending the power and dominion of a nation over the political or economic life of others, which is supported and perhaps even impelled by impressive ideological formations that include notions that certain territories and people require and beseech domination, as well as forms of knowledge associated with domination....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Cultural Imperialism

Although the central postulate of cultural imperialism thesis remains valid due to the lopsidedness in the global media market, the so-called cultural imperialism through the Western cultural products cannot be seen as one sided as the theorists of cultural imperialism perspective understood it to be.... The core concern of the essay “Cultural Imperialism” is to examine what is remaining relevant with the arguments and concerns regarding cultural imperialism and the criticisms provided by the contesting theoretical doctrines from the vantage point of the tremendous transformations....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Marxism in General Implies Analysis of Social and Political Processes

First, I will outline the basic problems that are the center of the intra-paradigm debate in Marxism, from the Gramscian and Neo-Gramscian perspective.... Second, I will bring an example of how the theoretical debates within Marxism contribute to differentiation in the analysis of the contemporary international situation....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Imperialism and Racism in 19th Century

4Surprisingly, the western political theory managed to keep this white domination unnoticed on both theoretical and condemnation level.... Cocker seems to agree with the idea that today's modern world emerged from European expansionist settlements, colonialism and slavery in addition to the fundamental factor that shaped it, i.... Violence is used in order to eradicate any kind of opposition and ensure compliance from indigenous peoples.... The assignment "imperialism and Racism in 19th Century" describes the well-documented history of subjugation and annihilation of indigenous peoples by imperialist European nations....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

The Phenomenon of Hegemony

It derives from the word of Greek 'Hegemon' which means 'leader'.... On winning the intellectual war of position, socialist leaders would then have the necessary political power and popular support to begin the war of maneuver - the armed insurrection against capitalism (Ratna)For Imperialists, Hegemony has its own specific concept that is called cultural imperialism that is the domination of one culture over another by a deliberate policy or by economic or technological superiority....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

The Role of the Russo-Japanese War in Japanese Imperialism

The conflict with Russia was caused by imperialistic clash that developed from the competition of Japan and Russia over Korea and Manchuria.... This paper ''The Role of the Russo-Japanese War in Japanese imperialism'' tells that after the disorder that burdened Japan at the end of the Russo-Japanese War, the government began an extensive propagandism.... Several Japanese historians in the 1960s discussed the role of the Russo-Japanese War in Japanese imperialism....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Should Human Rights Be Understood as Universal Concepts, or Are They Culturally Relative

The essay will use this perspective in analyzing arguments criticizing universal human rights followed by a presentation of alternative conceptions of universal human rights and the identification of development, which will ensure their universal application and respect.... The western perspective of human rights and the incompatibility of its imposition is evidence that human rights cannot be applied universally (Freeman, 2011).... This argument derives its assertion from John Locke's understanding of the natural law which maintains that human rights are pre-political hence they are unaffected and immune to alterations necessitated by political or cultural variations....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us