StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Self-Determination as a Human Right - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Self-Determination as a Human Right" paper states that territorial integrity and state sovereignty combined not only help to attain self-governance but pave the way for due consideration of political aspirations of every group in the population and to aid in the development of state institutions. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Self-Determination as a Human Right
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Self-Determination as a Human Right"

Self-determination as a human right Human rights ‘Human rights’ is a term used to symbolize the protection of the individual and can be associated with ‘humanitarian’, although both are applicable under slightly different circumstances. While humanitarian law applies in the context of any armed conflict, human rights work towards the protection of the individual both in times of war and during peace. As such, the former is a way to restrict the suffering and damage caused by war and achieves this by monitoring and regulating the way in which military operations and objectives are achieved by the warring parties. Humanitarian law is therefore the law of war and its aftereffects whereby its goal is to limit the damage of war on people, poverty and the protection of the vulnerable elements in the event of a conflict. Modern states have largely been committed to human rights, and this is more prevalent in states under democratic rule. Democratic governments are bound by the pressure from the people to adhere to national laws and observe customary rules that are components of bilateral treaties. However, such limitations in scenarios of warfare have varied immensely throughout history and the only aspects that can be interpolated among all such conflicts are the place, time and the parties involved in it (Stephen Shute, 2006). The first recognizable humanitarian laws were created only in the 19th century that could be considered as internationally recognized. These laws initially looked to oversee the conduct of people involved in warfare and their treatment. During the middle of the 19th century, the founder of the Red Cross, Henri Durant, championed the first universal codification of humanitarian law, which is today known as the first of the four Geneva Conventions. During the course of a 100 odd years, humanitarian laws have evolved and come to encompass the proper treatment of an individual even during peace times or in isolated cases. It must also be understood that humanitarian laws were subject to constant review as the methods of warfare kept improvising and became much more deadly over time. The First World War was famous for the use of poisonous gases and prisoners of war. The Second World War witnessed the killing of both military personnel and civilians in similar numbers (Jack Donnelly, 2003). In 1945, the United Nations came into existence. Its charter clearly stipulates that threatening or using force against other states is illegal except in situations where there is an absolute need for self defense. The Geneva conventions of 1949 added further to the restrictions over the use of methods of warfare and catered to the protection of non combatants as well as prisoners of war. Humanitarian laws clearly outlaw any acts of ethnic cleansing, which is done with a view to eliminating a particular group (Hurst Hannum, 1996). This was necessary especially after the world had witnessed the horrors of the holocaust and the recent events in the Balkan republics. Self-Determination and Human rights Self determination encompasses every right of all peoples and is aimed at their development across the economic, social and cultural perspectives. The right to self determination is therefore a fundamental right of the people as well as international law. It is an integral part of the charter of the United Nations and several other conventions that focuses essentially on human rights. The inter-relation between individual rights and the rights applied collectively to people towards self determination are evident to those involved in such struggles towards achieving self-determination. In many of these cases, such abuses of human rights at an individual level are a symptom of a larger fundamental problem, which is most often the result of a conflict of interest over the adherence to self-determination. As such, such abuses cannot be ended unless the underlying cause is effectively dealt with (Robert Friedlander, 2005). Consider the case of the apartheid regime in South Africa, where human rights abuses were clearly based on the system in place that denied the majority black population of the country, a right to self determination. In the case of Tibet, the law enforcing authorities have been arresting, torturing and intimidating the local population due to their struggle for independence and their denouncing of occupation and oppressing at the hands of the governing powers. Although this interdependence may be evident in most of these cases, it is never always recognized, and the only voices that rise against any violation of human rights come from the affected and oppressed people. The United Nations professes the right to Self determination as a prerequisite for individuals to enjoy any other human rights. As such, differentiating between these two is highly artificial and does not serve any purpose. This interrelation is also clear from the practice of population transfer that has been going in places such as Tibet and Xinjiang, thereby violating human rights not only of the people transferred, but also of the people who have to clear out space to accommodate these newcomers (Malcolm Shaw, 2003). Such population transfers undermine the fundamental human right to self determination by manipulating the demographic balance of a territory as it dilutes the opportunities to the indigenous people and leads to conflicts as the one recently witnessed in Xinjiang. The rights of individuals and minorities are linked to the right to self determination in a number of ways. People highlighting the importance of the right to self determination must also recognize the same to other people even if they have to share the same set of opportunities and resources. this principle of equality in self determination for all people is necessary to protect the rights of minorities and is enshrined in the preamble of the United Nations. Similarly, the right of people to function as a separate entity required such an entity to respect the universality of human rights as also those of the individuals under their authority (Jack Donnelly, 2003). Territorial Integrity and State Sovereignty The recent years have witnessed several incidents and issues that have involved the conflict over certain regions or states. Consider the case of the conflict between China and the Tibetan government-in-exile. Both have been at loggerheads for over5 decades now and there is no end in sight to the conflict. Similarly, the recent war between Russia and Georgia over South Ossetia and Abkhazia involved a high involvement of the Americans. The declaration of Kosovo’s independence led it to be recognized by the United States and the EU countries, which was primarily a way to oppose the stand taken by Russia against such a move. Supporting Kosovo by the US has aggravated nationalist sentiments, which provided further ground to Russia to justify its ground assault against the Georgian government. All such incidents have constantly raised the issue of State Sovereignty and Territorial integrity, which are principles under international law that forbid sovereign nations from encouraging separatist movements of any form. Further state sovereignty requires countries to recognize the existence of other states and to prevent any move towards influencing any border changes in other states (Shutaro Tomimas, 2007). Territorial integrity and state sovereignty combined not only help towards attaining self governance, but also pave the way for due consideration of the political aspirations of every group within the population and to aid in the progressive development of state institutions. One of the problems in this case has been the lack of adjusting such governance to the local circumstances of the regions and their populations thus aggravating their right to self determination (Malcolm Shaw, 2003). A classic example of a situation where territorial integrity and state sovereignty collided can be witnessed from the Kosovo war. References 1. Stephen Shute (2006), On human rights. New York: Basic Books. 2. Jack Donnelly (2003), Universal human rights in theory and practice. Cornell University Press. 3. Hurst Hannum (1996), Autonomy, sovereignty, and self-determination: the accommodation of conflicting rights. University of Pennsylvania Press. 4. Robert Friedlander (2005), Self-determination: national, regional, and global dimensions. University of Virginia. 5. Malcolm Shaw (2003), International law. Cambridge University Press. 6. Shutaro Tomimas (2007), The open-door policy and the territorial integrity of China: with verses in Japanese. University of Michigan. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Self-Determination as a Human Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Self-Determination as a Human Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/politics/1727259-self-determination-as-a-human-right
(Self-Determination As a Human Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Self-Determination As a Human Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/politics/1727259-self-determination-as-a-human-right.
“Self-Determination As a Human Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/politics/1727259-self-determination-as-a-human-right.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Self-Determination as a Human Right

Indian Self Determination Act 1975

Indian Indian self-determination and Education Assistance Act 1975 Abstract Up until 1975, the philosophies governing US federal administration of Indian reserves in different periods oscillated widely between extremes of cultural suppression and assimilation ideology and bureaucratic paternalism.... hellip; The Indian self-determination and Education Assistance Act was designed to put in place a more productive system of governance.... This Act promised a more Indian driven approach of self-determination to enhance the stability and improvement of social and economic conditions for the Indian people....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

'Self-determination is irrelevant in the 21st Century'. Discuss

Name: Instructor: Course: Date: Self-determination is irrelevant in the 21st Century Self-determination, or as is formally referred to; 'the rights of nations to self-determination', refers to the legal right that is given to people that allows them to decide their own destiny in the international order.... hellip; That nations have the right to freely choose their sovereignty and international political status with no external influence or interference1 from foreign nations or bodies because of the innate right to equality and social freedom2....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Animals

This also means that while a human, being an “end in itself” ( 64 ) are not indebted to animals, kindness towards animals “will help develop good character in us and help us treat our fellow human beings with greater consideration” ( 63 ).... Kind treatment of the dog, especially one that has been faithful over time, in not necessarily a human being's duty towards the animal, but a human being's duty of “humanity which it is his duty to show towards mankind” ( 64 )....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior

The paper "Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in human Behavior" will begin with the statement that fear is one of the intrinsic factors that instigate the human motivation process.... This analogy, which was set forth by Roderick Wong, is said to explain the incidence of compulsions in human behavior.... 192) The theory that learning has something to do with human motivation falls in the realm of the behaviorist approach, which argues that motivation is a result of factors generated by the environment more than arising within an individual....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

The Principle of Equality That Peter Singer Defends in His Book

The French have already discovered that the blackness of the skin is no reason why a human being should be abandoned without redress to the caprice of a tormentor” (Singer, 1989).... It is the basic assumption of the current investigation that Singer's ideas about equality are much more rational, and much less radical, when they are employed to describe human beings; Some of Singer's theories about equality can therefore be challenged by logic, and not accepted, by people who, for example, see a difference between animals and humans, in terms of the equality applied and implied to them....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Impact of Motivation and Determination on Professional Sales

The paper "Impact of Motivation and Determination on Professional Sales" discusses how motivation, discipline, and determination applies to professional sales in light of the movie Pursuit of Happiness.... It also covers how these factors play their role in improving the individual performance.... hellip; The Pursuit of Happiness is one of the most motivation movies of all time....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Concept of Self Determination in International Law

elen Quane argues that the right to self-determination implicitly validates the right of certain ethnic groups to reject territorial regimes.... In support of her position, Jane cites several incidents of turmoil that resulted from the right of self-determination.... Since the UN Charter recognizes the right of ethnic groups to self-determination there are myriad problems for internal conflict.... Quane argues therefore that principles of self-determination in international law should only be applicable when questions concerning the abuse of human rights arise....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

The Use of Military Force by Yudonia and Zackstralia

UNO Declaration Friendly Relations in Shaw, 'International Law' (2008) 6th Edition, Chapters 20 and 22 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press and Brown-John, 'Self-Determination and Separation' in Options Politiques (Septembere 1997) at 40-43When a people are prevented from the exercise of self-determination, internal to a state, that people's right to secede is recognized in international law, to some degree.... Further, GA Resolution 1541 (XV) declares that a minority who are distinct culturally and ethnically may have a right to secede: only, however, if there is a clear constitutional denial of political, constitutional, cultural and religious rights....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us