StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces" will carry out a comparative analysis of two altarpieces created in the renaissance period: Fra Angelico’s The San Marco Altarpiece and Robert Campin’s The Merode Altarpiece, with emphasis on similarities and differences…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces"

Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces In art, a comparative analysis is the process that enables one to study in detail a piece of artwork by observing the application of elements, concepts, and ideas. Studying an artwork brings out contrast and correlation between two or more pieces to better understand its history and time of creation, the style in use, its function, the artistic period and so on. To guide one in comparing art pieces, it is important consider the formal elements, variety in lines, motion, use of space, texture, pattern, function, medium and every other aspect that has any effect on the particular piece. This essay will carry out a comparative analysis of two altarpieces created in the renaissance period: Fra Angelico’s The San Marco Altarpiece and Robert Campin’s The Merode Altarpiece, with emphasis on similarities and differences. The San Marco Altarpiece (Madonna and Saints) This piece is the work of early Italian renaissance artist, Fra Angelico. It is currently in Florence, France at the San Marco Museum. Its estimated time of creation is around 1438 to 1443. It is tempera on wood and is a panel artwork, with a main panel accompanied by nine other predella panels although only the main panel remains today. The main panel has an illustration of the enthroned virgin and child with saints and angels surrounding them. There is a curtained panel standing on two pillars overlapping a landscape with trees forming the background (Woods 204). The Merode Altarpiece (The Annunciation) Renaissance artist Robert Campin did this piece in the period 1427 to 1432 and it is currently in the Metropolitan Museum, USA. It oil on oak with three panels. It has a main (center) panel in between two smaller panels. The main panel shows the moment just before the annunciation of Mary. She is sitting on the floor reading a bible and is looking down. To her left is an angel she is not aware of, with an oval table separating them. A small figure of Jesus is flying towards Mary holding a crucifix. The right panel has Saint Joseph in a carpentry workshop where he is making mousetraps with a townscape appearing behind him in an open window. The right panel has two figures called the donors waiting to go inside an open door (Metropolitan Museum of Art). Similarities The scenarios appearing in both paintings depict religious themes. In The San Marco Altarpiece, there is Virgin Mary who is holding baby Jesus around saints and angels, which is a scenario in Christian beliefs. The same case applies in The Merode Altarpiece where the same Virgin Mary is in the same room with an angel and a perception of Jesus flying in. much of the iconography is therefore religious. On another note, both paintings are renaissance panel altarpieces that Italians made in the 1300’s to 1400’s. Altarpieces consist of wooden panels covered with cloth that is plastered with gesso paste to create a smooth painting surface (D'Elia 19). Both have several panels that make up a complete work under the same theme. Another similarity between the two is the exclusion of the crucifix with Christ on it from the main idea of the picture. According to Casa Santa Pia, the Dominican order of those days only allowed painted or sculpted crucifixes on altarpieces. In The San Marco Altarpiece, Angelico uses a special optical illusion to include the crucifix in the main picture but still it appears as a unique piece on top of the bigger painting. In The Merode Altarpiece, Campin uses an almost similar tactic. The crucifix is not easy to spot but it is in a miniature size above the angel’s head and appears as a small figure (representing Jesus) flying down towards Mary clutching onto a crucifix. There is also a similarity in the use of a single color to highlight subjects in both paintings. In The Merode Altarpiece, the highlight color is red. In the left panel, the color red attracts the eyes to reveal a tiny figure in the extreme background. In the main panel where the most red is, the eye concentrates on Mary’s robe as it is all red. Mary here is the main subject and the highlight lets one notice the bible, her pose, the table and angel beside her. There is also a bit of red on the angel’s wings, maybe to emphasize that this is not a human being. He uses same red on the descending crucifix such that one does not fail to notice it, and on Joseph’s cuffs, to bring out the action that he is doing. The same applies to The San Marco Altarpiece where orange is the highlight color throughout the painting. It is used on the saints, the virgin, the angels, the crucifix, and on the upper corners to include the curtains within the painting. In both paintings, the artists employ one-point perspective to create an illusion of continuity. In Angelico’s The San Marco Altarpiece, every object in the workspace has scale and place that recede as they go deeper into the work. From the foreground, the arrangement of saints is wide and progressively narrows until the eye gets to the centre of the piece where there is Mary and the baby who overlap the panel that covers the vanishing point (Levy 3). In The Merode Altarpiece, the one-point perspective is visible especially in the right panel with Joseph where in the open window; a linear townscape visibly recedes into the background. On the aspect of balance, the two pieces show similarities. The balance in use is symmetrical. Looking at the main panel of The San Marco Altarpiece, the symmetrical aspect is obvious due to the mirror effect that balances both sides. If the panel splits in half, the resulting halves will weigh equal. The same balance appears in Robert’s The Merode Altarpiece. If one draws a vertical line in the middle of the main panel, the table splits into two, Mary and the angel go to either side, the dark chimney on the right balances with the angel’s dark wings on the right, and the depression in the left background will balance with the open window to the right of the background. Differences One of the outstanding differences is the size, thus use of the two altarpieces. The Merode Altarpiece measures 64cm by 63cm. It was a private commission to Robert Campin. The commissioner commonly referred to as “donors” assumingly needed it for household prayer that in those days represented personal devotion (Kleiner 220). On the contrary, The San Marco Altarpiece is bigger in size, measuring 195cm by 158cm. The commissioner, Cosimo de Medic, intended it for a monastery’s beautification, therefore for aesthetic purposes in appealing to the visitors or congregation (Finnan). The San Marco Altarpiece is tempera on wood. The Merode Altarpiece is oil on oak. The renaissance age saw the preference of using oil over tempera owing to the many limitations tempera has. When using tempera for instance, an artist had to work fast because it dries out fast. The problem with drying out fast is potential inability to mix and acquire a color similar to the previous. This greatly affected the quality of work. Tempera also limited the style of achieving some important effects while painting. For instance, The Renaissance Connection states that the only way an artist could achieve three-dimensional forms was only by layering more and more tempera color over another to blend or shade. On the side of oil paints, the style of working depends on the artist’s preference. A good example is The Merode Altarpiece in which Robert Campin achieved the three-dimensional effect on a flat surface by foreshortening as is visible in the center panel of the piece; the beams on the ceiling recede into the background creating the perception of spatial depth. The use of different medium (tempera and oil), affects the overall appearance of the altarpieces. The tempera (The San Marco Altarpiece) displays less brightness, quality, and detailing. The difference might not be because of skill level but rather medium used. According to (renaissance), the extraordinary realism of oil colors was not discovered until the 15th century even though its use dates back to the 12th century. The new artists’ combination of realism, together with the easy of application by brush of oil paints, slow drying, and ease of blending opened a new chapter of realism. In addition, the oil in them makes the pigments translucent enabling the application of paint in thin glazes (superimposing) thus creating amazing effects such as the ability to express textures, sparkles, light, and glass effect. These qualities of oil paints gave Flemish artists like Campin the ability to represent objects with sharp, clear, and focused clarity, irrespective of their size (Barnet & Nancy 131). An example of their application appears on Mary and the angel’s robes that have a silky finish. Work Cited Barnet, Peter, and Nancy Y. Wu. The Cloisters: Medieval Art and Architecture. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2012. Print. Casa Santa Pia. Art in Tuscuny. Web. 7 Nov 2013. D'Elia, Una R. Painting in the Renaissance. St. Catharines, Ont: Crabtree Pub. Co, 2009. Print. Finnan, Vincent. Fra Angelico. The Patron of Catholic Artists. 2008. Web.7 Nov 2013. Kleiner, Fred S. Gardner's Art Through the Ages: A Global History. Boston, MA: Thomson, 2009. Print. Levy, Allison M. Re-membering Masculinity in Early Modern Florence: Widowed Bodies, Mourning and Portraiture. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2006. Print. The Metropolitan Museum of Art.2013. Web. 4 Nov 2013. The Renaissance Connection. Tempera versus oil paint. Web.7 Nov 2013. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1491069-comparative-analysis-of-altarpieces
(Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1491069-comparative-analysis-of-altarpieces.
“Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1491069-comparative-analysis-of-altarpieces.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces

Visual analysis of The Merode Altarpiece

The name itself also hints one on the purpose of the painting: Christian believers or cathedrals for devotional and aesthetic purposes commissioned altarpieces.... Visual rhetoric is a term under the broader visual literacy, which is a framework that describes how visual images can act as communication mediums....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Art of the Insane: The Purest Form of Art Expression

People have been enthralled with the insane, and accordingly, with their art, actually, since the daybreak of psychology as a justifiable field of research.... With time passing by, psychology has distinguished itself from physiology and other sciences, with the making of breakthroughs in the year workings of the mind, meticulously, with the development of the theory of the conscious as well as the sub-conscious as distinct pieces of the consciousness....
13 Pages (3250 words) Term Paper

Comparative Analysis

As comparative analysis of the Psychology of the Concerned August 24, Comparative Analysis Schizophrenia is mostly characterized by a severing of contact with the realities of life, usually addressed as psychosis (Butcher, 2002).... I believe that Alice is suffering from schizophrenia....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Portinari Altarpiece

This essay discusses a religious painting prepared by Hugo Van Der Goes.... The painting represents the Holy Family and Adoration of the Shepherds referencing the Biblical chronicle in Luke, is regarded as an influential piece in the 15th Century Christian art.... hellip; Tommaso Partinari, an Italian banker, commissioned the historic art piece for the church of the hospital of Santa Maria Novella located in Florence....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Jan Van Eyck's Ghent Altarpiece

It tells the story behind the creation of the masterpiece and gives a detailed analysis of “The Adoration of the Lamb” and “Annunciation”.... This assignment "Jan Van Eyck's Ghent Altarpiece" analyses a three-piece fresco painted in the Renaissance.... hellip; “The Adoration of the Lamb” and “Annunciation” are one of the most intriguing pieces of art to be painted....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Venetian Altarpieces 1460-1505

This paper “Venetian altarpieces 1460-1505” will examine the Venetian altarpieces in more detail, and will explain them altarpieces themselves in greater detail.... Included in this paper will be a special look at some of the great altarpieces of Giovanni Bellini, Vivarini, Giorgione, and Cima.... The altarpieces were often funded by the affluent Venetians, therefore the altarpieces, like the chapels that house them, were often meant as a celebration of the affluence and rank of these families....
14 Pages (3500 words) Literature review

To What Extent Does the Original Context of the Isenheim Altarpiece Explain Its Imagery

"To What Extent Does the Original Context of the Isenheim Altarpiece Explain Its Imagery" paper states that Isenheim Altarpiece was originally used for patients who needed physical healing but the original founders' goals were for the patients to accept death.... hellip; In the painting, Lucifer is a suffering angel, not the arrogant one who wanted to usurp God's throne....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article

Jan van Eyck's the Ghent Altarpiece

This document will analyze Jan and Hubert van Eyck's artwork in light of its significance.... This research will begin with the statement that Honour and Fleming argue that Ghent Altarpiece by Jan and Hubert van Eyck ranks among Europe's most significant piece of art… It is evidently clear from the discussion that produced in 1432, Ghent Altarpiece is housed in Belgium at Saint Bavo Cathedral where it is safely guarded to prevent the large altarpiece from being stolen or destroyed....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us