StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Working at McDonalds by Amitai Etzioni - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article “Working at McDonald’s by Amitai Etzioni" presents one of the perspectives on the issues surrounding the employment of young people. It argues that current employment is not preparing teenagers for adult work: it does not teach them skills and makes them rely on immediate rewards…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Working at McDonalds by Amitai Etzioni"

Some skills are learned in these workplaces, Etzioni claims, but they are often not a good example. Money earned in these jobs is spent by teens to support themselves, in poorer areas, or saved for a major item, but more often it is used to buy trend items, with little lasting value, according to Etzioni. He concludes the article by advising balance in activities for teenagers so that the desire to earn money does not prevent a well-rounded educational process.

Critical Response to the article “Working at McDonald’s” by Amitai Etzioni
Amitai Etzioni in the article “Working at McDonald’s” examines the phenomenon of teen employment in the United States. The writer’s central claim is that the kind of employment that is offered to teens, and their widespread joining of such employment, is becoming a problem due to the inappropriate nature of the jobs they are able to get.
At the outset, the writer acknowledges that very few scientific studies have been carried out to examine the nature of jobs at places such as fast-food outlets. This concession may strengthen the argument presented because it suggests that the writer is going to persuade the reader with a logical argument based on personal observations. A point of view is going to be proposed, for the audience to be convinced by. On the other hand, it may weaken the argument, in that not enough scientifically proven fact exists to strengthen what is being claimed.

The latter is true. This article presents an almost entirely personal point-of-view, and generalizations so wide that the reader would have to question even the most simple of Etzioni’s claims.

An important example of generalization is that there are more traditional teen jobs, which are much better for young people than current ones. The claim is that the traditional lemonade stands, which teach the value of entrepreneurship, and paper routes, to learn the skills of hard work and regular, good service fit into the American work ethic better than jobs currently(according to the writer). Not only is it a generalization to propose that every youngster in the past benefited from these “wholesome” jobs, but it is also an appeal to the emotions of Americans, generally, in that the writer presumes that everyone believes that the old way of life in the USA was better than the current one.
Other generalizations follow: that all teenagers with very few exceptions spend their money unwisely; that most fast-food outlets are poorly managed and do not allow for the employee to take initiative; that all teenagers’ school education is badly affected by part-time work.

Added to these sweeping statements, the writer also appeals to the reader’s emotions and exaggerates the actual conditions of work for teens. He uses negative terms such as “pot party” to describe these workplaces. Any parent would not be happy with the possibility that a child’s place of work could be described in this way.

Etzioni further proposes that the kind of work available to teenagers causes the continued poverty of sections of the American population: “…tend to perpetuate their disadvantaged status … no career ladders …” This is not only insulting to youths from more disadvantaged backgrounds but also feeds into a preconception that certain minorities in the USA are destined to remain poor. The stereotyping of such populations does not strengthen an argument.

This level of stereotyping of modern young people continues when the writer insists that most young people do not save the money they earn for anything worthwhile, nor do they support themselves: “… the youngsters live free at home …” Instead, the claim is that most of the money earned by most working teenagers is spent on nonsense. All or even most teenagers may or may not be obsessed with material goods of no value, and the general pattern of American life may or may not consist of “…trite … American consumerism …” – in both cases, the writer is allowing a purely personal perspective to surface. The argument used here is based on a subjective opinion, which the writer has not substantiated with any evidence, other than a superficial observation of American society.

It is only in the final paragraph of the article that the writer is able to present a less subjective viewpoint. The wording and structure of the last sentences indicate that the writer is presenting personal advice, perhaps valid as a suggestion based only on personal experience and perspective. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Working at McDonalds - the Kind of Employment Offered to Teens and Th Article, n.d.)
Working at McDonalds - the Kind of Employment Offered to Teens and Th Article. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1753479-summary-and-critical-response
(Working at McDonalds - the Kind of Employment Offered to Teens and Th Article)
Working at McDonalds - the Kind of Employment Offered to Teens and Th Article. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1753479-summary-and-critical-response.
“Working at McDonalds - the Kind of Employment Offered to Teens and Th Article”. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1753479-summary-and-critical-response.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Working at McDonalds by Amitai Etzioni

Argumentative paper

However, in the article Working at McDonald's, amitai etzioni decries the employment of teenagers at McDonald's and other fast food outlets, blaming them of stifling and regimenting nascent creativity, introducing the impressionable minds to the evils of consumerism, encouraging academic truancy, imparting flimsy and worthless skills and financially enabling the minors of indulging in illicit and harmful activities.... Name of the Student English Name of the Concerned Professor 22 September 2012 working at McDonald's- Response Paper It is a well known fact that America has been built on the foundations of hard work and tenacity....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Summary and Critical Response

Name Student identification Course Institution Date (all above optional – if you need them) Summary of the article “Working at McDonald's” by amitai etzioni In the article “Working at McDonald's” Amitai Etzioni argues that current employment is not preparing teenagers for adult work: it does not teach them skills, and makes them rely on immediate rewards.... (199 words) Critical Response to the article “Working at McDonald's” by amitai etzioni Amitai Etzioni in the article “”Working at McDonald's” examines the phenomenon of teen employment in the United States....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Working at McDonald's

In "Working at McDonald's," amitai etzioni argues that teen-agers working at McDonald's are more exposed to negative effects.... Name Instructor's Name Course Date “Working at McDonald's”: Summary and Critical Response Part 1: The Summary In "Working at McDonald's," amitai etzioni argues that teen-agers working at McDonald's are more exposed to negative effects.... The assertion that teen-agers render long days and hours working at fast-food chains cited the Charper and Frazer study which disclosed that more than 30 hours per week were rendered by a third of the employees or approximately 33%; 20%...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Analyses of Youths Working in Fast Food Industries

The essay "Analyses of Youths Working in Fast Food Industries" presents an overview of the article "Working at McDonald's" by amitai etzioni who emphasizes that there is little learning in terms of skills development taking place.... This essay analyzes the article "Working at McDonald's" by amitai etzioni where the author argues that this work is bad for kids due to the fact that it undermines their school attendance and involvement as they concentrate on part-time jobs to earn money....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Sumary and responses

Summary and Response In "Working at McDonald's," amitai etzioni argues that teens should not work for McDonalds because of the type of jobs that the teen-agers undertake at McDonald (Axelrod and Charles 281).... Ultimately, amitai etzioni reckons that the teens should establish a balance between their quest for earnings and the need to develop their careers.... amitai reckons that many students are now holding part-time paying jobs at fast-food chains especially at McDonald (Axelrod and Charles 281)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Summary/Critical Response

In the article “working at mcdonalds," the author critically mentions and argues that the recent trend of teenage working at various fast-food joints including McDonalds has more drawbacks compared to the benefits. ... tzioni support Article summary In the article “working at mcdonalds," the critically mentions and argues that the recent trend ofteenage working at various fast-food joints including McDonalds has more drawbacks compared to the benefits.... amitai etzioni's argument is that there various reasons why he dislikes this increasing trend among the teenagers: the work weakens school performance and general attendance, lacks extra skill for these youngsters to learn or that are practical in building their future career, and gives them a wrong mindset about money....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Working at McDonalds: Critical Response

 Working at McDonald's by amitai etzioni In “Working at McDonald's” Amitai Etzioni argues that holding a part-time job at McDonald's is bad for American High School students.... “working at mcdonalds.... amitai etzioni enjoys a highly reputed position as a social commentator, intellectual, writer and academician.... “amitai etzioni.... Although etzioni is a reputed writer whose arguments are well presented, he does not support his position with adequate research data and does not sufficiently emphasize that the number of hours of work is the major factor in this debate....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Summary & Critical Response

He attests that teenage working at mcdonalds deprives teenagers their quality time in school.... however, the long-term impact lies from the fact that the jobs do not teach students enough skills that would be essential in their later life; they encourage school absenteeism or minimize attendance; and concurrently affect the teenagers' values such as opinions concerning The paper "working at McDonald's by Etzioni Amitai" is a delightful example of an article on human resources....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us