StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Chinese-Made Toys at Mattel - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Chinese-Made Toys at Mattel" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues concerning Chinese-made toys at Mattel. The issue of toy quality and safety was not a significant concern to Mattel because, in the 1980s, Mattel's video games interests began generating large revenue losses…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Chinese-Made Toys at Mattel
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Chinese-Made Toys at Mattel"

(A1) In my opinion, the issue of toy quality and safety was not a significant concern to Mattel because at the moment, in the 1980s, Mattel “video games and other non-toy business interests began generating large revenue losses” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc.,174); the company was under pressure of bankruptcy, and enforcing strict quality controls was perhaps not as important as creating profits was. Secondly, as the article states, “problem with toys containing small loose magnets was the result of Mattel’sown flawed toy designs, and not due to any lack of adherence to manufacturing requirementsin China” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc., 177); from this, it is inferred that the toy quality/safety problem could be avoided if Mattel paid more attention to its product design sector to devise toys in a reliable and safe manner. Any toy quality/safety problems could be overcome by making manufacturing changes. The article also mentions that there was “lax regulatory enforcement,” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc., 179) in the factories that Mattel had set up in China, which often meant that“these laws were routinely ignored” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc., 179); problems of toy quality and safety could clearly be avoided if there was stricter control and supervision of product quality in these factories. Also, this problem of safety and quality could be eliminated if Mattel had developed its Global Manufacturing Principles before it had started a supply chain trading partnership with China, and ensured that the Chinese industries followed the rules and regulations of the GMP and terminating the partnership in case the Chinese did not follow the rules. (A2) Mattel made a number of positive responses to the toy recalls that largely had the impact of improving its public image and in winning back its good reputation. Firstly, its CEO Robert Eckert appeared in a video, in which he made a public apology for the defected and harmful toys Mattel had produced and also pledged to “change how we work in the future”(The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc,176). Mattel representatives in September 2007 even made clear to the American Congressional Committee that the defected toys were a result of Mattel’s “own flawed toy designs”; this then lead to Mattel making changes in its manufacturing process. Apart from this, Mattel also guaranteed to “increase the frequency of its paint inspections, testing every batch delivered” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc., 176). In 2007, it also put a check on its products that were being shipped out of its Asian factories in order to thoroughly examine them for quality and potential health hazards; this had the effect of preventing “more than two-thirds of the recalled toys from reaching consumers” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc,177).Lastly, Mattel set up a “Corporate Responsibility division, which had accountability internally and externally for adherence to company safety and compliance procedures” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc., 177). The effect of all these actions was that it restored the positive image of Mattel in the public eyes. (A3) The article includes coordination and collaboration with channel partners, which can be suppliers, intermediaries, third-party service providers and customers” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc., 179). Between Mattel and Early Light, there is a supply chain trading partnership that involves the two companies to work with one another when making decisions about manufacturing and distributing products. As the article states, the two companies have enjoyed this kind of collaboration for 15 years, and in my opinion, the two should continue to work together as supply chain trading partners since this entails a number of benefits. Firstly, the long amount of time (15 years) Mattel and Early Light have worked together in collaboration means that a high level of trust must have developed between the two. The article states that “When trust between trading partners exists, collaboration can occur,” and that “Trust and collaboration are seen as the two key requirements for buyer–supplier relationship success” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc., 181); Mattel should continue using Early Light as its supplier because of the high degree of collaboration and trust that exits between the two. Lastly, Kenichi Ohmae states that in today’s marketplace, with “dangerous opponents, it is best not to go it alone” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel, 181,181); collaboration is clearly beneficial in the way that it can provide support to its partners. In Mattel’s behavior with other foreign companies, I feel that it would be useful for Mattel to extend supply chain trading partnerships to different companies in different countries too; as the article states, these partners indulge in “sharing of information and the pooling of resources to achieve an objective,” and how this “improves operating efficiencies,” and “creates sustainable competitive advantage for the supply chain participants and better, cheaper products for the final consumers” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc,179) (A4) In my opinion, there is no need to add anything more to the GMP since it already contains all the principles needed to become a responsible and successful industry. There is a great need for industries to realize that there can be cultural differences between the culture they are from and from that of the country they are setting their factories up in, in order keep up a good public image. The GMP states that any other company that shares a supply chain partnership with Mattel will“protect the environment while respecting the cultural, ethnic and philosophical differences of the countries where Mattel operates (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc., 180).” As the article states, Mattel has been using the services of International Center for Corporate Accountability (ICCA), New York, to carry out audits and examine the events taking place in factories it controls, to see whether or not these factories are following the GMP or not. When Mattel was auditing its industries in China, it requested these industries’ managers to fill out papers on whether or not they were complying with the GNP, and also it carried out “an examination of the plant’s policies, procedures and practices with regard to the environment; employee health and safety issues; inspections of the general maintenance of the manufacturing facilities; storage, treatment and disposal of hazardous waste materials; hygiene issues; and dormitories and recreational facilities” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc,179). The result of all this auditing was to allow a report to be generated that could be forwarded to Mattel by the ICCA so that Mattel could take “corrective actions.” (A6) Nicholas A. Benvenuto in his paper on “Outsourcing—A Risk Management Perspective” claims that “Three-quarters of U.S. companies outsourced some or all of their information technology activities in 2004,”and he mentions three reasons for developing supply chain collaborations with other companies in other countries: “Cost or internal headcount needs to be reduced, internal capacity is constrained by increasing market demand, and internal manufacturing or service performance is insufficient or does not meet requirements.” Outsourcing or developing collaborations with other industries can help Mattel for example, to cut down on bearing heavy losses all by itself and enable it to access the resources of other industries. However, there is a negative side to outsourcing and looking towards other companies in other countries as potential supply chain trading partners. However, this outsourcing can be disadvantageous too. For instance, there is heavier reliance on suppliers; although this interdependence can be useful in the way that it allows division of labor and specialization to take place, sometimes a company can end up losing its own control over its activities. For example, many toy making industries in China that were working with Mattel were forced to shut down since “they could not afford the types of product testing Western buyers started requiring,” and “Foshan Dayi Toy Co. said their firm was raisingprices by 10 ten percent to cover the increased testing required by their customers, which included Mattel and Wal-Mart” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc., 182). Clearly, this interdependence that supply chain trading partnerships entails puts industries at disadvantage because it forces their actions to be directly dependent on those of its partner companies. Specifically for Mattel, an instance to illustrate how this interdependence plays out negatively is of how “Hong Li Da, a Chinese subcontractor used by Early Light, was required to use a Mattel-specified low-lead paint; however, it chose instead to use a less costly, higher lead-content paint from an unapproved supplier” (The Chinese-Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Inc,175). We can see here how Mattel had to suffer losses in millions because it had toys with dangerous levels of lead in them because of the paint that some Chinese subcontractors used, without its approval. Another risk is that the companies in distantly located areas may not even be following the rules and regulations that Mattel has lain down. The fact that the dangerously high levels of lead in Mattel toys had to do with “Chinese subcontractors (who) used unapproved paint,” just shows how difficult it can be for one industry to enforce its rules on a partner company that is geographically located very far away from it. Also, when an industry insists on keeping a close eye on the happenings inside its partner companies, there is the increased cost of hiring employees to act as managers and to keep a check on the situation. Work Cited Benvenuto, Nicholas A. "Outsourcing- A Risk Management Perspective." Http://www.isaca.org/. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 Apr. 2013. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Chinese Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
The Chinese Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/marketing/1476541-the-chinese-made-toy-recalls-at-mattel
(The Chinese Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
The Chinese Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/marketing/1476541-the-chinese-made-toy-recalls-at-mattel.
“The Chinese Made Toy Recalls at Mattel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/marketing/1476541-the-chinese-made-toy-recalls-at-mattel.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Chinese-Made Toys at Mattel

Case Analysis of Mattel's China Experience

Unit Four mattel Case Study Analysis Learner's Name: Kaplan University School of Business and Management MT460-02 Management Policy and Strategy Dr.... Following the launch, mattel transformed the toy commerce with the production of talking dolls and toys.... mattel went public in the year 1960 and almost immediately managed to feature among top five hundred largest U.... mattel introduced Hot Wheels in 1968.... mattel experienced massive recall of a variety of its products manufactured in and shipped from China in 2007....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

The Toy Manufacturing Industry: Mattel Inc and Branded Toys

This paper will analyze to what extent mattel Inc demonstrated its legal and ethical responsibility while responding to the issue.... mattel Inc, the global leader in the toy manufacturing industry, headquartered in El Segundo, California, recalled its millions of toys worldwide in 2007 so as to comply with the corporate and legal accountability.... mattel's branded toys include Barbie dolls, Fisher-Price toys, Hot Wheel Cars, etc.... Evidently, mattel acted in a responsible way by performing a series of product recalls in 2007....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Mattel and Toy Safety

In this paper, mattel's toy safety behaviors and its social responsibilities are going to be addressed in light of the crisis faced by the company due to the product recall.... mattel produced 65 percent toys in China.... For the cost minimization perspective, mattel delivers its most of the demands through the manufacturing head present in China but owing to the corruption of a few subcontractors in China it created a major obstacle for the company in terms of its goodwill by a considerable extent....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Marketing in the Developing Economy of Country

The price of the toys at the beginning must be lower than the prices set by the potential rivals in the market.... toys played by the children are luxury goods in nature.... Thus a newly entering business of toys in the Chinese market should strategically plan its packaging, advertising and promotion in the market.... When it comes to packaging the company must make ecological friendly packages for the toys.... The company in order to promote the sales of the toys must keep the provision of product trials....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Mattel's China experience

mattel's China Experience: A Crisis in Toyland 1.... How did mattel's detailed code of conduct fail to detect vendors who used lead paint?... Although mattel's detailed code of conduct was designed to detect vendors who use lead paint, in this instance it did not because it did not have control over the entire process.... mattel made more than half of its toys in China, and the company did this through a combination of company-run plants and a network of contract manufacturers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Mattel Organizational Crisis - Communication Strategies Used

mattel attributed most of the recalls to high percentage of lead pain contained in Chinese-manufactured toys.... The Wall Street Journal (2007) notes that previous to the recall, mattel was the biggest toy manufacturer reputed for its strict safety standards.... This paper examines mattel crisis, the paper will specifically examine how the crisis happened, corporate communication of crisis, crisis management and give conclusion.... The combination of magnet strength with poor design of mattel toys made these toys dangerous to the health...
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Mattels China Experience: a Crisis in Toyland

This essay analyses mattel's attention to maintaining the reputation of its brands through the implementation of standards has in a way backfired as the company has found itself in a precarious position.... mattel also developed and introduced its Global Manufacturing Principles all around the world.... Despite mattel's passion for implementing standards to ensure that the reputation of its brand remains intact, it was faced with a major problem which cost the company approximately $40mn....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Mattels's Chines Sourcing Crisis of 2007

The author examines mattel's Chinese Sourcing Crisis of 2007 and identifies whether is lead paint on toys or defective sliding sides on baby cribs, whose responsibility it is to assure safety – the company, like mattel, or the country, in this case, China.... mattel's global sourcing in China, like all other toy manufacturers, was based on both low-cost manufacturing, low-cost labor, and a growing critical mass of factories competitively vying for a contract manufacturing business....
20 Pages (5000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us