StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Nature of Justice in the Soul and State - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Professor Course Date Philosophy 1. Nature of Justice in the Soul and State Socrates view justice as ‘one of the cardinal human virtues’ or states of the soul. Based on the Plato’s Republic, three parts comprise the soul namely reason, spirit and appetite…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful
Nature of Justice in the Soul and State
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Nature of Justice in the Soul and State"

Download file to see previous pages

On a personal view, the definition of justice can be logical based on the fact that the three components of the soul can greatly affect the concept of justice. There is only one question in terms of the fact that reason, spirit and appetite can be considered as subjective or personal. This had been answered in the view that the soul is the microcosm of the state. Due to the fact that soul is hard to analyze, the corresponding events in the state can be studied to be able to understand the soul (Republic 436b8–9).

With this analogy, it had been considered that by managing the state well, the soul can achieve happiness. For example, the part of the soul, reason is mainly interested in knowledge. In the state, reason corresponds to philosophers who have the virtue of wisdom. Honor is the main interest of the spirit and is possessed by the warriors who have the virtue of courage. Desire, which is the third component of the soul, can be equated to the commoners since the main interest is to achieve pleasures.

They have the virtue of temperance (Republic 415a-433e). Looking through the different virtues, justice cannot be found. The main view of Plato is that justice can be found in all of the classes in the society, although each one may have different perception of the concept. In the dialogue, different individuals gave their opinions which all had logical points. Cephalus said that justice is about telling the truth and repaying debts, but Socrates pointed out that it can be true but not at all times or situations (Republic 331c).

Polemarchus on the other had said that justice is “giving to each what is owed” but Socrates pointed out that this can alienate the people who had done crimes which can lead to more crimes or wrong doings (Republic 335d). Every speaker in the dialogue had a point specifically Socrates. The other speakers were concerned about the application of the definition of justice to their own field but Socrates was able to present the different sides on a general term. The bottom line in the view of justice, based on the reading then, is that justice does not consider sides, perspectives, virtues, or other elements in the social structure that people deemed important.

The main reason for this is impartiality. Plato is right soul and state are the main ground where the rules of justice will be applied. In this case, it is subjective to begin with. There is never an absolute right or an absolute wrong. The view that Plato perceived justice to be in all the classes and all the components of the soul is his own version of impartiality. No matter how he deemed that the philosophers’ roles in the society are the most important in all classes, he still believed that justice can be achieved by the commoners. 2. Characteristics of a Good Citizen and the Possibility of Utopian State There are different definitions of the term citizen depending on the philosophers or the context.

Based on Plato’s view in the Republic, a good citizen participates and contributes to the achievement of the goals of the state. He expressed in his work that the people who participates in governance are the citizen. For the Utopian society, he citizens are the philosophers, while the others are the people being led and ruled over. Plato’s philosophy on good citizen and even the existence of people revolve around the political concepts (Republic 415a-433e). Thoreau described good citizens as active people with goals

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Nature of Justice in the Soul and State Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1426302-1-the-nature-of-justicein-the-soul-and-the-state-2-the-characteristics-of-a-good-cittzen-and-the-possibility-of-a-utopian-sta
(Nature of Justice in the Soul and State Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1426302-1-the-nature-of-justicein-the-soul-and-the-state-2-the-characteristics-of-a-good-cittzen-and-the-possibility-of-a-utopian-sta.
“Nature of Justice in the Soul and State Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1426302-1-the-nature-of-justicein-the-soul-and-the-state-2-the-characteristics-of-a-good-cittzen-and-the-possibility-of-a-utopian-sta.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Nature of Justice in the Soul and State

Plato's Reply to Glaucon's First Objection that Justice Is No More than a Compromise

That can only occur in the soul when each part has and does its own - when reason rules and the other parts are subdued.... However, order in the soul is exactly like order in the State – and it is justice.... the soul is a complex entity.... Thus, as the health of the body, intrinsically desirable, is physical order, so the health of the soul is psychic harmony - and that is happiness.... hellip; It is difficult to define justice in few words because of the different perceptions and understandings associated with justice by different people....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Plato's theory of justice

Plato asserts that justice is the excellence of the soul, where man alienates unreasonable longing to explore on the pleasures of the world and satisfaction of self-interest pleasure from anything they handle and are comfortable with their way of life.... PLATO'S THEORY of justice Name Professor Course Date Introduction Plato's philosophy uses a famous area to emphasize on the issue of justice.... Cephalus, a diplomat of traditional integrity of the early trading category, founded the traditional theory of justice....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Socrates Defense of Athenian Law

hellip; Because he openly admitted the purpose and nature of his lifetime activities, Socrates' case would appear to be based on a matter of interpretation instead of fact.... Socrates stated that his teaching, contrary to corrupting the morals of the youth, had made Athens become a better state.... This shows just how much he believed that the Athenian legal system was the foundation of the Athenian city-state to be valued.... The city of Athene's tribunal sat to bestow justice by the city's regulations....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Platos the Republic: Justice

All the parts of the soul and that of the state take up their respective duties for the betterment of the whole.... Plato gives the example of the universe generating gold, silver, and bronze where naturally the golden individuals are suitable for ruling, the silver are the guardians, while bronze are meant to work; in addition, Plato feels that justice is achieved when there is harmony and agreement in the soul or the state.... It is evident that the soul is subdivided into three unique portions, which include the appetitive, spirited, and the rational....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Significance Of Hamlets Ghost Scenes

Additionally, these deceitful and false mediators continually seek to separate us from profits of soul and at the same time showing total disregard for God.... Demons could actually be the damned ones and may create apparitions of a soul that is damned in order to torment imagination....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Justice in Greek Philosophy

The immense dialogue in the Republic is opened by questioning the nature of justice.... Plato, one of the Greek's ancient philosophers, ideally believed that sense-gained knowledge remains impure and confused and that only the soul that contemplates and turns away from thinking carnally can receive true knowledge.... He also believed that only the soul can know the real essences of things, acquire knowledge of forms since the world as seen by the eye is nothing short of an imperfect copy (Bakalis, 2005)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

What is social justice

He described the mind as a soul or mental substance.... It involves finding out what these subjects are as well as their importance (Gao, 12).... This type of philosophy tries to discover what makes a government legitimate, the rights and freedoms it… It refers to a general view, political belief or attitude that does not belong to the technical discipline of philosophy (Gao, 13). The philosophy of body and mind explains the relationship between our mental states, events and process with the physical states, These states, events and processes include our actions, beliefs and thinking (Gao, 96)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Justice Defined by Plato

Plato has given much prominence to the idea of justice in all his works.... He also discussed other facets of life like the immortality of the soul in his book "Phaedo".... hellip; He worked towards propagating equality and true justice in his famous work “Gorgias”.... According to Plato, the absence of a fair form of justice for all led to the ruin of the Athenian democracy.... Plato's theory of justice encompassed the fact that justice is the only remedy available for curing the evils like individualism and meddlesomeness which destroy the essence and fair practices for society....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us