StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Analyze both stories. Is the author's suggestions a good solution to solving a problem - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Subject Professor Date Infanticide: An Ethical or Unethical Euthanasia? Introduction If people like Jhamak Ghimire, Helen Keller, John Nash, Thomas Edison, George Washington, Tom Cruise, Walt Disney, Woodrow Wilson, and Bill Gates had been victims of infanticide due to their disabilities since birth, the world would have fewer names of inspiration…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
Analyze both stories. Is the authors suggestions a good solution to solving a problem
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analyze both stories. Is the author's suggestions a good solution to solving a problem"

Download file to see previous pages

On the other hand, the Houyhnhnms see themselves as superior to the Yahoos because they are more rational, thus giving the former the right to have power over the latter’s life and death (Lemke, Martin, Fuentes, and Swift 47). Justifying Infanticide depicts how Singer sees himself as a rational Houyhnhnm who should have a power to decide over the life and death of those considered non-humans, or those who are not yet humans. However, Swift’s aim is to make people realize that humans are indeed Yahoos with pure genetic composition and the propensity towards sensual pleasures, but are also Houyhnhnms with rational thinking and the propensity towards oversimplifications and ideas.

In Justifying Infanticide, Singer separated these two --- intelligence and incarnation --- by referring to newborns not as persons, but merely pain-receptors having no psychological association to its future personhood (33). Therefore, if one follows this line of reasoning, newborns are Yahoos whose life and death are under the decision of the superior Houyhnhnms. A Modest Proposal is entirely different since it is a satirical exaggeration that states selling the children as food to rich people may alleviate the poor parents’ economic situation (Swift 13).

Justifying Infanticide Justifying Infanticide has a utilitarian root that reinforces the concept of “doing the greatest good for the greatest number.” It says that a deed is made moral if the end justifies the means. In line with this thought, Singer theorizes that eliminating a certain percentage of the population is acceptable if justified by the situation or the result it offers (34-5). According to the utilitarian point of view, objections from people who perceive that killing a person is morally incorrect are mostly based on emotions.

Utilitarianism asserts the belief that reason should be the main basis of ethics, so it means that infanticide can be justified by reason in some cases, thus be deemed ethical (Sloane 47-8). For a clearer definition of terms, infanticide is the intentional killing of an infant for reasons ranging from partiality to a specific gender to control of population (Vehmas 38). Utilitarian Peter Singer provides the most controversial defense of infanticide. For example, Singer states that the costs to families and societies and the quality of life in caring for children with specific disabilities entail more effort but provides less positive results (35).

This may be a controversial stance, but on a realistic viewpoint, the child will live a life that is considered unhappy or unwanted by most people. This is one case where infanticide is considered humane (Sloane 48). One great difficulty, however, is in deciding when this is justifiable because there is always the argument that no one can really say when a certain life is undesirable other than that very person. However, one strong defense of infanticide in the utilitarian standpoint is the argument against the suffering infant whose medical case is beyond the scientific capacity to cure (Vehmas 39).

For Singer, it is more altruistic to allow parents to choose to end their and their child’s suffering through euthanasia (36). A Modest Proposal The lack of compassion towards the poverty-stricken citizens is the target of Swift’

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analyze both stories. Is the author's suggestions a good solution to Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1412708-analyze-both-stories-is-the-author-s-suggestions-a
(Analyze Both Stories. Is the author'S Suggestions a Good Solution to Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1412708-analyze-both-stories-is-the-author-s-suggestions-a.
“Analyze Both Stories. Is the author'S Suggestions a Good Solution to Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1412708-analyze-both-stories-is-the-author-s-suggestions-a.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analyze both stories. Is the author's suggestions a good solution to solving a problem

Different Methodologies of Learning and Their Relationship with the Process of Conceptualisation of Learning

The authors have argued that it is possible to implement both approaches of learning at the same time and in the same place.... The paper "Different Methodologies of Learning and Their Relationship with the Process of Conceptualisation of Learning" states that evolutions of methodologies are also needed to be discussed and duly examined....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Leadership and Organizational Culture

This research paper, Leadership and Organizational Culture, stresses that the main problem faced by the employees is the different leadership styles adopted by different Chief Executives in the organization in the health department of NHS Acute Trust.... hellip; According to the paper the employees are the persons who realize the changes that are taking place within the organization and they are the only people who are capable to measure the effectiveness of superiors in managing the overall performance in their organization....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

How does mediation prevent, manage, and resolve international conflict

International stability is always at stake owing to these conflicts that do not have a solution to them and where none of the disputants are willing to compromise to reach a settlement.... It's very difficult to find a solution to such intractable disputes since they go on for a long period with negotiations almost impossible.... The role of the mediator is to facilitate and assist the parties in working out what the real issues of dispute are, allowing communication between them and other things that meet the interest of the parties by finding a solution to their dispute....
80 Pages (20000 words) Thesis

Strategy Management of Tawam Hospital

Recently acquired by John Hopkins and striving to maintain accreditation standards, Tawam Hospital is focusing on strategic change… ent goals in the area of “service effort indicators, service accomplishment indicators, efficiency indicators, and explanatory information” (Oldroyd, 2005)....
50 Pages (12500 words) Essay

The Importance of Implementing an Enterprise Resource Planning System

The paper "The Importance of Implementing an Enterprise Resource Planning System" states that the use of ERP techniques presents certain limited shortcomings.... The main shortcomings of the ERP packages are the high costs associated with the implementation of the packages.... hellip; The study conducted shows the various issues related to organizational communication....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Proposal

The relationship between play and creativity

Evolutionary theorists argue that pretend play prepare children for necessary adult activities; they claim that pretend play offers unique opportunity for children to practice with the skills of problem... both pretend play and elaborated role play stimulate divergent thinking and imagination among children which in turn develop their creativity.... reativity researchers identify that both creativity and pretend play are characterized by cognitive abilities, the ability to create a variety of ideas, divergent thinking, broad associative skills, insight, cognitive flexibility, and perspective taking (Russ & Wallace, 2013, p....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Finding Possible Resolution Measures in the Central Africa Republic

hellip; The Central Africa Republic (CAR) is one such country that has experienced this state of ethnic conflict for a good number of years now.... The suggestions for the use of conflict resolution mechanisms come from the fact that conflict resolution emphasizes reconciliation and mediation, which are important tools that satisfy the unique dynamics of ethnic conflicts....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Moral Panic and Young People Behaviour

ouths are both regarded as a risk as well as the source of risk in many moral waves of panic.... This literature review "Moral Panic and Young People Behaviour" discusses an incident that makes excellent content for news media.... Sometimes, these contents include the opinions of experts despite some media consulting the opinions of individuals who have very little expertise....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us