StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Environmentalists cannot be animal liberationists - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Many people think that the environmental activists and animal rights activists are same. They perceive that both environmental activists and the animal rights activists are involved in similar social and environmental welfare activities to achieve a single goal. In short, it can be said that their purpose of work is same. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Environmentalists cannot be animal liberationists
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Environmentalists cannot be animal liberationists"

Paper Introduction Many people think that the environmental activists and animal rights activists are same. They perceive that both environmental activists and the animal rights activists are involved in similar social and environmental welfare activities to achieve a single goal. In short, it can be said that their purpose of work is same. Here, it needs to be mentioned that above assumption of common people is true to a certain extent as both the environmental activists and the animal rights activists act to maintain the ecological balance of the planet to ensure environment friendly world with a proper ecosystem.

However, here it needs to be mentioned that there have been certain different arguments that seems to differentiate between the environmental activists with the animal rights activists. Environmentalists cannot be animal liberationists. Animal liberationists cannot be environmentalists Although various people believe that both animal rights activists and the environmental activists belong to the same class. Author Gary Varner actually spoke with Mark Sagoff mentioning the belief that the animal rights activists cannot be environmental activists.

As a matter of fact this is a statement that has been made by various authors. According to the authors, it is very hard to mess these two groups into a larger group. Varner also stated that among the environmental philosophers there is a tendency to compare the environmental ethics and the animal rights. This is usually done by differentiating the specific views in the ethical theories or the specific accounts of the views that might imply to discussion (Varner 98). The environmental philosophers on the other hand cannot come into an agreement over the fact that the theoretical foundations as well as the practical applications of the animal rights view are quite inconsistent with the people belonging to the discipline of the environmentalism.

Varner also provided evidence that the two groups look at themselves as two different groups, hence the people around should also look to do the same. Varner also said that Bryan Norton believed that both the groups of animal rights activists and the environmental activists should help each other because both the values and systems of the groups point towards the common objective of protecting the ecological balance. The topic became interesting after going through an article regarding billboards that PETA had positioned in Canada.

The billboard actually said ‘Eat the Whales’. This was actually targeted towards the environmentalists that were protesting against the hunting of whales. According to Sagoff, animals have rights in not suffering just like the humans. According the animal rights activists the nature undermines the rights of the animals by killing the animal in far larger numbers than human beings do. The nature visits the animals with suffering that exceeds the sufferings of the animals in the hands of the humans.

Therefore, to protect the rights and interests of the animals the animal activists should be committed to get the animals out of the wild. In simple terms Sagoff wanted to differentiate between the animal rights activists and the environmentalists. According to Sagoff the animal rights activists look to maintain animal equality and animal rights. The moral standing of the activists is only for the higher animals. There is presence of individualism and anti hunting. On the other hand the environmental activists actually believe in the ecological integrity.

The ecological or environmental ethics stands for the respect for the overall functioning of the natural systems. The moral standings of the environmental activists focus on the animals, plants, ecosystems and the Earth itself. Another major difference between the animal activists and the environmental activists is the fact, that the animal activists actually feel that, predation is not a good thing for the animal rights. Whereas the environmental activists feel that predation is god as it helps in maintaining the ecological balance and it is needed to protect the predators and if needed reintroduce them.

Conclusion From the detailed discussion above, it can be concluded that the animal rights activists actually believe that the activists are morally compelled to prevent predation. But such proposals actually are anti environmentalist. This sacrifices integrity, authenticity and the wildness of the whole ecosystem. Hence, it can be said that the environmental activists cannot consistently be known as the environmentalists, Add to this the policy of recommendations that follow from the theories of the animal activists are quite strange and tends to contradict with that of the bigger picture itself, i.e. the ecological balance.

Work Cited Varner, Gary. In Natures Interests? Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Environmentalists cannot be animal liberationists Essay”, n.d.)
Environmentalists cannot be animal liberationists Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1622451-environmentalists-cannot-be-animal-liberationists
(Environmentalists Cannot Be Animal Liberationists Essay)
Environmentalists Cannot Be Animal Liberationists Essay. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1622451-environmentalists-cannot-be-animal-liberationists.
“Environmentalists Cannot Be Animal Liberationists Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1622451-environmentalists-cannot-be-animal-liberationists.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Environmentalists cannot be animal liberationists

The Community of Passionate Environmentalists

The author of the paper "The Community of Passionate environmentalists" although he is not a professional environmentalist, yet he is very much of a practical environmentalist.... hellip; The author of the paper says that he belongs to the community of passionate "environmentalists".... nbsp;The author of the paper discusses these topics so much that people have started to identify him with environmentalists....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Environmentalism as Religion

The paper "Environmentalism as Religion" highlights that I always make sure that I drop garbage in the designated places wherever I go.... Use of garbage bins has a plus for me since they improve my organization style as well as ensure that garbage is assessable from one place.... hellip; Garbage disposal is another issue that an environmentalist would think of....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Environmentalism as Religion

hellip; To achieve the mission, environmentalists form economic and social organizations that fight for environmental protection through the assessment of human activities that are harmful to the environment.... To achieve their mission, environmentalists form economic, political, and social organizations that fight for environmental protection through the assessment of human activities that are harmful to the environment.... However, environmentalists claim that their acts are driven by values and there are guidelines on how to maintain all values attached to the environment....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

You can make a topic

This therefore supports the view that humanitarian ethics (appreciation of animal welfare) will always contradict environmental welfare (Sagaff, 43).... orks citedSagaff, Mark, “animal Liberation and Environmental Ethics: Bad Marriage, Quick Divorce” animal liberation and the land ethic.... he contradiction arises while the environmentalists and conservationists concentrated efforts in ecological issues unlike expressing their interests in humanitarian issues....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Reading response

This, the author says is one of the reasons why environmentalism principle cannot be fully implemented.... He indicates that animal liberators cannot be environmentalist and the environmentalist cannot be liberators.... Due to these complexities, the two principles cannot be used to solve animal and environmental issues.... In order to explore the issue of land ethics and animal liberation, Sagoff explores various views of various animal and environmental liberators (1)....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

The Rights of the Nonhuman World by Mary Anne Warren

Both land ethic environmentalists and animal liberationists deny a homocentric view on moral rights.... Land ethical environmentalists neglect a difference of “logical foundation” when discussing moral rights of nonsentient and sentient natural entities, while animal liberationists don't see how different is content and strength of human and animals' moral capacities (Warren 608).... The same thing is with a moral right on life: animal don't suffer morally from ruined hopes, or long term plans, while humans do....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

"The Rights of the Nonhuman World" by Mary Anne Warren

ow do the perspectives of "land-ethic" environmentalists and of animal liberationists complement each other?... he perspectives of land-ethic environmentalists and animal liberationists complement each other in the sense that they advocate for the rights on the nonhuman beings....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Deep Ecology and Shallow Environmentalism Environmental Philosophies

hellip; Shallow environmentalists argue on the need to protect the environment if this will serve humanity or will be for the advantage of human beings.... nbsp; Both the deep ecology and the shallow environmentalism environmental philosophies have shaped the efforts and perceptions of environmentalists towards the protection of nature....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us