StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Difference Between Modern And Medieval States - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Difference Between Modern And Medieval States" describes the process of consolidation of states that started in the seventeenth and eighteenth century in Europe resulted in changing the geographical boundaries of nations through the process of annexation…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
The Difference Between Modern And Medieval States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Difference Between Modern And Medieval States"

Discuss the process of consolidation of modern s in Europe? What is the difference between modern and medieval s? What political systems have emerged in the process and why? What were their advantages and disadvantages? Use specific examples The process of consolidation of states that started in the seventeenth and eighteenth century in Europe resulted in changing the geographical boundaries of nations through the process of annexation, resulting in the emergence of a new political system in the newly formed states. The small states of the continent got consolidated into the larger ones with the dismissal of the geographical boundaries through the process. The process was characterized by political unification as the political governments of the states got unified from the previous stage of fragmented governmental frameworks. The last years of the nineteenth century marked the zenith of the process of consolidation (Anderson, O’Dowd and Wilson, 2003, p15). The political as well as the practical lives of the Europeans had been transformed by the rise of the centralized states. During the period of the fifteenth century the continent had more than dozens of political units of different sizes ranging from the tiny state of Italy to the larger one of the Grand Duchy of Lithuania. The trend of the existence of different political units of different sizes in the eighteenth century Europe ultimately resulted in the formation of larger political units, larger than the large political units that were already present. The boundaries of the states of England, Netherlands, France along with Spain and Portugal hardened their boundaries through the process of absorbing the kingdoms of smaller peripherals within their boundaries. In the process the states of Scotland and Ireland got integrated within the larger political state of England. The Basque kingdom of Navarre was absorbed within the periphery of Spain. France followed the trend of annexation of territories along with the German, Italian, Breton, Flemish and the Provencal speaking population. A different practice has been undertaken in the process of consolidation on the east Central part of the continent. The great empire of Ottoman advanced, conquering the maximum parts of the Balkans and certain parts of the kingdom of Hungary. The monarchy of Habsburg conquered the Crown lands of Hungary throughout the seventeenth and the eighteenth century. Sovereignty over certain parts of the states of Serbia, Transylvania along with Hungary and Croatia was transferred to Habsburgs by the Long Turkish war as named by the natives of Austria. The consolidation in the far northern part continued with the creation of the Commonwealth of Many Nations by the natives of the states of Lithuania and Poland, known as the Union of Lublin. The state was formed on the basis of institutions of layered representatives those shared their powers with that of the king or the ruler. The Union of Lublin was the state totally dominating the region till the end of the seventeenth century. However in the eighteenth century there were the emergence of two new powers, namely, Russia and Prussia. The fall of the Swedish monarchy in the end of the seventeenth century marked the emergence of a region economically dominated and politically structured by the Dutch in the Baltic region. Thus this consolidation process that continued throughout the seventeenth and the eighteenth century in Europe resulted in the formation of state organizations of new and different forms along with the emergence of different institutions and systems of functions. (Collins and Taylor, 2006, pp 299- 300) The medieval state has the form of authority that relies more on the claims of the personal authority than that of the territorial ones. It is important to understand therefore, that the feudal state was patrimonial in nature. The empire was basically the ancestral property of the concerned dynasty. Hence the modern notion of accountability of the kings to the state and the subjects was not a feature of the old feudal system. Bonds of loyalty between the vassal and the lord organized around the feudal order resemble the features of a medieval state. Certain puzzles of the behavior of medieval states can be solved considering the personal organization of the state authority of the medieval period.  Viewing the medieval state authorities as territorial often results in inexplicability of the puzzles.  The European states of the medieval period, namely, Medieval France, England, the early Roman Empire are all examples of medieval states. (Gayton, 1996 p. 2) Along with certain reliance on personal authority the modern state also relies in part on territorial authority. The states formed through the process of consolidation are examples of modern states like the modern Rome along with the consolidated states of France, England etc. (Gayton, 1996, p. 2) the economic theory of mercantilism urged the authority concerned to develop resources for their states. Hence there was an understanding of the interdependence between administrative, economic and political aspects in terms of their role in the state’s welfare. The kings and their officials who were mostly trained ones, now worked towards building of roads and infrastructure such that the people would mark the kings as public servants instead of the wealthy and privileged state runners. This also formed the focus of the French Revolution of 1789 (Butler, 2007). Absolute monarchy was substituted by the term “enlightened despot”. However the feudal social system prevailed and the peasants also had some feudal obligations on them. The centralized states, which came up during the Enlightenment period, were the key to the evolution of the modern state. Consolidation of the geographical boundaries of several states in the seventeenth and the eighteenth century in Europe resulted in the expansion of the political representation with the expansion of democratization. The ability of the state in controlling and securing its borders through the increase in the endowment of the citizenship rights and less through the application of force resulted in the formation of this new political system in the newly formed states. The functional interests along with the rights to the individuals gained priority in the system of the internal political representation. Thus the consolidation of the states resulted in the formation of the democratic system within the states. (Anagnostou and Triandafyllidou, 2005, p. 8) The basic advantage of a democratic political system is the scope for decision-making about the ruling power of the country by the general citizens of the country. The central power can easily be reassigned from one political party to the other by the easy mode of elections. The second advantage is that the system averts the emergence of monopoly rule of the party in possession of the central power. Functions in favor of the general public have to be ensured by the political party effectively. Moreover a feeling of responsibility emerged among the ruling class towards the general citizens through this political system since they owe these common people their very accomplishment in the state elections. This feeling helps the ruling party gain an inspiration for the proper fulfillment of their duties. Moreover the responsibility of the citizens towards the society in which they are residing also increased through this system, as they are the ones choosing the ruling class. However since every political system has certain structural flaws democracy is no exception.  Common people can in some instances make choice that proves to be wrong for the society being unconscious of every political matter and hence the decision may affect the society (Advantages and disadvantages of democracy, 2011). Moreover the public can be sometimes easily influenced in taking wrong decisions. Common people can be manipulated through hordes thus forcing them to take some decision under the pressure of the majority. However despite these flaws this political system encourages team effort and prohibits the authority in performing against the desire of the majority. References 1. Advantages and disadvantages of democracy (2011), Scribd, retrieved on 2nd June 2011, from http://www.scribd.com/doc/37008304/Advantages-and-Disadvantages-of-Democracy  Anagnostou, D and A, Triandafyllidou, (2005), Regions, Minorities and European policies, EUROREG Collective State of Art Report 25, retrieved on 2nd June 2011 , from http://www.scribd.com/doc/55257148/2/Nation-state-building-border-regions-and-minorities-in-Europe 2. Anderson, J. O’Dowd L. and T. M. Wilson, (2003), New Borders for a changing Europe, Routledge 3. Butler, C. (2007), The Rise of the Modern State in Enlightenment Europe, Flow of History, available at: http://www.flowofhistory.com/units/west/15/FC101 (accessed on June 8 2011) 4. Collins, J.B. and K. L. Taylor, (2006), Early modern Europe, Willey- Blackwell 5. Gayton, J. T. (1996) From personalism to territorialism, International Studies Association Conference. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Difference Between Modern And Medieval States Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1424274-the-difference-between-modern-and-medieval-states
(The Difference Between Modern And Medieval States Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1424274-the-difference-between-modern-and-medieval-states.
“The Difference Between Modern And Medieval States Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1424274-the-difference-between-modern-and-medieval-states.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Difference Between Modern And Medieval States

Emergence of Modern Europe

The European states turned towards science between 1700s, which led to focus of life as experience of human being.... By doing so, the enlightenment period influenced greatly on modern western European states.... The usage of these ideas motivated a sense of western emergence into contemporary or modern time that had real and precise technological knowledge of this world....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Medieval versus Modern

Name Tutor Course College Date medieval Versus Modern I will begin the essay by focusing on the cultural differences between the medieval drama and modern drama.... I will do this by comparing the medieval drama the “crucifixion” (Greenblatt 407) with the early modern drama “King Lear” (Greenblatt 1200).... Any comparison between medieval plays and modern plays leads to the realization of significant changes in the field of drama over time....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Differences in Insurance Policies between American Airline, Delta Airline and United Airlines

Differences in Insurance Policies between American Airline, Delta Airline and United Airline Name Institution Course Instructor Date Abstract To secure properties and lives, air travel companies have established insurance policies which serve as agreements for compensation in case of a loss.... hellip; Insurance policies are therefore contracts or agreements between the insured and the insurance company.... Differences in Insurance Policies between American Airline, Delta Airline and United Airline Introduction The airline insurance policies are also referred to as aviation insurance policies....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Modern Class Systems as They Evolved from Medieval Concepts of Class

The emergence of both a merchant class and technologies lead to the development of stratification which exists within the United states.... Client's Name Class Date Modern Class Systems as They Evolved from medieval Concepts of Class The class systems in contemporary European and American society are the result of the class systems that developed in Europe during the medieval period.... Through the example of the medieval social class system which provided for a small amount of social mobility, the development of the stratification social system was allowed to emerge in which the social classes still exist, but have mobility through both achievement and opportunity....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Difference between Liberalism and Socialism

Introduction History and Political Science What is the difference between liberalism and socialism?... Liberalism and socialism reflect the way in which political, social and economic situations are viewed in the society.... Socialism is promoted by individuals that advocate for equal distribution of resources throughout the population....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Muslim and Christian Medieval Theocracies

This essay is very relevant to what is happening in today's world within some Islamic and Christian states. Generally speaking, a theocracy exists when the ruler of a government is also the religious leader of that same government.... This essay will focus on Islamic and Christian theocracies during medieval times and will compare the two.... The major religions during medieval times were Christianity and Islam.... between 1500 AD and 1700 AD the Holy Roman Empire began its decline....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Complementary and Alternative Medicine and Conventional Medicine

For many years, people in the United states are known for their dependency over the use of conventional medicine.... On the contrary, the recent 2007 National… alth Interview Survey on the use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) use in the United states revealed that as much as 38% of the American adults (> 18 years old) and roughly 12% of the children are using some type of CAM (National Center for Complementary and It is very interesting to know that the number of individuals who visit alternative therapies is already higher than those individuals who visit the Western-based physicians....
8 Pages (2000 words) Thesis

Traditional Banking Versus Modern Banking in Venice

However, due to the wealth created in the Italian cities such as Venice and Milan, they became autonomous city-states, each of which included an enclosed metropolitan center and the neighboring countryside.... In addition, this modernization drove the city-states to create a new social system in the country.... hellip; In contrast to the medieval Venetian banking system, modern banking systems have revolutionized to form a well-established form of government for the banks....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us