StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of Architecture and Authority in Japan by William Howard Coaldrake - Book Report/Review Example

Summary
The author focuses on the book "Architecture and Authority in Japan" by William Howard Coaldrake which is a powerful attempt to explore the most exalting exhibition of the Japanese civilization- architecture. It tackles the close relationship between architecture and authority in Japan…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Analysis of Architecture and Authority in Japan by William Howard Coaldrake
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Architecture and Authority in Japan by William Howard Coaldrake"

The book en d Architecture and ity in Japan written by William Howard Coaldrake is a powerful attempt to explore the most exalting exhibition of the Japanese civilization---architecture. Particularly, it tackles the close and collaborative relationship between architecture and authority in Japan. The book asserts that there is more to key structures and architectural styles than being mere signs of power of the rulers who built them. The author, William Howard Coaldrake, is a Foundation Professor of Japanese and Head of Japanese Studies from 1992-2007, at the University of Melbourne. He gained his PhD from Harvard University. He is a member and the only non-Japanese of the Kyoto Guild of Traditional Master Builders, a group that works on the restoration of Japanese heritage buildings. He compiled all the information he has gathered based on his experiences on this book and was later on published by Routledge in 1996. In terms of writing style, Coaldrake must have scored high among readers. He used first-person pronouns in writing some parts of it which would make readers get to relate to the content even more. Nonetheless, his formal tone was present all throughout the material. The author also lessened some technicality in Architecture, making it more pleasing and enjoyable to any common reader who lacks knowledge about the subject. Moreover, his use of examples and illustrations aids in deeper understanding and analysis of the subjects in point. Throughout the reading, though, it is good to look at pictures [other than those found in this book] of these architectural subjects or better yet, to personally visit the building, in order to visualize the different architectural aspects presented. In this book, before delving deeper into the analysis of Japanese architecture, the author gave a clear definition of architecture and authority. Basically, he refers to heritage buildings as the architectural subjects in point; and defines the term authority as “encompassing influence and power, dignity and legitimacy, status and hierarchy, religion and belief, and tradition and continuity, all of which play a role, but not all necessarily at the same time or in equal measure.” This definition provides readers a clear delineation of people who are in authority apart from those who are not. Meanwhile, Coaldrake, in his quest for greater knowledge, sought for numerous empirical evidences that would link architecture and authority in the history of Japan. Essentially, he examined different heritage buildings such as the Grand Shrines of Ise and Izumo, the Nara Imperial Order, the Heian Palaces and Kamakura Temples, the Castles e.g. the Nijo Castle, the Tokugawa Mausolea, the Shogunal and Daimayo Gateways, the Meiji State, and the Tange Kenzos Tokyo Monuments. He has immensely shown that all these buildings, along with their styles and structures, projected a powerful sense of authority to those who would see them. Moreover, there were several points present in this book regarding the link of architecture and authority. The author emphasizes, first and foremost, that Japanese heritage buildings were the tangible structures that contained authority; and their architectural forms served as the systematic process through which authority is contained. In relation to this, he features architecture as the by-product of the functions and activities that were made under different kinds of authority. He points out that the political, religious, and social nature of authority in the past has made the creation of these buildings possible. Secondly, Coaldrake also points out that the use of architecture, its structures, and forms, in order to express authority has long been practiced, as evidenced by Japan’s European and Asian counterparts. For example, the author provided an explanation on the role of Gothic arches that can be found in Venetian city states and in some great learning centres such as Oxford to depict political and intellectual authority in the city. In the same manner, in Japan’s Nijo Castle, for example, were displayed entrances to the rooms of the bodyguards, which are purposely done to intimidate visitors. Thus, as the author suggests, it is very difficult to separate architectural forms in understanding Japan’s history. Third, he points out that architecture has a means to communicate, whether in literal or in abstract way, the level of authority it wants to impose on others. He cited divided walls or united roofs as examples of architectural works that control human relations. In addition, he points the use of architecture in the Japanese language like that of Shoin’s [of the Meiji government] use of a decaying house as a metaphor to the crisis facing Japan at that time. Meanwhile, aside from these points, the author also chose intelligible questions that were essential in scrutinizing one-by-one the different Japanese architectural buildings. To name a few, he asked about the initial impact that the building has on its viewers; the relationship of setting with the special characteristics of the building; types of spaces enclosed and the materials used for the various parts of the building; the decorations included; the role of colour, surface, and texture of the building; its structure; and the scale and proportion between the parts of the building. Fortunately for readers, Coaldrake has answered these questions in various perspectives, i.e. in different angles, in different seasonal conditions, or different light, which is giving a more comprehensive review of the building---so comprehensive that it left behind no questions unanswered. He has utilized well both his primary and secondary sources to key in the answers to the most significant questions he had in this book, making it more convincing and overpowering compared to other books about architectural history in Japan. Overall, the book is very effective in convincing readers that there is indeed more to Japanese architecture that one can see rightly; that these buildings go beyond serving as architectural artifacts or as mere symbols of the power of its rulers. The buildings’ key structures and styles were truly intended to project the spiritual and religious beliefs, as well as the ambitious visions of its political leaders who instructed to build them. To concur with the findings of the author of this book, there is really a synchronized relationship between authority and architecture. This is evident in the author’s numerous mentions of the empirical evidences that link lines of authority to the different architectural aspects of architectural works. This book is a great reading material, especially to the Japanese, because it is in itself a great addition to Japan’s cultural history. It is also good course material to various readers; ranging from those who are studying history and architecture to those who are enthusiastic in delving deeper into the socio-political norms present in the Japanese society. This book is also a great addition to the collection of references of those who are in the academe, for it would surely grow their appreciation towards Japanese architecture. Its exquisite way of presenting the most significant pillars of Japanese culture and tradition is the proof that it is a material worth reading. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Architecture and Authority in Japan by William Howard Coaldrake

Architecture and Authority in Japan written by William Howard

Particularly, it tackles the close and collaborative relationship between architecture and authority in japan.... Particularly, it tackles the close and collaborative relationship between architecture and authority in japan.... Particularly, it tackles the close and collaborative relationship between architecture and authority in japan.... The book en d Architecture and ity in Japan written by william howard coaldrake is a powerful attempt to explore the most exalting exhibition of the Japanese civilization---architecture....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Ise Shrine: Architecture Plan and Wood Connection

The shrine is located in the city of Ise in japan.... The Ise is officially known as Jingu in japan.... Ise shrine is probably the holiest and the oldest of all Shinto shrines in japan.... Economic relevance of the shrine Ise shrine in japan is a very popular tourist destination.... Geographical features of the shrine The holy shrine of Ise in japan is located in the Ise Peninsula of the Mie Prefecture (Shitennouji Temple)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Diagrammatic Transformation of Architecture

The diagram is set as a convention of architecture and a discussion is provided of how this convention diagram has been understood in Classicist architecture.... The diagram is set as a convention of architecture and a discussion is provided of how this convention diagram has been understood in Classicist architecture.... Those concepts regarding town planning are measures of recognizing the continuity of classicism architecture and the contemporary concepts of town planning (Reynolds 97)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Land Reclamation Project in Tokyo Bay

architecture and authority in japan.... The reasons for this expansion are rooted in japan's need for more space. ... There are 127 million people in japan living in a geographical area the size of only five times the size of Britain(6, Mason).... The attitude toward public space in japan is unlike the that in the West.... The modernists schools of architecture left their impression early in japan's history, where during the expansionary times of the 1930's Architects in japan went abroad and took in the ideas of the modernist Architects like Le Corbusier....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Influence of Ancient Rome on Architecture

One thing that certainly made the Romans have such a great influence in the world is their superior skills particularly in architecture and engineering.... McGill University, School of architecture, n.... nderson, william The Architecture of Ancient Rome.... The paper "Influence of Ancient Rome on architecture" discusses that ancient Rome did influence architecture significantly.... Influence of Ancient Rome on architecture Historians, architects, lawyers, and anthropologist agree that the society we live in today have significantly been influenced by the ancient Rome....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Islamic Architecture

There are various forms of architecture that have evolved and developed over these years.... This essay "Islamic architecture" perfectly describes that it not only reflects the perspective of the people of that particular culture but it also tells about what people think about the world, while at the same time it also tells about their religion.... Among these many architectures, Islamic architecture is one of the most notable and one of the oldest architectures that has evolved....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Signifier of Victorian Architecture

The book's targeted audience is any individual who is interested in learning about how the Western architecture has changed over time and what has been its major influence and in turn how it has influenced the architectures in other continents especially the architecture and history students.... The book's targeted audience is any individual who is interested in learning about the different materials used in the Victorian architecture and the significance of iron over the years, especially the architecture and history students....
8 Pages (2000 words) Annotated Bibliography

Analysis of Islamic Architecture

Some residents and non residents favor the progress in the architecture and have the view that the development in the region is irrespective of the architecture.... However, the modern ways of architecture have contributed much in destroying the architectural heritage of UAE. ... Both of the structures are a unique piece of architecture having many similarities and dissimilarities.... The major similarity is that both of the buildings utilized the Turkish aspects of architecture like ornamenting the mosques and the massive space of the both the architectural buildings....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us