StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

United States Supreme Court - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
This discussion stresses that Petitioner Dewsnup, the debtor in this case, borrowed $119,000 from creditor/respondent Timm.  This loan was secured through a Deed of Trust which granted the creditor liens on two parcels of Utah farmland owned by the debtor.  …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
United States Supreme Court
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "United States Supreme Court"

 Petitioner Dewsnup, the debtor in this case, borrowed $119,000 from creditor/respondent Timm. This loan was secured through a Deed of Trust which granted the creditor liens on two parcels of Utah farmland owned by the debtor. The debtor defaulted in 1979; later, in 1981, the creditor issued a Notice of Default and foreclosure proceedings were commenced. A stay against foreclosure of the collateral was issued by the Bankruptcy Court pending resolution of various claims made by the debtor pursuant the Bankruptcy Code.

The immediate issue in this case arises from the debtor’s filing of an adversary proceeding pursuant to section 506(d) of the Bankruptcy Code. This issue is important because the fair market value of the collateral ($39,000) is less than the debt’s amount. The question presented is whether a debtor can “strip down” the lien of the creditor on the real property pledged as collateral for the debt to the value of the collateral; more specifically, the United States Supreme Court was asked to determine the applicability of section 506(d) to this particular set of circumstances.

For the reasons discussed below, the Court held that section 506(d) did not allow the debtor to “strip down” the lien. As an initial matter, the Court admits that section 506(d) is ambiguous, that both parties have made valid points, but that sound policy and harmonization of the modern Code section with pre-Code rules mandates a holding that section 506(d)’d lien-voiding provisions are not applicable. The Court began its analysis by examining the relationship between sections 506(a) and 506(d); this is because the debtor argued that section 506(a) demanded that a claim was “secured only to the extent of the judicially determined value of the real property on which the lien is fixed.

” This is significant, the petitioner argued, because section 506(a) must be read together with section 506(d), resulting in a determination that a debtor can rely upon this value reduction language in order to later secure a lien voidance under section 506(d) to the extant of the difference between the value of the debt and the new judicially determined value of the underlying collateral. The Court, however, refused to treat these Code sections as complementary; quite the contrary, they stated that where a claim is fully allowed under section 502 and secured by a lien, that the debtor cannot use the language of 506(a) in such a way as to independently justify the lien voidance mechanism offered by section 506(d).

The Court’s holding, it must be noted, was not unanimous. Two Justices, Scalia and Souter, dissented. The dissenting opinion argued that sections 506(a) and 506(d) ought to have been read as complementary sections, that Congress’ ambiguity should not be remedied by the majority’s interpretation, and that the debtor was correct in arguing that the lien avoidance provisions of 506(d) were applicable. In the final analysis, this is a strong majority opinion and probably not subject to change in the future.

Sections 506(a) and 506(d) deal with independent legal issues, the language of 506(a) may not be used to invoke the lien avoiding language of 506(d), and debtors must suffer the burden of such disparities between the value of the underlying collateral and the debt itself.ReferencesDewsnup v. Timm 116 L.Ed. 2d 903, 112 S. Ct. 773 (1992). Available: http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?navby=case&court=us&vol=502&page=410

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“United States Supreme Court Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1527355-the-united-states-supreme-court
(United States Supreme Court Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1527355-the-united-states-supreme-court.
“United States Supreme Court Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1527355-the-united-states-supreme-court.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF United States Supreme Court

A Criminal Case That Has Been Adjudicated by the United States Supreme Court

There are a number of cases that have been handled by the supreme high court that have in one way or another set precedence over future rulings that may occur on similar matters and one of these is the Gonzalez Vs Raich case which occurred in the year 2005 (Find law).... Congress has the ability to criminalize the use and production of Cannabis that is home grown even when states have allowed its use for medicinal purposes....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

United States Supreme Court and the Constitution

He points out that Americans had a predisposition on how the Supreme Court would function; … McCloskeys' thesis is that the decisions of the United States Supreme Court lean congruently with popular American opinion.... Some historians have put forth the administrative argument that Chief Justice John Marshall was the first Chief Justice of the United States Supreme Court, albeit belies the historical facts.... McCloskeys' thesis is that the decisions of the United States Supreme Court lean congruently with popular American opinion....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

United States Supreme Court Case Analysis

The supreme court in 2007 ruled over the Massachusetts v.... The complainants were dismissed by the district court in New York which was presiding over the case on the view that the case raised political inquiries that were thought to be inappropriate for a judicial resolution.... It was argued by the court that the issues on climate change that had been presented by the plaintiff would require a delicate balancing of the environment, foreign, economic policies and the interests of the national security....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

The Principal Role Players in Criminal Cases

The judge determines whether the defendant should be held in jail or released on conditions during the first appearance (“supreme court of the United States,” 2010).... If the evidence presented is sufficient, the court issues a Immediately the defendant is arrested, pretrial interviews and investigations are conducted by the prosecution.... During the case, the court appointed Harry and Wilbur Dettmar to...
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Scott Peterson Case

He was later sentenced to death through… Scott Peterson is now incarcerated in San Quentin State Prison on death row as his case waits on the supreme court of California on appeal. Scott had two attorneys The court thus proceeded to assign him one by the name of Kirk McAllister who was a veteran defense lawyer....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Role of Dredd Scott Case in the Civil War

Dred Scott case can be said to be the worst decision that the United States Supreme Court has ever rendered that it even become the catalyst of the American Civil War.... In the Dred Scott case, the United States Supreme Court decided that all people of African descent could not… Therefore, people of African descent such as Dred Scott could not sue the government for his freedom. As a person, Dred Scots was a slave who was first owned by Peter Blow in Missouri....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The United States Supreme Court

From the paper "The United States Supreme Court" it is clear that the fourth and final exception involves officers who are in “hot pursuit” of felons who are fleeing and evading capture and officers who are gathering evidence that could readily disappear.... In addition, all Federal courts must abide by the decisions laid down by the supreme court, as well as the United States Constitution.... With respect to state courts, the interpretations and decisions that the supreme court makes apply, but the Court is limited to interpreting and changing Federal laws, not state laws....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

The United States Supreme Court: Trevino and Assistance of Counsel Claim

This new attorney found the evidence that the first attorney did not, and presented the evidence to the federal habeas court.... rdquo; The federal court is essentially stating that a lawyer has the duty to raise ineffective assistance of counsel arguments about himself.... Yet the district federal court, and the circuit court, somehow thinks that the ineffective assistance of counsel claim should have been raised at a time when there was not any evidence available to raise it....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us