StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Simulation: Environmental Nuisance Lawsuit - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
Environmental nuisance means doing a right thing or a wrong thing in a wrong place, which mainly entails unreasonable interference with other person’s property. (Turner, 2004) The supreme court of Iowa State in the case of Bowman v Board of supervisors held that granting…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Simulation: Environmental Nuisance Lawsuit
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Simulation: Environmental Nuisance Lawsuit"

Environmental Nuisance Suit INTRODUCTION Environmental nuisance means doing a right thing or a wrong thing in a wrong place, which mainly entails unreasonable interference with other person’s property. (Turner, 2004) The supreme court of Iowa State in the case of Bowman v Board of supervisors held that granting agricultural farms immunity from nuisance law suits would amount to unconstitutionally taking of a neighbor’s property. The action may be public or private, private nuisance involves where a harmful substance intentionally and carelessly flows to another’s property by land, air or water thus occasioning a trespass where the defendant will be held liable for damages while public nuisance entails an act causing damage to public health or obstruction.

Under common law, courts opine that modern federal environmental law such as Clean Water Act has displaced nuisance laws but common law action can be inferred. (Turner, 2004) The facts of the scenario at hand The suit involves the defendant, a dairy farm v the plaintiff, a group of citizens. The plaintiffs live near the diary farm, the defendant accumulates and stores manure in lagoons, which smells horrific, the manure flows into the plaintiffs adjoining property and a state park and subsequently into a stream which citizens fetch water for personal use.

Leakage of pipes and overflow during rain season causes this. The legal question to be answered The question remains whether the acts of the diary farm constitutes a public nuisance. (Bangle, 1990) To some extend the leakage of manure to the neighbor’s property and the stream constitutes an obstruction to a private person and an interference to use of the rights therein hence a private nuisance while the pollution of the stream constitutes a public health hazard hence public nuisance.

The legal concept emerging includes; The concept of burden of proof arises. (Bangle, 1990) The general legal rule requires that whoever alleges a fact proves, in this scenario the burden of proving that the diary farm’s act is a public nuisance lies on the group of citizen. The other concept appertains to the reasonableness of the farm allowing the manure to flow from the farm to neighbors property, and whether due diligence has been sought to prevent the escape.

This concept becomes relevant to this scenario because the law gives a ‘right to farm’ as a defense to the charges, if a farm exercises acceptable manure application procedures while under a prudent and a qualified manager. Similarly the technical practice and economic reasonableness provides that, mechanical equipments are prone to defaults and a certain aroma should be expected from manure. (Turner, 2004) Conclusion In conclusion, first, no health injury in relation to the diary farms act has been reported, secondly, the source proves to be of a high economic value for providing milk and manure, thirdly, the location suitability seems good having regard to the park, fourthly, the technical practicability is that the plaintiff should have reasonably expected an aroma from a diary farm and lastly, the farm has applied due diligence to avoid the escape by piping the manure and building a concrete wall.

The mechanical equipments are bound to defaults and so the suit is dismissed with costs to the plaintiffs. ReferenceC Turner(2004) Unlocking The Law of Torts (4th edition)London, Guttenberg press limited.R Bangle (1990) law of Torts (10th edition) India, Narula enterprise Press

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Simulation: Environmental Nuisance Lawsuit Assignment”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1593565-simulation-environmental-nuisance-lawsuit
(Simulation: Environmental Nuisance Lawsuit Assignment)
https://studentshare.org/law/1593565-simulation-environmental-nuisance-lawsuit.
“Simulation: Environmental Nuisance Lawsuit Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1593565-simulation-environmental-nuisance-lawsuit.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Simulation: Environmental Nuisance Lawsuit

Environmental Nuisance Lawsuit

environmental nuisance lawsuit Name of the Writer Name of the Institution environmental nuisance lawsuit Factual Summary: In the given scenario, a civil lawsuit has been filed by NICE (Neighbors Invested in a Clean Environment) against Chris Lively, owner of Northfield Farm.... We are told that judge has already denied an earlier motion by Chris Lively to dismiss the charges, and will now decide by Bench Trial without jury whether the Common Law offences of nuisance and trespass have been violated in the light of the facts presented....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Virginia Business Lawsuit

Name: Professor: Course: Date: Southwest Virginia Malls Vs the National Alliance for Accessibility Summary The malls of southwest Virginia have faced a lawsuit for discriminatory practices against the disabled customers.... The lawsuit involved the major malls located in the region.... The lawsuit was forwarded on behalf of the plaintiffs by the national alliance for accessibility.... The group cited the lawsuit was because of the gross violations by the malls on the Americans with Disabilities Act....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Local Lawsuit - Black & Decker Corporation

Local lawsuit Name Institution Local lawsuit Black & Decker Corporation is one of the top manufacturing companies in the United States since it was founded in 1910.... In 1998, Black & Decker Corporation was involved in a lawsuit with the Internal Revenue Service regarding allegations by the company to be refunded 57 million dollars from its earlier tax payments.... However, there a number of risk management strategies Black & Decker Corporation management could have implemented to avoid the lawsuit....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Class Action Lawsuit

The number of players suffering is large enough this time again to make a joinder impracticable; hence the class action lawsuit was filed, while others still continue to sue the league individually.... Being the plaintiffs' attorney, it is natural to make the first move and make use of the tactical advantage and build the lawsuit based on the inherent advantage of acting first.... Keeping the timing in control and handling the sequence of discovery accordingly, it is most appropriate to keep the defendant in a defensive position for the entire lawsuit and keep the players' perspective dominating....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

The Problems of Anti-Social Behavior Perpetrated by Neighbors

oc)To substantiate the Home Secretary's statement and policy, and to provide clarification to staff and residents, most property developers have brought the following actions under anti-social behavior:Use of threatening or offensive languageOffensive drunkennessUsing a property or any of the communal areas on a scheme for immoral orIllegal purposes, such as prostitution, or illegal manufacture, sale or use of drugs Excessive domestic noise, whether from radios, televisions, hi-fis, musical instruments, social activity, daytime or late night parties or gatheringsThe lighting of bonfires in the garden of a property or in any of the communal areas on a schemeThe depositing of litter or rubbish either in the garden of a property or in any of the communal areas on a development or estate owned or managed by AccordFailure to control the behavior of pets including taking adequate precautions to prevent the fouling of neighboring areasThe playing of ball games sufficiently close to neighboring homes so as to cause a nuisance or damage to Accord's property including boundary fences, trees and shrubsThe carrying out of maintenance or repairs to motor vehicles other than those normally used for domestic purposes by the resident or members of their householdUsing threatening or aggressive behavior towards visitors....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Entertainment Law in the United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom the main types of businesses that are usually started by investors are that of a sole trader, a partnership, a public or a private limited… As there is no such legal requirement of any sort to maintain audited account books, Vick will be spared from this haggle.... Yet he will still need to pay the income tax that will be charged on his The advantages of this form of business would be that this business form is easy to establish and there are no legalities involved in setting up....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Local Lawsuit: Apple and Samsung

In the paper “Local lawsuit” the author analyzes the most gigantic scuffle in the technological world – recent attack of Samsung towards Apple after the launch of the iPhone 5.... According to a recent court filing, Samsung asked the jurisdiction in Korea to include the iPhone 5 in the countersuit claim....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Demaree Family against Wal-Mart

A lawsuit was filed by the Demaree family against the Wal-Mart accusing them of not telling the Demaree parents about their unsuitable print policy and reporting their children's bathtub photos to the police department of Arizona. This all started when the Demaree family took… The photos were taken by them during their vacation at San Deigo.... (ross, 2009) As the result of this series of miserable events that caused a great disgrace to the Demaree family, they filed two separate law suits lawsuit....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us