StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Requirements for Admissible Statements Analysis - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
We will discuss different aspects of these cases including case description, final ruling, laws applied for final decision and impact of decisions. We will also develop a chart comparing these two cases. Common factor between the two cases is that both of them were concerned about the rights of the accused in police custody…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Requirements for Admissible Statements Analysis Case Study
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Requirements for Admissible Statements Analysis"

Download file to see previous pages

Illinois', Danny Escobedo, a 22 year-old young man, was accused for the murder of his brother-in-law. The incident happened at the night of 19th January, 1960 when the victim was fatally shot. After few hours Escobedo was arrested without a warrant and taken to custody for interrogation. Escobedo made no statements to police and he was released in the afternoon when his lawyer pursued writ of habeas corpus to the state court with the appeal of releasing his client as according to him there were no sufficient evidences against his client.

But Escobedo was again arrested along with his sister on January 30, on the basis of the statement of Benedict DiGerlando who was another suspect of the murder. Benedict DiGerlando stated to police that Escobedo shot his brother-in-law causing his death. Police handcuffed Escobedo while taking him to police station and threatened him by saying that they have enough proof of his crime and it will be better for him to confess.

According to the Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution, nobody can be forced to be witness against himself in any criminal case but this rule was violated in case of Escobedo. Even, when Escobedo requested to consult with his attorney, his request was rejected. The attempt from Escobedo's attorney to see his client was also rejected by police. Again it was the violation of Sixth Amendment of U.S. Constitution as it states that, the suspected person has the right to enjoy legal assistance in all criminal prosecution.

Finally, Escobedo confessed the crime and based on that he was found guilty of the murder. He appealed in the Illinois Supreme Court to reconsider his conviction. But it was rejected and then he approached to the U.S. Supreme Court. Supreme Court's decision went with Escobedo and his conviction was overturned by declaring his confession statement as inadmissible. In the second case 'Miranda v. Arizona', Ernesto Arturo Miranda, was accused in two cases one is robbery and the other is attempt to rape.

He was arrested on March, 1963. In the attempt to rape case, the victim identified Miranda as the attacker. He also confessed the fact during police interrogation. The court appointed attorney of Miranda, John J. Flynn, tried to defend the accused by highlighting two points. First point was the instability in the story stated by the victim in the attempt to rape case and the second point was the confession of Miranda during police interrogation without any legal advice from any lawyer.

But the Arizona Supreme Court convicted Miranda a 20-30 years imprisonment for the punishment of both cases by overruling all objections of his lawyer. But an appeal to the U.S. S

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Requirements for Admissible Statements Analysis Case Study - 1”, n.d.)
Requirements for Admissible Statements Analysis Case Study - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501433-requirements-for-admissible-statements-analysis-case-study
(Requirements for Admissible Statements Analysis Case Study - 1)
Requirements for Admissible Statements Analysis Case Study - 1. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501433-requirements-for-admissible-statements-analysis-case-study.
“Requirements for Admissible Statements Analysis Case Study - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501433-requirements-for-admissible-statements-analysis-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Requirements for Admissible Statements Analysis Case Study

Business Domain & Requirements Analysis

This Report is viewed as an initial stage in the definition of the requirements in terms of systems, processes, and software requirements for the new integrated environmental data gathering system, so no detailed cost-benefit analyses have been provided.... This case study "Business Domain & Requirements analysis" discusses the IT services industry as a system integration exercise, and it is expected that the proposed environmental data capture and collation system will be implemented along these lines....
25 Pages (6250 words) Case Study

Why Are Ambiguous Business Requirements the Leading Cause of System Development Failures

Vague business requirements frequently occur due to the non-involvement of end-users in system development during its analysis and design phase.... The prime reason identified for a project to fail is the bad business requirements that are ambiguous.... Vague business requirements frequently occur due to the non-involvement of end-users in… When different people interpret differently, the system loses its real essence and lead to dissatisfied customers/ clients The vague use of certain words can also lead to ambiguous business requirements causing failures....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

CASE STUDY - Financial Statement Analysis

his show that the FINANCIAL MENT analysis al Affiliation Financial ment analysis The rate of sales growth is given by the following formulaRate of sales growth=Net sales of current year-Net sales of previous year Previous net sales x 100%Chem- Dem's rate of sales growth for 2012 is given by: 3,814-3,051 = 25% 3,051 x 100%Chem-Med's forecasted rate of sales growth for years 2011, 2012 and 2013 are given below: Year 2011: 5,340-3,814 = 40% 3,814 x 100%Year 2012: 7,475-5,340 =39....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Law of Evidence

The laptop, the stash of condoms and the $5,000 would be admissible in court as they obtained while the police officers obtained a warrant of to search the premises.... However, even though such evidence is admissible in court, the court must still determine the weight in which the evidence should be given in relation the amount of significance....
13 Pages (3250 words) Case Study

Satelite Distribuidora de Petroleo

Besides, Darby will study the past financial performance of SAT through both trend and ratio analysis in order to make an informed decision.... It will be able to diversify further by increasing the product mix and also get the capital base to serve the unsatisfied customers (Applegate and Minardi)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Hearsay Evidence in Criminal Justice

The paper "Hearsay Evidence in Criminal Justice" highlights that the CJA 2003 does not have all the answers.... This would not be such a worry if we kept our evidence rules under constant review, but experience suggests it may be a good long while before we see any further attempts at reform....
13 Pages (3250 words) Case Study

Tax Refund for Nonresident Aliens

They were not aware of some important US tax requirements.... This paper "Tax Refund for Nonresident Aliens" focuses on the fact that a portion of the cooperative education assignment was utilized to understand the main causes of refund issues.... It has been noted and mentioned by IRS that substantial amount of money is lying with IRS unclaimed....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Admissibility of Evidence in the Widdowson Case

This paper “Admissibility of Evidence in the Widdowson Case” seeks to establish the admissibility of evidence provided in a case involving the plaintiff, Mr.... Widdowson, and two defenders.... The plaintiff is a thirty-six-year-old male who is in a marital relationship with one Mrs.... Widdowson....
21 Pages (5250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us