StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Response to McCloskeys Article On Being an Atheist - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Response to McCloskey’s Article On Being an Atheist" is about the philosophy of existence which is arguably one of the most difficult, challenging, and most widely contested branches of philosophy. No deep understanding of existence seems to provide absolute proof to all philosophers…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Response to McCloskeys Article On Being an Atheist
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Response to McCloskeys Article On Being an Atheist"

?Response to McCloskey’s Article “On Being an Atheist” Introduction The philosophy of existence is arguably one of the most difficult, challenging and most widely contested branches of philosophy. No deep understanding of existence seems to provide absolute proof to all philosophers. One philosopher, theorist, or thinker comes up with an argument only to be contested by other lines of thought. McCloskey is perhaps one of the philosophers who have given the issue of existence of God a deep thought. His arguments on the article “On Being an Atheist” present a wide dimension of thought, discussion, and critique. In this paper, a response is given to McCloskey by basin g the arguments to what has been covered in the philosophy of religion unit.  McCloskey, in his article “On being an Atheist” presents a very strong counter argument against theist arguments about existence of a supreme perfect being referred to as God. According to him, theists hold on to arguments about existence of God as the fundamental proofs of his existence. The arguments do not certainly infer to proof of God’s existence nor do they provide a proof of why we exist. He actually claims that theists are sucked into the realms of religion not because of the basic proofs that exist but due to mere arguments. According to McCloskey’s line of argument, it is possible to argue that God certainly does not exist. The world is so imperfect to be the engineering work of a perfect being. In fact, we can only conclude that God, if he ever exists, is an evil God since there is more pain and suffering in the world than joy and happiness. Where is God when all the evil happens? Where was he not to control Hitler? Arguably, God may not exist if we take this line of thought. I have always observed the unjustified pain and suffering that happen to the per se “wrong people.” Young babies who are flawless in the eyes of Supreme Being “God” should certainly not suffer at least because they are innocent. Why can’t God bring us closer to him by good deeds and not through pain and suffering as claimed by theists? Things would seem more rational. On the other hand, existence would cease to make any meaning if God did not exist. What if God made the universe the way it is with an ultimate purpose? To me it seems more logical than to claim his nonexistence McCloskey presents a very strong yet questionable argument about cosmology. According to him, it is possible to have a cause without cause. He infers that it is possible to have the world, as we know it without a causative agent. The mere existence of the universe is not a justified reason enough to posit that there exists a cause behind creation. I quite agree with his argument since the existence of the universe is not a foolproof evidence of existence of a supreme being. However, I tend to agree more with the theists, not because there is foolproof evidence but because both atheists like McCloskey and the scientific giants have not yet provided exact proof of cause. I would rather live believing that there was God and die to find there was none, than to live as if he never existed and died to find that he actually existed. According to Evans line of thought about “cause for cause,” existence of the universe would be both irrational and absurd if there were no cause for the entire perfectly tuned universe as it represents itself to humankind. Craig also shares the same arguments on his article “The Absurdity of Life without God” (Craig, 2008). All religious beliefs experience an appreciable form of connection with a supreme being. Surprisingly, virtually all religious ideologies about supremacy of the creator share the same basics. Christians experience faith, miracles, healing, pain, and suffering among other connective experiences with God. McCloskey may have a point in his argument but his argument is somewhat one sided. I might ask McCloskey one simple yet fundamental question what determines the discourse on the universe? Is it a collective contribution of every human being and his relationship with the universe? Is it an all-perfect coincidence? Certainly, it is only logical to presume that there exist a cause that determines the discourse on the universe. That cause can only be the supreme God according to me. Teleological arguments are arguably the closest to truth or evidence about existence of cause. It is possible to make a deductive reasoning about the maker of a car, house, boat or anything manmade by investigating and evaluating the visible or present object. Likewise, it is very much possible to make inferences about God, or his existence therein by looking at the universe. McCloskey claims, “To get the proof going, genuine indisputable examples of design and purpose are needed” (Rationalist Press Association, 1968). Whilst his claim holds some elements of fact in them, a counter argument about his position can be presented. There is too much coincidence in the universe to possibly claim that all happened by coincidence. What genuine undisputable proofs of design and purpose does he possibly want? His supportive argument leans on the fact that the world has so many imperfections to be termed as a creation or design of a perfect God. What McCloskey fails to reckon is that God, in his perfectness, could have deemed it perfect to make the world imperfectly. We have no any justification to question his design. Anyone can design his creation, innovation, or idea the way he deems appropriate. For instance, we sometimes lie to children to protect them or at least wait until it is the right time to tell them the truth. Suppose the world was perfect, what would McCloskey possibly argue? Would that be a definite proof of God’s existence? McCloskey should see the imperfectness in the world as a perfect design by God. Dwelling too much on the evil, pain and suffering in the world is not justified. The many good and pleasurable things in the world bring about God’s purpose and design. For instance, writing this response article to McCloskey is tasking and challenging but the joy, gratitude and happiness that follows good grades are great. If the world were perfect, such gratification, and happiness from accomplishment would not be possible. To me, that would be an imperfect world. The present design is perfect if we look at it from the other dimension. Undeniably, McCloskey bases most of his argument on the presence of evil in the world to support his atheist argument about lack of God’s existence. He claims that “No being who was perfect could have created a world in which there was unavoidable suffering or in which his creatures would (and in fact could have been created so as not to) engage in morally evil acts, acts which very often result in injury to innocent persons” (McCloskey). Arguably, the imperfectness in the world may be assumed a reason for God’s nonexistence but not absolute proof. According to Evans argument, we can posit that the imperfections seen by McCloskey are actually the design of God. The virtue of freewill therefore makes meaning in the amidst of the imperfection of the universe. Evan argues that the universe is meticulously designed with the imperfections with an ultimate purpose that man may find meaning and purpose of existence. It is true that, pain and suffering does exist in the universe but on the other hand, freewill gives humankind an appreciable degree over those pains and sufferings. If humankind used the freewill endowment for the right cause, then much pain and suffering in the world would cease to exist (Evans, 1985). Therefore, McCloskey should not look at the pain and suffering as imperfectness of God but his design to let man exercise freewill and therefore determine his destiny the way he deems appropriate. By bringing the thoughts of McCloskey and Craig together on the table, some conclusions can be made. McCloskey claims, atheism is comforting, which I think makes no meaning at all. It seems rather difficult if not impossible to rest assured that life has no meaning at all. It is difficult to believe that everything falls into place by coincidence and without any meaning. I would rather lean on Craig’s thought. I find it hard to believe in the nonexistence of God since that in itself is absurd. There would be no ultimate purpose in life without God’s existence. Life would be meaningless and there would be no any justification for doing good. However, if we believe in the existence and supremacy of God and appreciate his design, then life makes meaning. If we follow the line of command as dictated by God, then everything gets meaning and we can then get busy making a reasonable discourse to our lives. Conclusion McCloskey presents a very strong atheist argument and argues about the nonexistence of God. However, a critical review of his article using different ideological measures from other thinkers such as Craig and Evans proves that his arguments are indeed weak. I wish Craig and McCloskey would debate on national television. McCloskey would certainly lose. I believe in God’s existence and I find it comforting. Additionally, it eliminates absurdity of meaningless life. Therefore, we should appreciate God’s existence and his universe design. This line of thought would make neonatal nurses like me make a positive contribution to the world. References Craig, W. (2008). Reasonable Faith: Christian Truth and Apologetics. Wheaton, IL. Crossway Books. Rationalist Press Association, Ltd. (1968). Question, Issue 1. Pemberton: Pemberton Pub. Co. Evans, C. (1985). Philosophy of religion: thinking about faith. London: InterVarsity Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Response to McCloskey's Article On Being an Atheist Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1439384-mccloskey-article-on-being-an-atheist
(Response to McCloskey'S Article On Being an Atheist Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1439384-mccloskey-article-on-being-an-atheist.
“Response to McCloskey'S Article On Being an Atheist Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1439384-mccloskey-article-on-being-an-atheist.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Response to McCloskeys Article On Being an Atheist

Article response paper

The article stresses the importance of being able to express oneself while keeping other people's ideas in mind, rather than keeping quiet in situations where your contribution could be of considerable help.... Article response Paper Name Institution Article response Paper A brief outline of the main issues/points discussed in the article The article discusses the challenges that people face when they find themselves in environments with cultures that are different from theirs....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Article response paper

Article response Paper Name Institution Main Issues/Points Discussed in Article The authors of the article seek to bring out facts about third language (L3) acquisition.... In an effort to answer questions asked perennially, they analyse several theories fronted for the relevance of L3/Ln acquisition in adults....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Natural Religion: A Conversation Between Cleanthes, Philo, and Demea

This could mean that they have become an atheist without their knowledge.... The Supreme being is also said to have similar aspects as those of Human Beings.... The people that explain about the simplicity of the Supreme being are Mystical.... Moreover, the Supreme being cannot be fully comprehended.... Has he gotten to declamation instead of being reasonable?... In the same way, these philosophers came up with ideas on the Supreme being....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Nisbette and Wilsons Article

Second, when reporting in the effects of stimuli, people may not interrogate a memory of the cognitive processes that operated on the stimuli; instead, they may base their reports on implicit, a priori theories about the casual connection between stimulus and response.... In the awareness in the existence of the response, mental processes depend on other external contributions of the environment.... In this case, a person will become knowledgeable or responsive into a certain action with the verification or response coming from the extrinsic force....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Response to Article Questions

The article claims that flavonoids in cocoa might play a major role in regulating blood pressure or even preventing occurrence of ailments such as cancer, heart diseases as well as relieving aching… Additional claims in the article is the likelihood that cocoa could be effective in relieving migraines in human, just like it has done in research involving mice....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Influence of L1 over L2 and L3 Acquisition

The article covers a study done whose main aim is to find out if L2(second language) has a greater impact on the L3(third language) lexicon of the learner/candidate who has attained a higher level of second language proficiency and also has had significant exposure to it.... The… dy focused on determining the different ways in which varying/different language systems interact in the mind and affect either the linguistic development, performance or both of the person/individual concerned....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Response 5 Article on india

Devyani, an ndian Diplomat, who was arrested… n the United States of America for having made false accusations in the United States as well as being in connection with fraudulent activities regarding her visa.... Devyani, an ndian Diplomat, who was arrested in the United States of America for having made false accusations in the United States as well as being in connection with fraudulent activities regarding her visa....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Reading response LN 4

It is at this position that the authors emphasize that a lot of Reading response LN 4 affiliation Reading response LN 4 The most interesting aspect about the article is the verity that the authors attest to there existing humor in visual form.... This is to mean that other forms of humor exist apart from the usual verbal humor....
2 Pages (500 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us