StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

On Roses Liberty, Property, Environmentalism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay describes that some believe that the only way to adequately manage the environment is to make it private property. Rose claims that “property-rights approaches are important and feasible, but that there are many pitfalls that will need to be avoided”…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
On Roses Liberty, Property, Environmentalism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "On Roses Liberty, Property, Environmentalism"

On Rose’s “Liberty, Property, Environmentalism.” Some believe that the only way to adequately manage the environment is to make it private property. The property-rights based approach is offered as a solution to the problem of abusing environmental resources. Rose claims that “property-rights approaches are important and feasible, but that there are many pitfalls that will need to be avoided” (p. 421, in Schmidtz and Willott, 2012). What are the pitfalls she is talking about? Present and explain them. Do you agree with Rose? Why or why not? Explain your answers using examples illustrating and demonstrating your point. According to Rose, property regimes may have significant pitfalls and these include the following: parties involved in the agreement may not necessarily come up with conformity, they may be ineffective, they may be aimed at certain objective not consistent with protecting the environment, property rights may not apply for environmental resources, and they may only produce monoculture instead of diverse environments (Rose 1-25). In property regimes, parties involved may not come up with conformity is a possibility. In the first place, it is a tough activity to manage the environment. It is hard to manage it because it is vast and unlike a single property or so, it is tough to control or maintain it due to its area of coverage (Rose 1). On the other hand, the environment is largely considered under the property domain of the public. This means that everybody could significantly own any possible integral component of an environment. In the case of Scarborough shoal, the heated debate between the Philippines and China continues to create significant tension as these two countries could not actually come up with an agreement as to which the territorial responsibility on this rich-oil area should fall. Due to significant benefits that this land could provide, it would ignite significant intentions which make it hard for the two countries to actually come up with an agreement. A rich-filled oil area is considered to be an asset of a country as processed oil has become lifeblood of the modern economy. Thus, economically and politically speaking, it would be a great opportunity for either China or Philippines to take hold of the said parcel of land or territory. Another pitfall of property regimes is their being ineffective. For instance, if prevailing law concerning area of territorial responsibility between nations is effective, then China and the Philippines would not have become too narrow-minded on the issue about Scarborough shoal. In the first place, it would have been easy for these two countries to resolve the issue. However, due to the point that there could be significant amount of politics that is not impossible to take place, ineffectiveness of property regimes could be expected because of the prevailing political, social or economic concerns associated with this issue. The level of inefficiency may be due to significant intentions of the people behind the property regimes. It is easy for everyone to justify individual points and even to argue their rights and privileges in every property under any public domain. Thus, complexity of the issue can always be expected. Another significant pitfall of property regimes is that they may be able to come up with certain objective not consistent with protecting the environment or its resources. As stated earlier, there are some various human concerns such as social, economic and politics that can be associated with property regimes. Knowing the fact that these concerns could substantially lead to personal matters such as in the case of China and Philippines, property regimes could therefore be used for any sort of justification just to be able to address personal gain. Furthermore, since the environment is substantially used as a very important resource that could be maximized for either of social, economic and political gain, then it is not impossible to come up with property regimes that will always look forward to address these human concerns. For instance, global warming issue is related with protecting the environment. However, sustainability issue which is clearly an integral component of protecting the environment will always look forward to related information prior to the development of relevant policies or procedures or property regimes. Concerning this, Al Gore pointed out that human activities substantially degrade the environment so highly industrialized countries need to refrain from over production or emission of harmful gas to the atmosphere. However, another research stand against the point of Al Gore telling the public and the rest of global warming alarmists that what is happening at present with the environment is due to natural process of nature which had long before taking its part on earth. Another important issue concerns about biotechnology and big corporations especially with coming up with genetically modified food. Some use the point that in order to reduce use of harmful chemicals for pest control, modifying the genetic makeup of agricultural crops would be the best option. Although this has a point, some would claim that the world should have no longer experienced shortage of food supply. So some would claim that only the powerful few and profit-hunger corporations benefit from this breakthrough technology. It is therefore clear that one could not separate significant political or economic issues associated with implementing property regimes particularly in the case of environment protection and sustainability issues. There is always a possibility that the entire intention may not be actually for protecting the environment itself or its related resources, which could substantially agree with Rose’s point. This connects to the next idea that property rights may not eventually apply for environmental resources. For example, Monsanto has property right over its genetically modified crops. However, based on EPA’s ruling, such right cannot eventually apply when some pollen of these crops went off the neighboring farms resulting to genetic pollution. As a result, neighboring farms may eventually possess new crops patented by Monsanto. It is not actually a form of thief because there is an involvement of natural process. It is the nature itself who would have initiated the actual situation. This is just a specific case of property rights that could possibly not apply for environmental resources. Finally, another pitfall of property regimes is the production of monoculture instead of diverse environments. For example, big plantations due to maximizing profit potential choose to plant single crop for a wide space or area of parcel of land. Due to property regime, a certain corporation or property owner could maximize this opportunity. However, the resulting impact of this results to producing monoculture environment instead of a highly diverse one. I certainly agree with Rose. The reason is that humans have the ability to maximize whatever it is that is at hand. Due to certain rights and privileges, humans always have the opportunity to maximize potential benefits even if it would mean threat to environmental sustainability or unfairness and inequality. For me, pitfalls therefore about property regimes should be avoided. Reference Rose, Carol M. Liberty, Property, Environmentalism. Social Philosophy & Policy 26.1 (2009): 1-25. Web. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“On Roses Liberty, Property, Environmentalism Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1453381-on-roses-liberty-property-environmentalism
(On Roses Liberty, Property, Environmentalism Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1453381-on-roses-liberty-property-environmentalism.
“On Roses Liberty, Property, Environmentalism Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1453381-on-roses-liberty-property-environmentalism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF On Roses Liberty, Property, Environmentalism

Is There Something Distinctive about Environmental Social Movements

It follows that environmentalism today has gained much success in encouraging people to adopt more environmental friendly products, methods and reducing dumping of wastes in the environment in advocating for “green living”.... As a result, environmentalism has become a common topic in forming political ideologies to support different efforts and goals towards “saving the world” (Goodwin & Jasper, 2003).... With these dynamics and the great success that environmentalism has achieved today, the report will investigate the unique aspects of social environmentalist groups and their approach to environmentalism....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Anthropology of Globalization

Covering a wide range of political, social, economic and anthropological trends the concept of "globalization" has recently become one of the frequently used terms in English language.... Due to rapid globalization contemporary world is furthermore believed to be a "global village".... hellip; The idea of "global village" refers particularly to the "First World" - world's most developed nations that are in the vanguard of globalization processes....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Social Activism Today

t is the common understanding of the natural environment that underlies environmentalism, a broad political, social, and philosophical movement that advocates various actions and policies in the interest of protecting what nature remains in the natural environment, or restoring or expanding the role of nature in this environment (Natural Environment).... nbsp;… The National Organization of Women (NOW) touched on almost every women's rights issue, including abortion rights, divorce reform, equal pay and credit legislation, consciousness-raising, gender equity in education, poverty, childcare, sex segregation in public places, political campaigns, sexual assault, and marital property reform....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Issues of Left-Wing or Right-Wing Politics

Through the course of history in Europe and America, power had come to be based on not only the institutions of church and state, but also on the race, gender, and ownership of property, particularly land.... This paper "The Issues of Left-Wing or Right-Wing Politics" focuses on the left-Wing or Right-Wing politics - terms used to classify the inclination of any individual, political party, political positions, prescribed policies etc on the Left-Right political spectrum....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Eco-Terrorism in the Legal Context

It is also considered as eco-sabotage and is a crime committed for nature's sake (Runyon p.... 1).... The term ecoterrorism, as understood by the… eneral society, refers to acts which are destructive and criminal in nature inflicted to innocent entities, humans, properties, and other physical structures, in order to echo out sentiments that are environmental and politically related....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Causes and Impacts of Environmental Degradation

As the paper outlines, environmental degradation is not a new aspect in the spectrum of the environment since it has been happening throughout the history of human beings; however, its rate has now increased to the extent of not leaving adequate time for the recovery and regeneration of the environment....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework

Welfare and Community Care Theories

According to Moore (2002),  The theories of social policy that underpin welfare provision include the new right approach, the social democratic approach, the radical socialist or Marxist approach, the feminist approach, the anti-racist approach, environmentalism, and the third way....
13 Pages (3250 words) Coursework

Causes and Impacts of Environmental Degradation

The goal of this paper is to provide an overview of the issue of environmental degradation and the threat it possesses to society.... The writer suggests that the governments and citizens need to assume collective responsibility in ensuring environmental conservation through relevant legislation....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us