StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism vs Realism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism vs Realism Name Institution In 1881, legal realism started following the publishing of the ‘Common Law’ by Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. attacking the orthodox viewpoint of law that stated that the life of the law has failed in being logical; rather, it has been the experience (Tamanaha, 2009)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism vs Realism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism vs Realism"

Download file to see previous pages

Although it has declined, it still continues to be influential in how the law is looked at (Tamanaha, 2009). Conversely, legal formalism is a rule and law-based perception of decision-making. According to this law, judges base their decisions on whatever the law says as opposed to what the law must be. This was the widespread view in the early on years and still is perceived by many as the appropriate way of deciding cases. While observing the constitutional law, legal formalists have the perception that it should be construed by its original implication (Tamanaha, 2009).

Present day legal formalism is especially prominent within two parts, constitutional law together with statutory interpretation (Tamanaha, 2009). According to the constitutional law, formalism is integrated with “originalism,” the perception that the constitution has to be interpreted in concurrence with its “original meaning.” Conversely, within statutory interpretation, formalism is integrated with the “plain meaning” theory whereby the statutes have to be interpreted in order that the words and phrases contain their ordinary denotation (Tamanaha, 2009).

Plain meaning methods also are integrated with the perception that the legislative history must not be used, particularly if it would end up in an interpretation, which varies from the statute’s text. . Other realists contend that judges must sometimes invalidate statutes depraved policy or establish judge-made rules thereby serving the ends of upright policymaking. It is easy seeing how realists are capable of criticizing legal formalism. In an instance whereby a formalist judge adheres to the statute’s plain meaning, that might result in its application even in instances where it will be harmful and converse to the intents of its drafters (Tamanaha, 2009).

Moreover, other realists contend that legal formalism was, in fact, fraud; apparently, judges do not adhere to the plain meaning, rather, the so-called formalist judges decided on the basis of their own policy inclinations and then dressed up the outcomes in the language of legal formalism. Although ideology performs the work, it is the responsibility of legal formalism to ensure that it looks pretty (Tamanaha, 2009). In spite of the realist critique, of late, legal formalism has been formulating a comeback.

The main reason for the rejoinder is the realization that intense versions of realism make it extremely difficult to understand what the law is according to the decision of a judge regarding a certain case (Tamanaha, 2009). The point of hard law, i.e. determinates legal rules that draw comparatively “bright lines”, is that they give certainty, stability and logic to the law. Purposes present less guidance, and there is a possibility of various judges having different views concerning what the true objective of the rule might be (Tamanaha, 2009).

These two points of views are at conflicting ends of the legal scale; in one perspective, with legal realism, there are

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism vs Realism Essay”, n.d.)
The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism vs Realism Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1462822-the-constitution-and-problems-of-interpretation
(The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism Vs Realism Essay)
The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism Vs Realism Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1462822-the-constitution-and-problems-of-interpretation.
“The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism Vs Realism Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1462822-the-constitution-and-problems-of-interpretation.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism vs Realism

British imperialism

Nevertheless, as Johnson points out, not all the members of colonial administration or British intellectuals dealing with the problems of relations with ‘natives' were racist; he refers to progressive views of Mary Kingsley, David Livingstone and others that contravened the dominant racist discourse (2003, p.... In the first section of this Chapter, Stereotyping the coloniser and colonised, Johnson argues that one should make certain distinction between racism as an ideology of superiority of some biological races of humankind over the others, and racialism, which is, in his interpretation, merely a use of category of race in social sciences (2003, p....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Rules Are an Essential Component of Every Legal System

Is it possible to severe rules from any legal system The theories of legal philosophy are looked into in order to determine how they view rules and what roles do they conceive that rules play in the legal system.... Some induction is applied in this regard because the theories are not always explicit with regards to rules....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Abstraction and Practicality in Legal Philosophy

he mental stimulations and practical value of jurisprudence is best studied and determined from the tension of the dichotomies of theoretical traditions particularly between legal positivism and natural legalism, legal formalism and legal realism, public choice theories and critical legal studies, liberal and socialist-progressive ideologies, indeterminacy/mystification and determinacy of judicial decisions, and of subjectivism and structuralism....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Joyce and Beckett

The announcement of Samuel Beckett's death on December 22, 1989, brought tributes from all over the world acknowledging Beckett as a truly original writer of this century.... James Joyce was linked with Beckett in the many memorials as an important figure in Beckett's artistic development.... hellip; Although this manuscript was in its final stages when Beckett died, it serves also as a tribute to both Samuel Beckett and James Joyce, two of the most important authors of the twentieth century. ...
26 Pages (6500 words) Book Report/Review

The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent

Primarily and most importantly, jurisprudence is the study of the sources of law.... The present study is a work on particular jurisprudence since it seeks the correct positioning of the doctrine of judicial precedent within the English legal system.... For the purpose, it is necessary to see jurisprudence as classified as particular jurisprudence and general jurisprudence....
26 Pages (6500 words) Thesis

Game Theory: Ludology Versus Narratology

Over the past decades, discussions and debates pertaining to the video game phenomenon have become highly popular not only among the academicians but also the general public.... In twenty first century, the lives of millions and millions of people from across the world are substantially influenced by video games (Pratchett, 2005)....
43 Pages (10750 words) Coursework

Investigating LMD Practices in Private Sector in Oman

5Research Philosophy 5To scrutinize the efficacy of the LMD practices in the Omani private sector 7Ontological and epistemological considerations of the present study 7Critical realism is a philosophical approach which is used to describe an interface between the natural and social worlds.... It suggests that mainstream economic relies on dedudivists methodology, embraces an uncritical enthusiasm for formalism and despite its failures, it believes in strong conditional prediction....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Global Legal Realism

The historical origin of this influence can be traced back to the middle ages, which faced the problems of the conflicts between the church laws and the sate laws.... This is a formalist perceptive of law which is being strengthened by the binary division emerging Some scholars have furthered the realism and common sense approach to comparative law by arguing that laws can be effectively studied separately from the surrounding concerns and environment.... he aim of this treatise is to explore and examine how western approaches like realism and the common sense approach to various business values and ethics have influenced legal studies in comparative law....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us