StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The politics by Aristotle - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In discussing the concept of the slave, Aristotle makes a clear distinction between those individuals who are considered slaves as a result of one nation conquering another and those who ‘natural slaves.’ …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.7% of users find it useful
The politics by Aristotle
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The politics by Aristotle"

The Politics by Aristotle In discussing the concept of the slave, Aristotle makes a clear distinction between those individuals who are considered slaves as a result of one nation conquering another and those who ‘natural slaves.’ Physically, Aristotle says the slave is constructed in such a way as to make him suitable for the tasks required by manual labor while the master is given a more upright carriage suitable for military life, other civic duties and managerial occupations. However, Aristotle recognizes many intellectual and spiritual differences between the master and the slave as well, making it possible for those naturally built to be slaves to have the spirit of a master and those built to be masters to have the spirits of slaves. After describing what is meant by the ‘natural slave’ and distinguishing him from the common animals, Aristotle goes on to distinguish what separates the slave from the master. To place the discussion in context, Aristotle first defines what the slave is within the greater society, “the slave is an animate article of property; and that subordinates, or servants, in general may be described as instruments which must first be present before other, and inanimate, instruments can be used” (Aristotle, 9-10). Within this description, the slave becomes an instrument of action essential for the functions of daily life within the household, not only serving the master, but “also belongs entirely to him, [and has no life or being other than that of so belonging]” (Aristotle, 11). Therefore, the ‘natural slave’ emerges as “Anybody who by his nature is not his own man, but another’s, is by his nature a slave; secondly, that anybody who, being a man, is an article of property, is another’s man; and thirdly, that an article of property is an instrument intended for the purpose of action and separable from its possessor” (Aristotle, 11). This concept of a natural slave is strongly based upon this concept of actually belonging to someone else. “A man is thus by nature a slave if he is capable of becoming … the property of another, and if he participates in reason to the extent of apprehending it in another, though destitute of it himself” (Aristotle, : 13). The natural slave, although his body is used to serve the daily living activities of the master, is still above the status of the animals because he does not blindly follow the instructions of the master but instead willingly concedes that the master is of greater reason. Aristotle distinguishes between the natural slave and the freeman by the quality of their goodness: “any goodness of a higher value, such as belongs to temperance, fortitude, justice and the rest of such moral qualities” (Aristotle, : 34). Because slaves would necessarily have to possess some form of goodness for society to function property, Aristotle indicates that while all peoples have some form of moral goodness, those of noble character have a higher purpose to their goodness and a different character: “Fortitude in the one, for example, is shown in connection with ruling; in the other, it is shown in connection with serving; and the same it true of the other forms of goodness” (Aristotle, : 36). The Odyssey Eumaios represents the perfect slave for Homer because he has remained dutiful and true to his master through all the years of Odysseus’ absence, found on Odysseus’ return still tenderly caring for the swine and busily occupied in the business of the estate. In listing the many things Odysseus has done for him, Eumaios makes it clear that for him, Odysseus himself is god: “gave me possessions, / A home and a portion and a wife wooed by many, / Such things as a good-hearted master gives his servant” (62-64). This is further emphasized when he talks about longing to again see his mother and father, but that his longing to see his master is even greater. “I am in awe to speak his name, stranger, though he is not here. / For he loved me exceedingly and cared for me in his heart. / But I call him ‘honored sir’ even when he is far away” (145-147). Despite this, Eumaios is shown to have been of noble birth in a faraway land – having been raised within the rich house of a nobleman and then purchased as slave by Laertes in his youth. In addition, Eumaois embodies the generous and hospitable spirit of the man he serves, making it clear that the house of Odysseus, although currently overrun by unworthy young men, was of the very noblest houses of the ancient world. Although he continues to berate the young men that have moved into Penelope’s house, he also continues to take care to send only the best meats available because he knows this is the type of hospitality Odysseus himself would expect to any guests of the house regardless of how welcome, or unwelcome, they might be, “I watch over these swine and protect them myself / And I make a good choice and send them the best of the swine” (107-108). He will put up with no lies or flatteries, telling the disguised Odysseus, “Do not blandish me or charm me at all with lies, / As I shall not respect and befriend you for that” (387-388). Finally, he pays proper homage to the gods as he prays that his master should return home, “He began by cutting the hairs of the head off the shining-tusked boar, / Threw them into the fire, and prayed to all the gods / That many-minded Odysseus return to his own home” (421-423). In many ways, Eumaios conforms to the idea of the natural slave that Aristotle describes. He is humble and completely devoted to the service of his master, Odysseus and his family. He is forever speaking in favor of them as if they were standing beside him and is willing to allow that Odysseus’ reason was far above his own. While Eumaios displays a great deal of goodness within his own daily activities, he is not responsible for the greater issues of justice and protection that would have been expected of him had he kept his original birthright. As a swineherd, Eumaois is not responsible for producing things for his master, either, but instead for the proper maintenance of the livestock so that Odysseus would continue to have appropriate instruments for the types of hospitality and offerings that were expected of the great houses. However, Eumaois does not fit the mold of the ‘natural slave’ perfectly. One of the glaring examples is his noble birth in the home of a wealthy individual. Because he is kidnapped by his nanny and taken away to be sold as a slave, he is not, strictly speaking, the ‘natural slave’ born to serve others but is instead a slave merely by accident of conflict. This becomes somewhat blurred, however, as it is also apparent that he comes from a faraway land, which Aristotle describes as barbarian, regardless of their level of civility. In addition, there are many instances where Eumaios is seen to act on his own, without permission or knowledge of his master or mistress, but always in keeping with the greater good of the estate. In taking on an additional servant out of his own funds, Eumaois is seen to be operating in the higher levels of goodness than is typically permitted to the slave class and not within the realm of the ‘natural slave’ described by Aristotle. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The politics by Aristotle Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
The politics by Aristotle Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1542066-the-politics-by-aristotle
(The Politics by Aristotle Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
The Politics by Aristotle Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/politics/1542066-the-politics-by-aristotle.
“The Politics by Aristotle Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1542066-the-politics-by-aristotle.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The politics by Aristotle

Plato versus Aristotle Political Philosophy

This essay "Plato versus aristotle Political Philosophy" analyzes the views of aristotle and Plato towards governance.... aristotle's main objective is to analyze how different organizational structures work in each state.... The essay focuses on their views towards self-interest and property....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Critique of Aristotle's Politics

[Name] [Module] [Instructor] [Date] aristotle's Politics Introduction The notion of government is a prominent consideration in the Greek and Roman philosophy.... In the development of his work, aristotle makes a comparison of different government structures by introducing criteria.... Benefits and disadvantages are associated with the types of government that aristotle discusses in his classification of empires.... Discussion One of the first political structures aristotle refers to is a monarchy....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Define the Words Myth and Allegory

To start with the discussion, we are first asked to define the words myth and allegory.... A myth can be a sacred story that relates the orgind of the world or how the world and the creatures in it came to have their present form.... In popular use, a myth is something that is widely believed but false much like an urban legend....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Aristotles Politics

aristotle's Politics, written around 350 BCE, enquires into how best people should be governed.... 1 aristotle's ideas are derived to some extent from independent thought, and to some extent he bases them on empirical evidence-what he actually saw and experienced.... In his book, Politics (as also in his Ethics) aristotle looks among other things at the political and the contemplative life, discussing what is involved in each type of life, and which one of these is preferable....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ancient Political Thinkers - Socrates/Aristotle/Republic, Politics

380 BCE) provides the Socratic dialogue concerning the order and character of the City-State and the dialogues in the book, among Socrates and various Athenians and foreigners, are noted for the discussion about the… Significantly, the first book of The Republic offers proposes different definitions of justice such as returning debts owed and helping friends and Socrates finds these definitions as inadequate in certain contexts, because they lack rigidity....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Critique of Aristotle's Politics

It will analyze the ethics of aristotle against the way today's governance.... This paper will offer an informed critique… The paper will discuss the prepositions of aristotle and the merits and demerits associated with each leadership. aristotle politics looks at the world scientifically and can differentiate the ideal and the practical.... According to aristotle, the philosopher king is the ideal governance.... When the respectable leadership of a monarchy becomes rogue, aristotle terms it as tyranny....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Aristotles Political Theory

In the paper “aristotle's Political Theory” the author looks at a Greek philosopher, logician, and scientist, who lives between the 384BC and 322BC.... aristotle was a pupil of the great Greek thinker Plato.... Along with Plato aristotle is considered to be one of the most influential of the ancient thinkers.... hellip; The author states that in his school aristotle taught his pupils to place the greatest emphasis on what they observed around them....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Political Theories: Machiavellis Prince and Aristotles Politics

This book review "Political Theories: Machiavelli's Prince and aristotle's Politics" presents a comparison of Machiavelli and aristotle's political theories in distinguishing legitimate political goals and creating manipulated images in the minds of the subject.... Machiavelli and aristotle have also come to present a similar effect by mirroring humanism....
11 Pages (2750 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us