StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans" highlights that the U.S. gets the benefits of having skilled Asian and Asian Americans, and the ability to maintain control over their political, social, and economic growth through labeling them as foreigners…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans"

When Chinese immigrants encountered racial oppression and exclusion in the U.S., they equated the mistreatment with their loss of civil rights and freedoms because both the U.S. and Chinese governments failed to protect them from racism and oppression, while the same governments ensured that Chinese Americans did not experience racial equality in the U.S. First, the Chinese government, instead of allowing Chinese Americans to thrive in the U.S., had kept them under a tight leash through oppressive surveillance and control practices. The Chinese government also countered any opposition or criticism from Chinese Americans, thereby making them inferior to other Americans who have freedom of speech. Second, the American government did not exactly stop China from controlling Chinese Americans in the U.S. The U.S. did not protect Chinese Americans in Americans soil because it continued to see the latter as suspicious illegal aliens, even after World War II. Furthermore, the U.S. government did not take positive actions to create equal conditions for Chinese Americans. It practiced racial profiling as a means of cleansing the U.S. of suspected communist Chinese Americans. This statement, “Chinese in the United States were subjected to a highly institutionalized structure of dual domination?” means that Chinese Americans had two lords in the U.S. - the U.S. government and the Chinese government. Both governments subjected Chinese Americans to racial oppression and exclusion, as already explained in the first paragraph. World War II did little to ease racism and oppression against Chinese Americans. Although President Roosevelt compelled the U.S. Congress in 1943 to repeal the Chinese exclusion laws, he did so because it was an essential military strategy. He also replaced it with a less stringent exclusionary law through the immigration quota system. During the Cold War, instead of improving the rights and liberties of Chinese Americans, the U.S. government practiced racial profiling to denaturalize or deport suspected or real communist Chinese Americans. Many Chinese Americans stayed silent and assimilated to show the U.S. that they were not bound to China or to communism. It was effective for them because it decreased American actions against them. 2. The effect on the atomic bombs on Japan and its economy is that, at first, the Japanese got angry at their military leaders, and many accepted that their nation should never launch another war, while the Japanese economy severely suffered initially because of lost jobs and the destruction of cities during the atomic bombing. First, after the atomic bombing, the Japanese remarkably felt more resentment for their military forces than the U.S. government. They did not harbor any racist feelings against the U.S., although some resentment developed during the opportunist actions of the U.S. toward Japan when the Cold War started. Second, the atomic bomb negatively affected the economy of Japan, where the unemployed reached 13 million and demobilized Japanese soldiers became beggars. The Japanese persevered by working closely with the Allied forces in forming a new government structure and new policies that affected its way of life. For instance, a new constitution was ratified in 1946, which guided the Japanese government toward a more democratic era. The Japanese constitution in 1946 laid out the preservation of the emperor as the symbol of unity of the people and renunciation of future wars. By preserving the Emperor, the Japanese were able to hold on their ancient cultural symbols, which helped them persevere during these trying times. The Japanese people received greater democracy in how members of the government were selected and removed too. Furthermore, changes in agrarian and labor laws improved satisfaction among peasants and workers. These changes enabled many farmers to own their own lands, while workers were allowed to form and participate in trade unions. By 1970, Japan became a world power despite the obstacles because of the combination of initiatives and partnerships between governments and private enterprises. The U.S. provided private and public assistance, while the Japanese government gave tax incentives and high depreciation allowances. Japanese banks made loans easy to get too, which improved entrepreneurial activities. Political changes happened also, which improved the ability of the government to encourage trade and business. Japan Prime Minister Yoshida improved relations with Russia and expanded trade with China. Succeeding Prime Ministers worked hard on preserving internal control, while expanding the economic growth of Japan. 3. The Model Minority is not entirely a myth because it is true that many Asian Americans are excelling in different fields. The truth lies in the capacity and will of Asian Americans to go beyond difficulties and to achieve the American Dream of a good life. David Bell gave examples of Asian American grocers, restaurant owners, musicians, writers, and doctors, among others, who are successful in their various endeavors. The positive effects of the Model Minority are that Asian Americans have become resilient to any form of racism and oppression and have become more focused on their ambitions in life. For example, Bell talks about the high rate of admission of Asian Americans into the top American universities. These statistics implicate that Asian Americans have the same chances as whites in entering prestigious universities, which, in turn, can open economic, social, and even political, opportunities for them. The Model Minority improves access to opportunities and enables Asian Americans to dedicate themselves to their pursuit of a good life. The good stereotypes of the Model Minority are good if they reflect the real needs, interests, and realities of Asian Americans. Bell provides numerous examples of Asian Americans who did well in the U.S. because of their hard work and because some of them also finished college and excelled in their fields after completing higher education. If this path is what these Asian Americans truly wanted, then they are benefitting from the good stereotypes that give them credibility in schools and the fields where they wish to flourish. The good stereotypes are bad, however, if they mask underlying racial oppression, which Frank Wu explains. Wu asserts that the Model Minority is a myth because Asian Americans are not true equals in American society. They are paid less in the same jobs where there are whites, and not many of them enjoy career growth, including promotion to the highest ranks of American international corporations. In other words, Wu argues that the Model Minority stereotype is bad if it makes American society blind to racism against Asian Americans, and by being blind to it, they are not doing anything to resolve it. Asian Americans should not fight the Model Minority stereotype if it inspires them and gives them economic, political, and social opportunities, but they should fight it if the Model Minority has become a political ploy for hiding the true realities of some Asian Americans who are not doing as well or are not pursuing the same paths as the mainstream Asian Americans. In reality, Wu provides a realistic portrayal of the Model Minority stereotype: It is good if it helps some Asian Americans succeed in America, but it is bad, if it hides racial oppression. 4. There was a huge difference in the status of Asians born in America both before and after the 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act because after 1965, the U.S. government lifted prior immigration restrictions and exclusionary laws, which resulted to a spectacular influx of new Asian immigrants into the U.S. After 1965, exclusionary laws were relaxed, and so many Asian refugees and relatives became free to enter and to live and work in America. Numerous Asian professionals also found better economic opportunities in the U.S. They were part of the Asians who used family reunification as a way of reuniting with their families by bringing them to the U.S. In other words, after 1965, Asian Americans experienced less immigration restrictions, thereby boosting their presence in America. With greater numbers, furthermore, Asian Americans were able to form ethnic/racial communities that strengthened bi-racial identities. While some Asian Americans decided to go for full assimilation, to the point of civil assimilation or absence of local values and power struggles, others maintained strong bi-racial identities through their expanding ethnic/racial communities. The U.S. easily exploits Asians and Asian Americans as it simultaneously enforces distinctions that render Asians linguistically, culturally, and racially “foreign” because as Asians, it can see them as vital only to the economy when they are needed, therefore, they are easier to lay off when economic conditions are harder. As for Asian Americans, by seeing them as similar and foreign, the U.S. exploits them through economic oppression, specifically by not providing them the same wages and upward career mobility as white employees. The best examples come from Wu where he states that based on Barringer’s study, whites continue to have better social, economic, and political statuses than Asian Americans, meaning that the latter are paid lower and do not have the same management promotion chances as white counterparts (330). Hence, the U.S. gets the benefits of having skilled Asian and Asian Americans, and the ability to maintain control over their political, social, and economic growth through labeling them as foreigners. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans Assignment, n.d.)
Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1487868-m-essay
(Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans Assignment)
Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans Assignment. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1487868-m-essay.
“Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1487868-m-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Effects of the Model Minority on Asian Americans

Why Asian American males are sexually overlooked (undersexed) in the US

However, the gap is narrowing, possibly due to the effects of increased pollution.... Considering this, it should not be surprising that many women do not consider asian males as likely prospects for sexual partnerships.... asian Birth Rates and its' Consequences While sources indicate that Japan has a lower birth rate than China, both are very low with no signs of an imminent rebound.... Also because asian males are not inclined to share the burdens of domestic duties, women find it increasingly difficult to combine a fulfilling career with marriage and child rearing....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Social Construct: Asian-Americans

In much of the research, Asian-Americans seem to have been constructed in the social psyche as being a “model minority”, a term found throughout the literature (Lowe, 1996).... The term “model minority” refers to the low incarceration rate of this group (Le Espiritu, 2008), as well as high household income (Siegel, 2012).... Image 1: Bruce from Get Smart (Segal, 2008) This social construct of the “model minority” has even permeated into the new media....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Asian American Immigration And Cultural Politics

The question of how do immigration, integration, and membership play a role in upholding the status of Chinese americans in the twenty-first century, in order to achieve a better and prosperous future for tomorrow's America is worth giving a thought.... The paper "asian American Immigration And Cultural Politics" focuses on the American immigration policy regarding asian immigrants in an attempt to evaluate and analyze the American legislation....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Asian Americans before 1952

hird, Lowell High School, in San Francisco, is a frequently mentioned example of the negative effects of the “Yellow Peril” designation as an affirmative measure (Allred 69).... First, the a majority of asian americans were… ale workers whose families could no longer be set up in the United States because of the “Aliens Ineligible for Citizenship” designation (Hutchison 19).... Some of these History and Political Science asian americans Before 1952 ALIENS INELIGIBLE FOR CITIZENSHIP The designation “Aliens Ineligible for Citizenship” made the immigration of Asians to America non-existent....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Proposal

Respose paper for an Asian-American studies

They are portrayed as weak, model citizens and invaders of business in Asian American Actor/Actress in American Media and Asian American society Asian American Actor/Actress in American Media and Asian American society Introduction asian americans constitute an approximate four percent of the total population of people living in America.... The singing, chorus lines, magic shows and dancing at the Forbidden City created a chance for asian americans to display their talent and spread positive awareness of Asian American among the audiences....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Model Minority Stereotype

It is stated that the model minority within the borders of a certain country refers to a group achieving higher results in various spheres of their lives.... Model Minority Stereotype the model minority within the borders of a certain country refers to a group (ethnic, religious) achieving higher results in various spheres of their lives.... At the same time, the stereotype might form distorted perception of Asian Americans among other groups as well as ‘white' Americans: in education it may result in envy and uneven treatment towards the students and other students feeling discriminated whereas Asian Americans are ‘given their grades for the fact they belong to the model minority' (Lim)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Inequality in Policy Making to Asian American Group

Asian Americans are not considered to have social and economic problems due to the model minority image and the group is considered as economically successful.... In the paper “The Inequality in Policy Making to Asian American Group” the author focuses on the social issues of asian americans.... Even after 200 years, asian americans are unable to gain equal rights and are subjected to hostility and harassment.... At present whenever there is a problem in the United States, be it economic, political or social, asian americans are targeted with hostility, singled out and unjustifiably blamed....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Race and Ethnic Relations: Asian Americans

Melanin is the first line of defense of the body against the ill effects of the ultraviolet rays in the sunlight (Harris, 112).... "Race and Ethnic Relations: asian americans" paper is about the concepts of race and racism that the author had prior to taking this course compared to the current concepts.... The blacks are from Africa, white people are from Europe and the yellow people are from the asian continent....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us