StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Barriers to Prisoners Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism by Weiman - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article, titled “Barriers to Prisoners Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism by D.F. Weiman”, sets out to evaluate the impact of a prison record/experience on former inmates’ opportunity of getting employed in high-end or low-end labor markets…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Barriers to Prisoners Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism by Weiman"

‘Journal Article Critique: Barriers to Prisoners’ Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism’ Overview The article, titled “Barriers to Prisoners’ Reentry into the Labor Market and the Social Costs of Recidivism”, sets out to evaluate the impact of a prison record/experience on former inmates’ opportunity of getting employed in high-end or low-end labor markets. The author puts forth arguments from the demand and supply sides of the labor market paradigm to demonstrate the barriers that former inmates’ face in their quest to reenter into the job market, as well as how these barriers contribute to increased cases of criminal recidivism. The author also demonstrates how some policies serve to harden low-level inmates into more serious offenders (Weiman, 2007). Clearly, the article demonstrates the importance for all stakeholders to embrace effective reentry programs for former inmates, with the view to enabling them find employment and hence reduce recidivism because the labor market is integral to the successful integration of released inmates into their families and communities. Description of the Research Problem The underlying research problem which the author attempts to address is the misalignment between current reentry policies and practices as illustrated within the United States criminal justice system and the opportunities available for former inmates to reenter into the labor market, hence minimizing recidivism (Weiman, 2007). Research Methodology The author does not conduct a primary research but rather uses primary sources (mostly surveys) to conduct a quantitative empirical analysis of the barriers to prisoners’ reentry into the labor system as well as the social costs of recidivism. Contributions to the Literature This article makes important contributions to existing literature. Apart from clearly analyzing the problems that affect former inmates as they attempt to get absorbed into the labor market, the article provides a breakdown of total social costs of recidivism to include (1) additional harm from post-release activity, (2) administrative costs associated with subsequent activity due to recidivism, (3) years of life lost during imprisonment, (4) disruptions to and burdens on families, (5) attrition of neighborhood social capital, (6) political estrangement, and (7) distrust of public authority (Weiman, 2007). Another important contribution is that the War on Drugs policies have done more harm than good, particularly in turning an increasing number of small-time drug offenders into repeat hardcore offenders. This view has been reinforced by Krontiris and Walter (2010), who argue that the 1973 Rockefeller Drug Laws have helped to not only fuel an unprecedented growth of individuals imprisoned in the U.S., but also to harden small-time offenders. Still, the author rejects the claim made by a number of scholars that a prison record is a trajectory to secondary labor market; on the contrary, the author suggests that a previous criminal record or experience acts as “a profound institutional barrier that prevents those on the socioeconomic margin from getting their foot in the doors that lead out of the secondary labor market” (Weiman, 2007 p. 597). This view receives support from Wikoff et al (2012), who suggest that many employers in the formal labor market view a prison record as an end rather than a means to a career prospect for inmates, irrespective of level of educational achievement. Article Critique As already mentioned, the researcher relied on conducting an empirical analysis on other primary sources to investigate the topic. A more befitting method, however, would have been for the researcher to conduct an original primary research with all the parameters needed not only to enable him focus on specific issues of interest, but also achieve a higher level of control over how the information was to be gathered to answer the study’s primary objectives. Overreliance on secondary sources of information often leads to biased and invalid results. The author’s approach to supporting the thesis did make some sense, though he failed to effectively demonstrate how the problems in supply and demand sides of the labor market were related to instances of recidivism and the policies already put in place to fight recidivism. Indeed, although the article is robust in its attempt to demonstrate how problems in supply and demand sides of the labor market complicate issues for released prisoners as far as securing employment is concerned, it is weak in connecting these problems of reentry to policies that have already been put in place by various agencies to ensure successful reentry. In their seminal work on prisoner reentry process, Bahr et al (2005) demonstrate how problems within the supply side of the labor market (e.g., deficits and challenges in behavior, lack of educational background and work experience, and negative stereotyping by neighbors and community) could be successfully dealt with by exposing inmates pending release to induction programs to prepare them morally and psychologically on what they are to experience once released back into the society. To better prepare prisoners in the context of these challenges, Gottschall & Armour (2011) advocate for local- and state-level corroboration, effective offender risk assessment, and graduated responses to criminal activity, whereas Pinard (2010) emphasizes the development and implementation of correctional facility reentry units that will permit returning offenders to better prepare for release close to their communities. Similarly, the author illustrates how supply side problems to the labor market, including employers’ negative reactions to prison record and complex legal environment requiring firms not to employ people with prison records, continue to negatively influence chances for released prisoners to get employment, hence increasing recidivism (Weiman, 2007). However, the author fails to connect these problems not only to their effects on recidivism, but also to the alternatives available to deal with them. Luther et al (2011) acknowledge that many small-time offenders are driven back into crime by a society that is so unresponsive to their needs, including the need to be employed. On his part, Pager (2006) opines that crime and recidivism are social constructs fueled by the same processes and systems that have been put in place to eliminate them. For example, while some correctional policies stress the importance for society to absorb released inmates into the labor market, other policies instruct managers not to entrust former inmates with particular jobs in the formal sector, implying that former prisoners will forever be relegated to low-skilled labor market (Gottschall & Armour, 2011; Weiman, 2007). Such an approach obviously leads to recidivism. Moving on, it is clear that the researcher employed the methods for doing secondary research correctively. The researcher, in particular, acknowledges the sources of his information and also attempts to explain what he did with the data in the process of analysis. He also rightly separates the sources as surveys, audit reports and agency data, among others. The researcher has ably followed the traditions for doing secondary research. However, he fails to elaborate where he got the sources from as well as the inclusion and exclusion criteria used. Conclusion Overall, the article is an eye-opener in terms of evaluating the problems that act as barriers to inmates’ reentry into the labor market from the demand as well as supply domains of the equilibrium. References Bahr, S.J., Armstrong, A.H., Gibbs, B.G., Harris, P.E., & Fisher, J.K.F. (2005). The reentry process: How parolees adjust to release from prison. A Journal of Theory, Research & Practice about Men as Fathers, 3(3), 243-265. Gottschall, J., & Armour, M. (2011). Second chance: Establishing a reentry program in the northern district of Illinois. DePaul Journal for Social Justice, 5(1), 31-69. Luther, J.B., Reichert, E.S., Holloway, E.D., Roth, A.M., & Aaisma, M.C. (2011). An exploration of community reentry needs and services for prisoners: A focus on care to limit return to return high-risk behavior. Aids Patient Care and STDs, 25(8), 465-481. Krontiris, K., & Walter, C. (2010). Rethinking prisoner reentry in Harlem. Harvard Journal of African American Public Policy, 16(1), 73-84. Pager, D. (2006). Evidence-based polices for successful prisoner reentry. Criminology & Public Policy, 5(3), 505-514. Pinard, M. (2010), Reflections and perspectives on reentry and collateral consequences. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 100(3), 1213-1224. Weiman, D.F. (2007). Barriers to prisoners’ reentry into the labor market and the social costs of recidivism. Social Research, 74(2), 575-611. Retrieved from http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE%7CA168397567&v=2.1&u=lirn99776&it=r&p=GPS&sw=w Wikoff, N., Linhorst, D.M., & Morani, N. (2012). Recidivism among participants of a reentry program for prisoners released without supervision. Social Work Research, 36(4), 289-299. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Barriers to Prisoners Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism by D.F. W Article, n.d.)
Barriers to Prisoners Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism by D.F. W Article. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1893677-barriers-to-prisoners-reentry-and-social-costs-of-recidivism
(Barriers to Prisoners Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism by D.F. W Article)
Barriers to Prisoners Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism by D.F. W Article. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1893677-barriers-to-prisoners-reentry-and-social-costs-of-recidivism.
“Barriers to Prisoners Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism by D.F. W Article”. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1893677-barriers-to-prisoners-reentry-and-social-costs-of-recidivism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Barriers to Prisoners Reentry and Social Costs of Recidivism by Weiman

Mellow Assignment #2

ccording to the article in the Prison Journal, prisons in California are facing an increasing threat of overcrowding and high service costs.... Most of the prisoner classification is dependant on the prisoner's sentence length, the study found it to be inappropriate which increases the costs for the prison.... While most of the prisoners weaken as captives, others get stronger and prove to be more Summary The of California has seen an alarming rate of prison violence in the past and the recent tragic event of the stabbing of Correctional Officer Manuel A....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Crime and punishment

Riding the Bus: barriers to Prison Visitation and family management Strategies.... The study also involved observation of family members during family support group meetings for prisoners' families and related activities for a period of 200 hours (Christian 35).... In addition, the study involved open-ended interviews with prisoners' family members.... The Main Findings of the StudyThe study established that many prisoners are never visited by their family members for a variety of reasons....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Prisoners rights

A right can be broadly defined as a fundamental rule that is allowed or owed to people in reference to some established legal system ethical theory or social convention.... Under theories of justice, rights are of crucial importance in relation to disciplines such as law and… This paper therefore seeks to explore the legal rights of prisoners in a jail setting that are assumed and give an opinion thereof. The Maricopa County jail system is regarded as one of the Legal Rights of Prisoners in a Jail Setting A Case of Maricopa County Jail System Insert Semester A right can be broadly defined as a fundamental rule that is allowed or owed to people in reference to some established legal system ethical theory or social convention....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Social media and prisoners assignment

While this discussion holds the view that it is appropriate to allow prisoners to have access and use of the social media, it is also important to look at… First, for those opposed to social media access and use by the prisoners, allowing prisoners to access and use social media to connect to the outside world is tantamount to an insult to the This is because, allowing the prisoners to access and use social media is placing the victims and the families of those affected by the crimes at the mercy of the prisoners, for perpetual threatening, insults and further torment....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Experiment of the Guards and the Prisoners

The paper presents the experiment which conducted in Stanford University involving randomly 24 selected college students to test the hypothesis that the guards and the prisoners are the cause of the abusive behavior in prison was a successful experiment to explain why chaos exist in the prisons.... hellip; It's also mentioned that the students selected to act as guards and prisoners brought out the concept very clearly.... The struggle between the prisoners and the guards was adapted very well....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Recommendation and rationale the idea of building prisons

percent reduction in recidivism as explained by Drake, Aos, & Miller (2009), helps in combating crime, compared to the expense of building more prisons.... The Effects of Prison Sentences on recidivism.... Evidence-Based Public Policy Options to Reduce Crime and Criminal Justice costs: Implications in Washington State.... Imprisonment leads to an increase in crime if the prisoners do not get a chance to improve their skills or behavior....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

SOCIAL PROBLEMS: Crime : Recidivism

The pressure from parole Thoughts, Concerns and Solutions for recidivism Thoughts and Concerns about recidivism There are several concerns that face repeat offenders that see them return to prison after serving a jail term.... The pressure from parole officers may play a role in recidivism.... Reducing recidivism: The Challenge of Successful Prisoner Re-Entry.... om/paul-heroux/reducing-recidivism-the-c_b_929510....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Violent, Overcrowded Prisons Negatively Affects Society

Currently, more than two million prisoners are jailed in local, state or federal facilities.... Not only the number of prisoners is increasing, but the ratio of prisoner to population is also widening as well.... “At midyear 2003 there were 4,834 black male prisoners per 100,000 black males in the United States in prison or jail, compared to 1,778 Hispanic male inmates per 100,000 Hispanic males and 681 white male inmates per 100,000 white males”....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us