StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Minorities and Disabled People - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
"The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Minorities and Disabled People" paper discusses the nature of one aspect of disadvantage, namely under-representation, and in the process illustrate how this is experienced by ethnic minorities and people with disabilities. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Minorities and Disabled People
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Minorities and Disabled People"

Discuss the nature of one aspect of disadvantage and show how this is experienced by ethnic minorities and disabled people An understanding of the ways in which society has been constructed will help people realize that however systems and social contracts were conceived, maintained and implemented in order to achieve equality in societies, the reality is that certain sectors and groups will be continually marginalized or at least disadvantaged. This is especially true for democratic societies, particularly the Anglo-European and the American, which have espoused tolerance and embraced multi-culturalism as a part of their social foundation. The upshot is due to the teeming number of groups within the communities they have been incessantly plagued by issues regarding disadvantaged social groupings. This paper will discuss the nature of one aspect of disadvantage, namely under-representation and in the process illustrate how this is experienced by ethnic minorities and people with disabilities. Disadvantage Jorge Gracia and Pablo De Greiff, wrote that “social structures do not exist as reified entities or as states, but rather as processes in the rules and expectations according to which we act, and in the way in which the results of previous actions have intentionally and unintentionally shaped the physical and the social environment in which we now live.” (p. 11) They argued that these structures create social positions that condition the opportunities and lives of people. To quote: Each of the differentiating factors by which a group is constituted might on its own be inconsequential or neutral with respect to the distribution of opportunities for the members of the group. But together they can form a structure, a web of constraints that puts the members at a significant disadvantage with respect to non-members. (p. 11) Sociology defines a group as one constituted not only when all members share the same characteristics with one another, but also when members stand in a particular relationship to nonmembers. (American Journal of Sociology, p. 453) And so, a relational account of group identity leaves open questions about the status of the claims raised by particular groups. The freedom granted to the constituents of American society empowers certain group to assert its supremacy which in the long-run become detrimental to minorities as policies are created according to the perspective of the dominant groupings. Under-representation One of the most significant aspects of disadvantage is the underrepresentation. It holds true for all of the minority groups across all societies as well as the people with bodily impairment. Most sociologists agree that the lack of opportunity becomes the dominant reason behind its incidence. John Edwards (1995), in his book, When Race Counts, observed that this disadvantage is consisted of “discriminatory barriers (either direct or indirect, intentional or unintentional), greater relative disadvantage (interpreted as higher proportions of minority group members suffering from disadvantage, or minority groups on the whole suffering higher levels of disadvantage, or both), different forms of disadvantage – and hence special need – or a compounding of disadvantages that would enable us to speak of racial disadvantage as a specific type of a more generic concept.” (p. 9) There are two manifestations of this underrepresentation wrote Edwards. The first is that members of affected groups do not have equality of opportunity to compete for and obtain desired positions and statuses while the second is comprised of the relatively greater, or different, social and economic disadvantages from which minorities suffer. (p. 8) Ethnic Minority The US Voting Rights Act and a series of its amendments has been the proof to the disadvantage and underrepresentation of Blacks and Hispanics in the US. For instance, the 1982 amendments to the statute kept the basic provisions intact but made some significant changes. Citro, Cork and Norwood (2004) provided us with the details: The amendments extended the preclearance requirements of the act until 2007 but provided that Congress reexamine them in 1997. Another provision stated that the standard of proof for judging an election law to be discriminatory was no longer discriminatory intent, but rather discriminatory result… Still another provision stated that minorities had no right to proportional representation as part of the totality of circumstances in cases brought under the Voting Rights Act. (p. 51-52) Citro, Cork and Norwood also explained how the redistricting plans and municipal annexations diluted the voting power of the minorities. One of the examples is the scheme of dividing concentrations of minority voters into adjoining majority-white areas, minimizing the number of minority districts by placing minority voters in as few districts as possible. Another example of disadvantage and underrepresentation of minorities is underscored by the controversial case of the murder of Stephen Lawrence. In April 1993, he was repeatedly stabbed to death in southwest London by a gang of white youths. No one was convicted of the racially motivated murder to date. A commission called to investigate the case reported that there was a gross miscarriage of justice, starting from the way the police handled the investigation and the entire criminal justice system for its “collective failure to provide an appropriate and professional service to people because of their color, culture or ethnic origin. It can be seen or detected in processes, attitudes and behaviour which amount to discrimination through unwitting prejudice, ignorance, thoughtlessness, and racist stereotyping which disadvantage minority ethnic people” (MacPherson 1999, p. 28) The lack of representation from among the minorities in the criminal justice system in Britain as stipulated above is seen as one of the reasons why the minorities are discriminated upon due to ignorance about their existence which translates into the lack of policies which could have sought to protect their rights and ensure respect for their beliefs. This is the same in other aspects of the British society. The “unfamiliarity” with regards to cultural differences, community mores and family expectations affect the ability of the dominant groups to understand. Hence, there is a tremendous impact on the ability of the minority group members, say, to compete in the merit system, on the range of choices open to them as well as the extent to which pursuit of a career can be a priority seems evident. Disability Anthony Giddens (2006) explained that “bodily ‘abnormality’ is seen as causing some degree of ‘disability’ or functional limitation – an individual ‘suffering’ from quadriplegia is incapable of walking, for example. (p. 281) This functional limitation is seen as the basis for a wider classification of an individual as an ‘invalid’. In his social model of disability, Giddens argued that disability could further be defined in social terms, that is, disabilities is understood as no longer a problem of an individual, but in terms of the social barriers that people with impairments face in participating fully in the society. According to the Union of Physically Impaired Against Segmentation (UPIAS), disability becomes “the disadvantage or restriction of activity caused by a contemporary social organization which takes no or little account of people who have physical impairments and thus excludes them from participation in the mainstream of social activities.” (Finkelstein 1993, p. 9-16) A specific example of disadvantage among the disabled concerns that of education. The underrepresentation of disabled people is “shown and attributed, in part, to problems of access, teaching methods and attitudes.” (Stromstad, Booth and Nes 2003, p. 133) Schools across the US is still viewed as less “welcoming” to disabled students, calling for an increase in recognition and policymaking that would assure the disabled as an integral part of the academic community. Stromsad, Booth and Nes illustrated one specific case regarding inclusion by referring to the Quality Assurance Agency Code of Practice which was established in the UK. This Code is intended to identify a comprehensive series of system wide expectations and authoritative reference points for institutions in order to assure academic quality and standards of programs, awards and qualifications. The Code referred to the disabled students in 24 precepts, establishing the aims of the abovementioned academic quality assurance. Particularly Soremstad, Booth and Nes highlighted the following precept: Precept 4: information for applicants, students and staff The institution’s publicity, programme details and general information should be accessible to people with disabilities and describe the opportunities for disabled students to participate. (Stromsad, Booth and Nes, p. 134) Here, it was explained that disabled students are only supposed to participate where there are ‘opportunities’, and only when these are ‘described’ to them. According to Stromsad, Both and Nes, “institutions are asked, in this case, to ‘consider implementing arrangements that ensure that information is clear, accurate and accessible. The verb to ‘consider’ cancels out any requirement to ‘ensure’ and simultaneously cancels out inclusion” (p. 134) While it appears that the precepts on disabled students encourage inclusion certain provisions are glaringly opposing it such as the following: It may appear that the needs of the disabled students are not central to institutional survival and should therefore give way to issues of ‘higher’ priority. (p. 133) Inclusion, which was an important element in reducing the incidence of disadvantage among the disabled students, is discarded by the Code, first, by insisting on demonstrating measurable outcomes and then by the unspecified threat of a negative QAA report. The Logic of Affirmative Action Affirmative action has been viewed as the solution as underrepresentation of minorities and the disabled now receive more attention than before. In affirmative action, the idea is to reduce underrepresentation by means of outreach, encouragement, training and so on. Specifically, affirmative action came to encompass a form of discrimination in favor of underrepresented groups, as opposed to an effort to abolish all forms of discrimination. (Weiskopff, p. 4) Perhaps the stringent implementation of the public policy in this regard has brought about a paradigm shift on disadvantage, particularly among the Black populace. A study by William Bridges and Wayne Villemez (1994), for instance, found that: Black workers were slightly more likely to have access to structured mobility opportunities and a lot more likely to have access to due process, grievance arrangements, and bureaucratic work control… What this means is that conventional theories of ubiquitous minority disadvantage are in need of substantial revision. (p. 101) Critics argued that is a superficial way of addressing the disadvantage. Such approach, understandably ignores the underlying social and economic inequalities. To cite further example, it has been argued that in school people ought to be judged based on merit and not gender or race and that abolishing affirmative action in education will result to a far more decisive factor in admission decisions. Hence, for some, the approach is inadequate for a number of reasons. John Edwards, for instance, pointed to the lack of any precision about goals to be achieved and how progress towards them is to be measured or about how procedures of affirmative action will operate in practice to reach desired ends. (p. 22) However, we take note of the study mentioned elsewhere in this paper which showed the changing landscape of disadvantaged minorities. And so, we set stock on the assumption that positive action becomes a remedy for past disadvantage that is a complement to, rather than a substitute for a general program for ending discrimination. The idea, said Edwards, is to make up for the disadvantage rather than compensate for the harm done by the incidence of discrimination. (p. 24) This aspect of addressing disadvantage has been upheld by the Race Relation Act in Great Britain and the Title VII and the Fourteenth Amendment in the USA. Again, we are reminded of the significant strides the society has achieved several aspects of disadvantage. African Americans are now better represented in society while statistics showed the representation of Asian-Americans more than tripled between 1991-1992 and 2001-2002. (Brym and Lie, p. 506) This paper also underscores the fact that the portrayal of racial minorities, the poor, people with disabilities and women still reinforces the conventional, mainstream and negative stereotypes of the disadvantaged. In the media, for instance, non-whites tend to portray comical and criminals characters in films and media materials. As long as this system continues to feed our concepts of each other, disadvantage will be in our midst. References Bridges, W. and Villemez, W. (1994). The Employment Relationship: Causes and Consequences of Modern Personnel Administration. Springer. Brym, R. and Lie, J. (2004). Sociology: Your Compass for a New World. Thomas Wadsworth. Finkelstein, V. (1993). The commonality of Disability." In Swain, J., Finkelstein, V., French, S., Oliver, M., (Eds.) Disabling Barriers - Enabling Environments. London: Sage Forbes, C., Cork, D., and Norwood, J. (2004). The 2000 Census, Counting Under Adversity. National Academies Press Edwards, J. (1995). When Race Counts: The Morality of Racial Preference in Britain and America. UK: Routledge Giddens, A. (2006). Sociology. Polity Gracia, J. and De Greiff, P. (2000). Hispanics/Latinos in the United States: Ethnicity, Race and Rights. Routledge. MacPherson, W. (1999). The Stephen Lawrence Inquiry. The Stationery Office. Somerstad, M., Booth, T., and Nes, K. (2003). Developing Inclusive Teacher Education. Routledge. "The American Journal of Sociology." (1963). University of Chicago Weisskopf, T. (2004). Affirmative Action in the United States and India: A Comparative Perspective. Routledge Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Coursework, n.d.)
The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Coursework. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1708593-sociology-discuss-the-nature-of-one-aspect-of-disadvantage-and-show-how-this-is-experienced-by-two-of-the-following-groups-a-women-b-ethnic-minorities-c-disable-people
(The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Coursework)
The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Coursework. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1708593-sociology-discuss-the-nature-of-one-aspect-of-disadvantage-and-show-how-this-is-experienced-by-two-of-the-following-groups-a-women-b-ethnic-minorities-c-disable-people.
“The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Coursework”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1708593-sociology-discuss-the-nature-of-one-aspect-of-disadvantage-and-show-how-this-is-experienced-by-two-of-the-following-groups-a-women-b-ethnic-minorities-c-disable-people.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Nature of Disadvantage and How This Is Experienced by Ethnic Minorities and Disabled People

Computer Technology Opens a World of Work to Disabled People

The author's thesis statement is "Fast computers and broadband connections have become so inexpensive and reliable that location is now not an issue for certain jobs (Joachim 2006 2). … "Computer technology opens a world of work to disabled people" by David S.... Many disabled people are willing to work and actively seek employment that suits their needs as laborers.... disabled people have the right to work if they are able just like any other person in the world....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Race and Ethnicity in Education

This is perhaps the best policy, because people who do not want to give up their own nationality too can become citizens of Britain and get the benefits.... This means, an individual's mindset about Britain and its citizenship mainly depends upon the treatment he received from the British people after migrating here, the stereotyped models the individual has maintained in his mind and also the prejudiced or unprejudiced attitude he had developed over the years, either aided by the local population, or totally unaided....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

How to Tackle Financial Exclusion Effectively

hellip; The first question anyone would ask is why would anybody be excluded and how could anybody exclude them The answer to these questions is not difficult.... In the simplest of terms, financial exclusion is when the people of any community or financial status are excluded from the general financial system of the country and generally with very severe consequences for the people who are excluded and the society in general.... So a certain group of people are excluded from the financial system , so how is this bad and most importantly , how does this effect you and me After all we are not a socialist or a communist country where everybody should have access to everything and we besides we already know that system has failed....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Equality of Disabled People

Established in 1972, the group is an independent organization which champions the right of equality of all the disabled people regardless of physical, sensory, mental ill health conditions.... Many disabled people internalize the negative message of the Medical model that all their problems stem from not having 'normal' bodies.... The internalized oppression can make disabled people less likely to challenge their exclusion from mainstream society....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Legislatures governing Equality Opportunities

The main challenges would include meeting the needs and aspirations of the people of the EU, especially in work areas like electronics, content and services including public servicing and the development of specialised skills for its people.... However this may create risks and difficulties upon underprivileged citizens, especially minorities, and they may not be aware of their rights and privileges under the law.... Under the provisions of Employment Equality Act 1998, of Ireland, any form of discrimination, on the basis of sex, marital or family status, sexual preferences, religion, age, race, colour, nationality, ethnic or national origins, presence of disability, and membership of traveller community is illegal and unenforceable....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Atitudes and perceptions of coaches on disabled people

The paper starts by… ducing the statistics of disabled people and goes ahead to suggest how they are perceived by the coaches and the rest of the population in terms of participating in sports.... Systematic approach has been chosen in order to evaluate and critically analyze the attitudes and perceptions of coaches on disabled people.... The key sentence “Factors Influencing Perception and attitude of coaches towards disabled people” was used in the different search engines to locate the required material....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Revision of Employment Law

Upon Appeal, the Employment Appellate Tribunal (EAT) held that the ET had not considered the full facts of the case, including the fact whether working from home would remove the disadvantage she was presently undergoing.... Therefore, the essence of employment status would lie in the characteristics of the terms and conditions governing employment, whether on a contractual capacity or in an independent nature....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

A Theory of Middleman Minorities

he examples provided by Bonacich (1973) in the article for a group of people appropriately representing 'middleman minorities' include the Jews in Europe, the Chinese in Southeast Asia, Asians in East Africa, Armenians in Turkey, Syrians in West Africa, Parsis in India, as well as Japanese and Greeks in the United States (p.... It could, therefore, be noted that these groups of people come from diverse ethnic, racial and cultural orientations and migrate to a foreign land which is different from their native homeland....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us