StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Native American Policy - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper aims at discussing legal issues, law integral to the policy on the above explained topic on the Native American policy. On several occasions, the American troops would lash out against the peaceful Indians, and as result the aggression was out of control…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Native American Policy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Native American Policy"

? NATIVE AMERICAN POLICY ANALYSIS Unit Introduction After the civil war, in 30 years the government policy of theNative Americans wanted to shift from forced separation to integrating to American society. The attempts to Americanize the Indians only had hastened the death of their presence and culture in America (Anderson & Benson, 2006). After the aggression, the objective of the policy was to combine the Native Americans in the American society. There were many attempts at this which were made, from offering the citizens to grant lands to the Indians, but all these attempts were in vain, but the results of the policies were the same as continued aggression. The government policy towards the Native Americans aggressive did not tolerate their presence in West. Americans and tribal leaders were able to compromise with the land arrangements and living situations. Since the Americans did not comply with the situation, it resumed the conflict and the beginning of the Indian Wars started which killed 5 Americans and resulted to over 1000 deaths of both Native and White Americans. From this point, the American policy was to force the Indians out of their land, force them to accept the treaties which resulted to fighting. On several occasions, the American troops would lash out against the peaceful Indians, and as result the aggression was out of control (Lyden, 1999). In that regard, this paper aims at discussing legal issues, law integral to the policy on the above explained topic on the Native American policy. Additionally, the discussion will include how this law conflicts with the second amendment and the supremacy clause of US constitution. Indian policy had shifted from the destructive mindset to a soft line and a peaceable policy. When the Indian Wars ended the Wounded Knee Battle, the battle had resulted to over 200 deaths, and all these marked change in the Indian policy. However, although the change had begun, the policies had begun to be kind, and therefore, the peace commission created a reservation policy. The policy provided the grant of landholding of the Native Americans, and replaced the tribal communal holdings. The 1906 Bruce Act also allowed the Indians to acquire citizenship if they left their own tribes, and eventually the Native Americans were granted citizenship in 1920. However, the intentions of the policy toward the Indians had shifted, and the outcomes of the policies helped suppress the Native Americans, in addition to their culture (Anderson & Benson, 2006).Though the policy had been created with good intentions, it had also had some reverse effects which helped in eliminating the Native Americans. Additionally, the policies did nothing to qualm or fight the Indian wars. It also had various negative effects on the Native Americans where it broke many reservations as well as lost much land to the whites. The Native American policy also killed the Native American culture and Indians left their tribes to attain the American citizenship. Although various benefits were created to save and benefit the Native Americans, the policy did nothing in helping the Indians as well as Native Americans and as a result, the Indians as well as their culture died out. This policy received a lot of criticisms from politicians and the Easterners, which brought a change in the policy. Although the policy was less bloody, they did not help in alleviating the Native Americans problems, and many times they worsened the problems. To add to this, attitude and the policy were volatile and had the same effects. The integration of the Native American to the American society was created (Lyden, 1999). Hastedt (2004) claims that, the Native Americans are indigenous individuals living in North Africa and United States and other parts of Alaska. They are composed of a number of states, ethnic groups and states, many of them who survived the political communities. They are also called the American Indians, most of whom lived as hunters and gatherers in the society, as well as matrilineal. The expansion of the American-European population after the revolution led to increased pressure on the Native American land, which brought about a policy which authorized the government to relocate the Native Americans to the south. However, they continued to live in the South and organized themselves as tribes by a number of states and the federal government. They carried a strong resistance in United States as well as a series of Indian Wars. The U.S forced a number of series, in terms of land and treaties by the tribes, as well as created reservations for the Natives in Western states. The U.S government encouraged them to adopt their way of farming and other similar pursuits. Anderson & Benson (2006) defines the Native American policy as operations and laws that was adapted and developed in the United States in order to outline the relationship between the federal government and the Native Americans. When the United States became independent, it is said to have adopted the policies of Europe in regard to Native Americans, but over the two centuries, it adapted its own varying wide policies in regard to necessities and changing of its perspectives of its supervision. However, in order to administer the government’s U.S Native American policies, the congress came up with a new agency in the department of war called the Indian Affairs Bureau, which worked closely with the U.S army in order to enforce such policies. Lyden (1999) contends that the federal government recognized the American Indians as independent, self-governing communities with a variety of cultural identities. However, there are times the government tried to force the Indians to leave their culture, as well as give up their land in order to assimilate their American culture. The U.S policies in regard to the Native Americans were influenced by the desire to increase the west territory that the Indian tribes had occupied. In order, to calm such fears, the U.S government held a meeting with the treaty of Fort Laramie and other Indian tribes, that allowed each native American tribe to accept a territory that was bounded, as well as allowed its government to construct forts and roads in the territory and gave a pledge of never to attack the settlers. In return, the government agreed to honor each tribe’s territory as well as pay the Indians annually. However, this law conflicts with the second amendment and the supremacy clause in the US Constitution.  The peaceful treaty between the Indians and the federal government did not last long, because the government broke its promise to the Indians after they heard of their fertile land and mineral wealth. This is how the Native policy came about, where the U.S government restricted the Native Americans to a small piece of land within their group territory, in order to give more land to non-Indian settler (Lyden, 1999). The government also forced them to give up their lands and occupy the reservations, and as a result gain protection from attacks by the whites. The Native Americans were also paid yearly for food, livestock, and money among others. Such reservations are said to create attempts to help clear a way for the U.S involvement and expansion in the West, in addition to keeping the Indians separate from the whites to reduce conflicts. Contemporary presidential statements, court decisions and statutes provide a strong support for the tribal government (Hastedt, 2004). For example, First Amendment makes sure that the legal tribal regimes survive as manifestations of sovereign indigenous powers, instead of creating federal laws. However, in order to keep this law, the Bill of rights do not apply to such actions of the government in regard to tribes because the First ten amendments binds the federal government and its agencies, but not to other independent sovereigns like the Indians. Some of the legal issues regarding the Native American policy, are where the Supreme court affirms that the native tribes imposes taxes on the Native American policies, as well as tried to place some limits on sovereign tribes powers. Additionally, the Supreme Court held that the sovereignty tribal does not include the power to connect to foreign relations, alienate as well as to wage war in any tribal land and imposing criminal punishments to the tribe non-members. Additionally, it also restricts the tribe’s power in order to regulate the activities of the Native Americans. Consequently, the Supreme Court acknowledges its decisions in limiting the tribal powers in the First Amendment in the U.S constitution (Hastedt, 2004). In order, to monitor the government interference, the Supreme Court rejected the efforts by local governments and states to regulate the Indian activities, and came up with the First Amendment in regard to tribal government, where it claimed that, any tribe is free to make its choices on matters such as family life, economic organization and environmental quality without any interference from the government. Therefore, the Native American policy was going against the Amendment by forcing the Indians to move out of their land in order to expand their boundaries (Anderson & Benson, 2006). Conclusion The Native American policy was to force the Indians out of their land, force them to accept the treaties, which resulted to fighting. On several occasions, the American troops would lash out against the peaceful Indians, and as result the aggression was out of control. However, the government policy towards the Native Americans was aggressive and did not tolerate their presence in the West. Americans and tribal leaders were able to compromise with the land arrangements and living situations. This law conflicts with The Supreme Court and the First Amendment because, it claims that any tribe is free to make its choices on matters such as family life, economic organization, and environmental quality without any interference from the government. Therefore, the Native Americans had a right to own land in the U.S boundaries. References Anderson.T & Benson.B (2006), Self-determination: the other path for Native Americans.Standford, Calif: Stanford Univ.Press. Hastedt,G.P (2004), Encyclopedia of American Foreign Policy. New York: Facts On File. Lyden.F( 1999), Native Americans and Public Policy. Newyork: University of Pittsburgh Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Native American Policy Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1391973-native-american-policy
(Native American Policy Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1391973-native-american-policy.
“Native American Policy Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1391973-native-american-policy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Native American Policy

American History 1865 to Present. Native Americans

geared for its aggressive expansion policy, the native tribes were pushed further away losing not only their land status and identity as a whole.... government to compensate the natives for their loss by way of reformative laws which included abolishment of the restrictive policies and introduction of measures to assimilate them within the mainstream american society.... 1866: The Powder River Indian Expedition The Powder River Indian Expedition refers to a full scale offensive launched by the american Army against a group of Native Americans namely the Sioux, Cheynne, and the Arapaho Indians, during the gold rush (Clodfelter, 1998)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Development of U.S Policy towards Native Americans and Tribal Government

native american is basically the original people who belong from the regions of North America and some parts of Alaska.... "Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That all non-citizen Native Americans born within the territorial limits of the United States be, and they are hereby, declared to be citizens of the United States: Provided, That the granting of such citizenship shall not in any manner impair or otherwise affect the right of any native american to tribal or other...
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

History of Native Education in the British North American Colonies

Internal colonialism was materialized by the Europeans through dislocating the Native peoples by their expansionary ways; by segregating and limiting the Native Americans in the reservation system; through forced integration of native american societies; political and economic supremacy of reservation matters by the colonizers; and promoting racial outlook on Native people.... What Structural Disadvantages did native Children Face?... To What Extent have These Disadvantages Disappeared, and What Factors were Responsible for the Change? The drawbacks of the internal colonial… Since their arrival in North America, the colonizing European societies found ways of suppressing the native values and ways of life....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The New Politics of Public Policymaking

The paper "The New Politics of Public Policymaking" highlights that the nation witnessed severe conflict over the issues of busing and affirmative action, but this time people realised the power of their opinion and stood up for their rights that ultimately forced the government to develop policies....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

The U.S. Policy toward Native Americans in the 19th Century

Jefferson believed that native american should give up their culture and beliefs to blend in with the Western Europe Culture.... Jefferson believed that native american should give up their culture and beliefs to blend in with the Western Europe Culture.... Similarly, President Jackson instigated forced resettlement of native american tribes from the Southeast to west of the Mississippi River.... ndian removal refers to the policy forced by the government of the United States for the relocation of native american tribes from the east of the Mississippi River to its west....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

The Effects of American Imperialism on Native Americans

It further reveals certain important features of the american policy frameworks on the natives.... hellip; This essay analyzes that the attitude of the United States in its formative years toward indigenous peoples caused a profound, lasting effect on the native american populations of the United States.... The American foreign policy on the natives of America began from the period of foreign invasion.... This paper will examine the short- and long-term impact of american expansionism on Native Americans....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

How native american were treated

An Indian Holocaust is a term used by the american Indians to describe the mass destruction of the Indian population following the European colonization.... Genocide is not a new phenomenon as the american Indians experienced it when colonialists burnt down their villages and shot all people including women and children.... In United States, the native Americans are the local people… They constituted a large number of different tribes, ethnic groups, and the colonization of the Americas by the European nearly destroyed the culture and the population of the native Americans....
5 Pages (1250 words) Personal Statement

Development of U.S Policy towards Native Americans and Tribal Government

native american is basically the original people who belong from the regions of North America and some parts of Alaska.... policy towards Native Americans and Tribal Government" discusses the background of Native Americans and tribal government in the United States, their lifestyles along with the reaction of the United States government towards them.... Native Americans are said to be the sole and native originators who encompassed America before the advent of other discoverers, this is why they are given many titles; such as, Native Americans, american Indians, Indians, Red Indians, Original Americans, Red Men, Amerindians, Indigenous, Aboriginals, and Amerinds....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us