StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Coercive Interrogation Analysis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Coercive Interrogation Analysis " it is clear that generally, constitutional protections against the use of coercive interrogation techniques exist to protect the innocent, which every person is ideally presumed to be until proven guilty.  …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
Coercive Interrogation Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Coercive Interrogation Analysis"

Because of the strict observance of the protections without exception, the ability of the law to constrain state violence is severely limited.
Recently, news reports and videos publicized the use of coercive interrogation techniques on suspected and known terrorists under incarceration. Investigations disclosed government memoranda which argued that such methods were of utmost necessity due to the threat to the nation. Furthermore, the use of coercive interrogation is not per se illegal, because (1) humanitarian Geneva Conventions could not be applied to the case of suspected Al Qaeda terrorists; (2) coercive interrogations conducted in Guantanamo Bay were conducted under the special maritime and territorial jurisdiction of the U.S. and were not covered by the statute; and (3) the president as commander-in-chief has the constitutional authority to disregard treaty or statutory prohibitions in addressing the “war on terror”.

Many legal authorities both in government and the private sector disagree with this position. Their common observation is that the United States has “departed from the international consensus on norms and rules for military engagement”, but it does so in a manner that does not ignore or transgress international humanitarian law (IHL). Rather, the US reinterprets the IHL such that it permits for the advancement of its political agendas, giving the departure from the norm a semblance of legitimacy.

On the other hand, what some see as a liberal and self-serving reinterpretation of the law, others view it as a necessary development of law to enable the country to respond to contemporary realities. To address present-day threats to the nation, the extra-legal measures model is seen as necessary and applicable for “truly extraordinary occasions”. “The seemingly absolute prohibitions of torture in international and U.S. law have hidden ambiguities and exceptions, which in turn create space for argument and manipulation – and for lawful torture. Most significant is the idea of necessity as a criminal defense and a justification for state violence”. It is thus that some forms of state violence are prohibited by law, but the law also allows for exceptions that permit the limited or justified use of violence. Coercive interrogation is on such form of violence thus legitimated.

Liberal use of violence is never an option. The choice lies between the absolute ban of torture, or selectively exempting certain cases. “Necessity” provides the requisite criterion and defense for the justified use of coercive interrogation by the state in individual cases. It is generally accepted that limited use of violence should be employed only under specific conditions, such as where imminent danger is to be averted, and only when the violent deed is the last and only recourse possible. The option to resort to extreme measures for the sake of self-protection should always be left open to the State. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Describe and discuss the ways in which the laws and legal limitations Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1580568-describe-and-discuss-the-ways-in-which-the-laws-and-legal-limitations-in-the-united-states-have-impacted-the-use-of-coercive-interrogation-techniques-then-discuss-what-we-lose-and-what-we-gain-from-these-legal-constraints
(Describe and Discuss the Ways in Which the Laws and Legal Limitations Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1580568-describe-and-discuss-the-ways-in-which-the-laws-and-legal-limitations-in-the-united-states-have-impacted-the-use-of-coercive-interrogation-techniques-then-discuss-what-we-lose-and-what-we-gain-from-these-legal-constraints.
“Describe and Discuss the Ways in Which the Laws and Legal Limitations Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1580568-describe-and-discuss-the-ways-in-which-the-laws-and-legal-limitations-in-the-united-states-have-impacted-the-use-of-coercive-interrogation-techniques-then-discuss-what-we-lose-and-what-we-gain-from-these-legal-constraints.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Coercive Interrogation Analysis

Psychology Research Paper: How to Get a Confession

Under this technique, prior to the actual interrogation process, suspects are usually interviewed in an informal, non-custodial setting where they are not usually informed of their rights.... This non-accusatory setting would help the interviewer build rapport with the suspect and to lull the suspect into a false sense of security; this informal process also helps the investigator gather information which can later be used to break the suspect's defenses during the actual interrogation process (Perillo and Kassin, p....
25 Pages (6250 words) Research Paper

Why Should Government Be Limited on How and When It Asks Questions

hanged the analysis of the Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination from a totality of the circumstances test for voluntariness to whether those subjected to custodial interrogation by police were advised of their rights.... As mentioned in the book: Approximately 80 percent of criminal cases are solved by less than a full confession, and a study on the success rate of current police interrogation techniques indicated that police interrogations produce at least some incriminating information in 45 to 65 percent of cases....
3 Pages (750 words) Coursework

Application Assignment: Video Analysis: Confession to a Homicide

running head: Confession To A Homicide Confession to a Homicide Video analysis Submitted to [Pick the date] A critical analysis of the video of Michael Crow's confession helped in understanding that the detectives were not aware of the techniques that should be used with juvenile suspects.... Given that this session is an interrogation and detectives realize the sensitivity of the issue i.... In the given case, the tone was highly coercive and accusatory....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

A landmark case: Miranda v. Arizona

Subsequently, Miranda was arrested and two police officers took him to an interrogation room.... n order to justify their inequitable actions, the police stated that Miranda, as an ex-convict, was expected to be familiar with the process of interrogation.... In the paper “A landmark case: Miranda v....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Gaining Confessions

'Connor & Maher (2009) indicated that there are “four major areas of concern to address to reduce future wrongful convictions incidents: false confessions, inadequate investigations, mistaken eyewitness identification, and delayed, absent, mistaken, or improper forensic analysis” (par.... The discourse would identify the different types of confessions; delve into the relevant aspects of interrogation, and present some recommendations to prevent or minimize the possibilities of generating false confessions....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Constitutional Law: Activity Search Warrant Exceptions

rom the article it is apparent that there are personnel that specialize in interrogation thereby facilitating suspects' confession over crimes committed.... In the article Robert Glenn is indicated as formidable detective, with a specialty in interrogation.... Moreover, it seems there are special facilities used to interrogate suspects for instance Danial Williams describes the interrogation room as a small room with a small table and a small chair where the interrogator sits in front of you a question and asks you questions....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Why Do People Confess to Crimes They Did Not Commit

The paper "Why Do People Confess to Crimes They Did Not Commit" states that since most criminals are extroverts, the methods of interrogation that are designed to effectively deal with the typical extrovert criminal may have an overwhelming impact on a suspect who is an easily-conditionable introvert....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

Confronting Terror: Coercion

In the following report 'Confronting Terror: Coercion' the author discusses coercion in the interrogation process, which is a new technique that gained major attention when it came to light in the Bush Administration after the September 11 attacks of 2001.... Coercion involves using certain harsh interrogation methods including waterboarding, starvation, and hypothermia....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us