StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

U.S. Supreme Court Tennessee vs. Garner - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
Various socio-legal institutions including the courts and the police are often expected to give expression to the collective conscience of the society. Though, it is a fact that the collective conscience is quiet a complex and multifaceted notion…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
U.S. Supreme Court Case Tennessee vs. Garner
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "U.S. Supreme Court Tennessee vs. Garner"

Download file to see previous pages

The various arms and appendages of law while towing the practical manifestations of their powers do sometimes give way to special situations that alter and remold the conscience of a society and bring them under direct and enhanced observation and scrutiny of the masses and the intelligentsia. Infact such instances happen to be the important turning points in the legal and judicial history of any nation and do many a times lead to the evolution of the existing statutory provisions in the light of the current and emerging changes in the society.

US Supreme Court case Tennessee vs. Garner is one such thought provoking event in the legal history of the US that strikingly challenged the existing statutory provisions pertaining to the use of force by the law enforcement agencies and called for reinterpretation and reshaping of this earlier taken for granted aspect of the policing in the US. October 3, 1974 was one other usual day in the life of the Memphis Police Officers Leslie Wright and Eton Hymon, when they were ordered to respond to a "prowler inside call".

Both the officers promptly arrived on the scene of crime and after receiving relevant feedback from the neighbors, proceeded to scan the house being targeted. Hymon noticed a person running across the backyard and with the aid of his flashlight, was reasonably able to discern that the suspect, Edward Garner was an unarmed teenager of slight built (Findlaw, 2008). When Garner tried to climb over a fence, Hymon shot him in the back of his head to prevent him from escaping from the scene of crime (Findlaw, 2008).

Later on a paltry ten dollars and a ring stolen from the house being scanned was found on the body of the suspect. Hymon acted in direct exercise of the authority given by a Tennessee statute to its police officers, sanctioning a deadly use of force so as to apprehend a fleeing suspect (Findlaw, 2008). The father of the deceased teenager filed a suit in the Federal District Court, to seek damages for the death and violation of his son's constitutional rights (Findlaw, 2008). The District Court upheld the constitutional credentials of the given statute and declared the officer's actions to be legal and valid (Findlaw, 2008).

However, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, while responding to an appeal by the appellee-respondent, reversed, stating that the use of force against a fleeing suspect in pursuance of the requirements of the Fourth Amendment is subject to be qualified in the light of the criteria of reasonableness (Findlaw, 2008). The basic issue that this case brings to fore is the ascertaining of the constitutionality of the deadly use of force by the law enforcement agencies against an unarmed, fleeing suspect (Findlaw, 2008).

It questions the gross generalization of the provisions pertaining to the use of force by the law enforcement agencies against the relatively innocuous suspects who try to flee. Should the nature or proportion of force used by a police team against an escaping terrorist be same as that used against a harmless teenager, who attempts to escape from the scene of some petty crime This case highlights the human rights of the fleeing suspects and pragmatically checks the unrestrained use of force by t

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“U.S. Supreme Court Case Tennessee vs. Garner Study”, n.d.)
U.S. Supreme Court Case Tennessee vs. Garner Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503387-us-supreme-court-case-tennessee-vs-garner
(U.S. Supreme Court Case Tennessee Vs. Garner Study)
U.S. Supreme Court Case Tennessee Vs. Garner Study. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503387-us-supreme-court-case-tennessee-vs-garner.
“U.S. Supreme Court Case Tennessee Vs. Garner Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503387-us-supreme-court-case-tennessee-vs-garner.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF U.S. Supreme Court Case Tennessee vs. Garner

Can the President Persuade The Supreme Court to Support His Policy Positions

This paper 'Can the President Persuade The supreme court to Support His Policy Positions?... Government lawyers, and principally the Solicitor General of the USA, are unavoidably caught up in the conflicts produced by the President's tentative association with the supreme court.... The thorny relationship between the President and the supreme court concerning the development of constitutional law has different consequences for different individuals who happen to be government lawyers at any given point in time....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

BC Supreme Court Ruling on Physician-Assisted Suicide

The paper "BC supreme court Ruling on Physician-Assisted Suicide" describes that the Canadian government has the power to influence people and persuade the society concerning the desirability of the policies, the ruling of the court is implemented thus prohibiting physician-assisted suicide.... In this case, the paper will conduct an analysis of the issue related to the BC supreme court ruling on physician-assisted suicide using Canadian politics concepts....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Teva and Sandoz court case

Teva was suing for copyright infringement, but Sandoz argued that patent was invalid as it did not outline… The case at the supreme court involved the question of whether the US Court of Appeals for Federal Circuit should review a fresh the defense provided at the district Court judgment for ‘clear error'. According to eral Rule of Civil Procedure 52 (a) (6), the Court of appeals ‘must not.... The supreme court in a 7-2 majority held when reviewing District's Court resolution of subsidiary factual matters made in the course of construction of the patent claim, the Federal Circuit must apply a ‘clear error' and not the de novo standard of review....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

The Selection and Description of Supreme Court Justices

The paper 'The Selection and Description of supreme court Justices' presents the US supreme court Justice System which is on par in terms of power and influence as the President and the Senate.... The US supreme court is mandated to uphold the Constitution in any issue.... It is thus of extreme importance that a supreme court judge be thoroughly cognizant of the US Constitution and to be able to set aside ideologies whether social, political or cultural....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

The Supreme Court - Standing and the Impact of Massachusetts v Environmental Protection Agency

The study "The supreme court - Standing and the Impact of Massachusetts v Environmental Protection Agency" discusses the reasons for the supreme court's decision in the Massachusetts case to dilute the standards for standing, the role of the new approach in the supreme court, etc.... hellip; This conclusion established that the government of Massachusetts, representing the entire population of the state, had demonstrated, “injury, causality and redressability” and, therefore, was entitled to standing in this appeal before the supreme court....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Tennessee V. Garner 1985 and Making of a New Force

The incident was thus described as Edward garner, an apparently unarmed felon, tried to flee the crime spot and a police officer, Elton Hymon chasing him, shot him in the back of his head while he was trying to climb over a 6-feet-high fence in order to elude the arrest; and as a result, the victim died during a surgical operation at a hospital.... The case study examines the conditional liabilities of the police department and the tennessee statute during the prosecution and after the verdict by the Apex Court of the US....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

The Decision of the Supreme Court in Autoclenz V. Belcher

This work "The Decision of the supreme court in Autoclenz V Belcher" describes the case, the role of employment law.... hellip; In this case, the main question to attend to was as to whether the claimants were actually workers, by taking into consideration the already existing regulations such as the 1998 working time regulation (WTR) and the 1999 national minimum wage regulation (NMWR).... The claimants later placed a case at the employment tribunal seeking to be recognized as workers considering the definition of a worker by the WTR and MNWR....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

The Case of the Supreme Courts Decision Regarding Hobby Lobby

The main focus of the paper "The Case of the supreme court's Decision Regarding Hobby Lobby"  is on examining such aspects as individual rights, freedom, liberty, philosophical interpretation, “On Liberty”, “tyranny of the majority”, “undemocratic” system.... Yet, rather than concluding their discussion with a broad platitude that states that John Stuart Mill would have been opposed to the supreme court's recent decision (five-four in favour of allowing Hobby Lobby to define its own healthcare provision), the following analysis will instead represent a point by point discussion for why this particular analyst believes that John Stuart Mill would have engaged with this issue in the way that will be represented....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us