StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Evaluating Popular vs. Scholarly Presentations of Global Climate Change - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Introduction: Sometimes scientific information is presented in a way that people gets easily convinced and believe wrong things. This paper will evaluate 2 popular and 2 scholarly presentations on global warming and answer some questions.
1. The popular presentations the article of the newspaper and the podcast are presented in an exciting manner…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
Evaluating Popular vs. Scholarly Presentations of Global Climate Change
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Evaluating Popular vs. Scholarly Presentations of Global Climate Change"

Evaluating Popular vs. Scholarly Presentations of Global Climate Change Introduction: Sometimes scientific information is presented in a way that people gets easily convinced and believe wrong things. This paper will evaluate 2 popular and 2 scholarly presentations on global warming and answer some questions.Answer to the questions1. The popular presentations the article of the newspaper and the podcast are presented in an exciting manner. The title of the article is eye catching and people will tempt to read it, as it says there may be an iceless Arctic summer as early as 2040.

On the other hand the scholar presentations are presented in a factual manner, because all the information presented in the article and in the podcast are well referenced and based on the scientific evidence and experimental results.1 (a) The clearest part of the polpular article is Arctic ice will melt by 2100 due to global warming. In the podcast the description of weather and natural beauty and taste of water is clearly understood. The introduction, conclusion and the graphs of the scholarly article are the clearest parts.

Climate change will cause the arctic ice to melt and it will further cause climate change is the clearest idea I got from scholarly podcast.1 (b) Least clear part of popular article is how declines in Arctic sea-ice cover during the winter months would reduce winter precipitation. From podcast it is least clear what 40 scientists are going to do Least clear part of scholarly article is the relationship of plant growth with UV-B. Least clear part in scholarly podcast is the how general circulation model works and how accurate are the predictions 1 The term perturbation is unfamiliar to me.2. The author of the popular article warns us about the danger of global warming.

The director of the popular podcast also trying to communicate the adverse impacts of climate change, but it gives more description of nature. The writers of the scholarly articles describe how different parameters are going to impact plant growth and how the ecosystem or different plant species will adapt to the change. The scholarly podcast gives information how global temperature change will cause the arctic ice to melt and how models work. 3. The presentation style in the popular article is exaggerated and may induce fear among the people about climate change and its effects.

But it is in easy language and it is meant for the general people and they will be able to understand it. The popular podcast also trying to make people aware. The presentation in the scholarly paper comes with graphs, tables and figurers and is also clear for the intended readers. But general people may not understand all scholarly write up because of its specific and scientific nature and they are all not for all types of reader. The presentation style of scholarship podcast is good and in the format of interview (question and answer), so it can attract the attention of audience.

It gives us concept about global warming and its impact on melting of arctic ice.4. For each style of presentation use of chart, graphs, tables and photographs work well. In case of podcast, interview or dialogue works well than monologue. 5. In case of popular presentations writers do not responsibly present information and there are dangers of popularizing science. General people may have misconception about a thing and act in a wrong way. But scholarly articles or podcasts are based on scientific evidence and the risk of communicating wrong information can be avoided.6. By following factual presentation style we can draw attention of people without over dramatizing it.

Like the news headline of the article "Forecast: an iceless Arctic summer; Climate models show a seasonal melting down to open ocean by the year 2100 -- and maybe as early as 2040" could be Forecast: Melting of Arctic Ice due to global warming. Also by using graphs, charts and photographs people's attention can be drawn. Conclusions: It is very important to communicate information accurately, so that misconception among the people about any issue can't occur. This can be avoided by effective communication.

ReferencesPhoenix, G. K. and Lee, J. A. (2004). Predicting impacts of Arctic climate change: Past lessonsand future challenges, Ecological Research, 19, p 65-74.Zarembo, A. (2002, March 16). Forecast: an iceless Arctic summer; Climate models show a seasonal melting down to open ocean by the year 2100 -- and maybe as early as 2040.Los Angeles Times p.A.32.http://a.abcnews.com/podcast/050726blakemore3.mp3, accessed on 27-04-07.Interview with Marika Holland, availed at http://www.exploratorium.

edu/poles/climate.php, accesses on 27-04-07.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Evaluating Popular vs. Scholarly Presentations of Global Climate Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506701-evaluating-popular-vs-scholarly-presentations-of-global-climate-change
(Evaluating Popular Vs. Scholarly Presentations of Global Climate Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506701-evaluating-popular-vs-scholarly-presentations-of-global-climate-change.
“Evaluating Popular Vs. Scholarly Presentations of Global Climate Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506701-evaluating-popular-vs-scholarly-presentations-of-global-climate-change.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Evaluating Popular vs. Scholarly Presentations of Global Climate Change

Multi-Channel Retailing - Global Retail Industry and Costco Wholesale

Multi-Channel Retailing Brief Overview of the global Retail Industry & Costco Wholesale The Retail Industry In relation to the present trend in the global retail industry, it has been recognized that there is an evolving scenario wherein the marketers are highly focused on addressing different needs and desires of the customers.... The global retail operations of Costco can be primarily classified into four major segments such as: Discount and Variety Retail – Warehouse Clubs and Superstores 2....
5 Pages (1250 words) Speech or Presentation

Convention of Citizens for a Greener Planet

The dramatic impact on the Amazon is reflected through the fires and climate change.... NASA satellite data are giving scientists insight into how large-scale deforestation in the Amazon Basin in South America is affecting regional climate.... Something much similar to today's 'commercial' wars with nothing but a global existence of man-eating man....
2 Pages (500 words) Speech or Presentation

Master of Information Systems(personal statement)

hat makes Kelley all the more respected is its forecasts for the global, national and state economies and financial markets.... For more than three decades, the Kelley School of Business has presented its national, state and local forecasts through a series of presentations....
2 Pages (500 words) PowerPoint Presentation

Finicial Evaluation of Techologies

A.... None of the projects fall within the required 2 years time frame. In each case state whether the company would invest the extra capital… (Be careful to take account of all replacements and salvage values during each assessment period.... But in the case of a technology that still has a useful lifetime remaining at the end of a period, do not Analysis of two energy proposals Two electri supply technologies have the following characteristics:   Capital cost Annual operating cost Lifetime (years)Salvage value (/cost) ($)Annual electricity supplied (kWh)Technology A (a sustainable energy option)20 00050020200025 000Technology B (a fossil fuel option)10 000300010-200025 0001....
2 Pages (500 words) Speech or Presentation

Evaluating Learning and Development Activities

evaluating Learning and Development Activities evaluating Learning and Development Activities The purpose of evaluation for different stakeholders The evaluation of learning and development activities serves the needs of various stakeholders.... pproaches and tools for evaluating (with merit for each) The initial basic approach to evaluation is to determine the current performance levels and the skills of the members.... The skills acquired and the learning level can also be measured as a way of evaluating the effectiveness of the programme....
2 Pages (500 words) PowerPoint Presentation

Management of change

Mark Jones has entered the NFW Corporation with an elaborate two-step process through which he will institute change in both the number and specific constitution of the HR trainers.... However, even with such an elaborate plan, there is no doubt that Mark will be faced by the major… The justification for the choice of resistance to change as a major issue that mark will face is informed by the fact that any form of change within an organization is disruptive of the status quo, and for that reason will always face resistance Secondly, the choice of resistance to change as a major issue that Mark will face is informed by the fact that Mark has established a two-stage strategy that seeks to eliminate the weaker trainers and retain the stronger ones, meaning that the weak trainers will certainly apply resistance strategies to ensure that they are not eliminated....
4 Pages (1000 words) Speech or Presentation

Power to Change People Lives

The author of the following paper "Power to change People Lives" argues in a well-organized manner that over the last decade, there have been reports of food contamination by numerous pathogens, the most outstanding one being salmonella.... I hope you take the contents of this letter seriously and change people's lives....
2 Pages (500 words) Speech or Presentation
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us