StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment - Dissertation Example

Cite this document
Summary
Subject: Cruel and Unusual: The End of the Eighth Amendment Justice Brennan found that death penalty is unconstitutional. In Justice William Brennan’s words, capital punishment was “irrational, arbitrary and degrading to human dignity…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment"

Download file to see previous pages

However, the punishment is applied on a trivial number of cases where it has been made compulsory. The punishment is irregularly and unfairly applied. In a country of over 200 people, the Justice Brennan observed that it was applied less than fifty people. As a result, the practice was perceived to be unconstitutional and prejudicial in the circumstances (Bigel, 59). The Justice concluded that the state is expected to confine the convicts in prison rather than kill them arbitrarily. The application of death penalty for the mentally retarded was considered to be unfair and cruel by the eight amendments.

According to Justice Brennan, death treats members of human race in an inhumane manner (Bigel, 51). Capital punishment suggests that human beings can be used and discarded at will. In the Gregg v. Georgia case, it was observed that death in inconsistent with human rights. Justice William Brennan observed that even the vilest criminals were entitled to human rights and human dignity. Civilized treatment of human beings demands that the ultimate fate of a human being should not be made subject to human judgment (Bigel, 19).

According to the premise of 8th amendment, the death penalty violates the premise of civilized treatment as guaranteed in the clause. According to Brennan, death penalty is cruel and should be classified as unusual form of punishment because it is prohibited by the clause. This formed the basis for stating that death punishment violates 8th and 14th amendment. According to Justice John Roberts, in the Baze verses Rees case, the pain experienced in the process of execution does not constitute unusual or cruel death.

He argues that the pain is objectively tolerable risk. Justice john Roberts argued that punishment through execution was the most human method known in Kentucky and many other states. He disagreed with the notion that death penalty is a violation of 8th amendment because is cannot be perceived to be probative with regard to careless killing or infliction of pain (Bigel, 31). He acknowledged that the society is moving towards more humane forms of capital punishment. Death punishment challenges the evolving standards of human decency.

The state is limited when it come to power over human life. According to Justice Potter Stewart, death punishment has a strong history of acceptance and is expected to apply to death row conflicts (Bigel, 39). The arguments against executions are challenged as emotional and unbalanced. Chief Justice Warren in the case of Trop verses Dulles argued that capital punishment does not violate the concept of cruelty as defined by the constitution in the United States. He argued that the punishment is imposed according to the enormity of the crimes or crime committed.

The traditional penalties need to be observed and appreciated according to the law. The chief justice urged the legal fraternity to draw a demarcation through the 8th amendment to deal with the evolving decency standards that are expected to mark a shift of societal perception. However, he suggested that it may not be appropriate to dismiss death penalty in entirety. Capital punishment is said to enhance deterrence. Deterrence is the belief that the severity of a crime can discourage the members of the society from performing criminal acts.

It has been argued that capital punishment is known to cause increased violence rather than reduce it (Bigel, 59). This is referred to as

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1”, n.d.)
Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1482269-cruel-and-unusual-the-end-of-the-eighth-amendment
(Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1)
Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1482269-cruel-and-unusual-the-end-of-the-eighth-amendment.
“Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1482269-cruel-and-unusual-the-end-of-the-eighth-amendment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment

Eight Amendment of the U.S. Constitution - Freedom from Cruel and unusual Punishment

The federal criminal justice system's has developed through the years with the insertion of the 8th amendent, specifically the right of freedom from cruel and unusual punishment.... Specifically, the research delves into the cruel and unusual punishment provisions of the amendments.... George Cole (2006) emphasized cruel and unusual punishment includes death penalty, torture, inhuman and degrading punishment, and excessive fines and excessive deprivations....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Ammendments to the bill of rights of the US Constitution

Other crucial rights covered by Bill of Rights include Freedom to petition as well as the rights to save themselves from unreasonable search, seizure and cruel and unusual punishment.... hellip; They demanded an amendment in the constitution for the protection of people's freedom (Krull, 1999).... The Fifth amendment upholds the rights of people in this case.... Majority of the Bill of Rights were applied to the nation by a sequence of decisions that include the due process clause of the Fourteenth amendment....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The 8th Amendment to the US Constitution

The History of the 8th Amendment The 8th Amendment to the US Constitution states thus: “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed and no cruel, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.... The inclusion of this passage in that law was to limit English courts from imposing punishments and fines that were excessive, cruel and unusual as was the practice of the English courts in the time of the House of Stewarts under King James VI who would impose such punishments such as quartering, boiling alive, disemboweling, decapitation and crushing criminals with heavy weights (Gill 114)....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Cruel and Unusual Punishment

It was later suggested that the death penalty was unusual and cruel, and hence unconstitutional in accordance to the eighth amendment (Mandery 77).... Name: Instructor: Course: Date: cruel and unusual Punishment Capital punishment refers to the legal process in which a person found guilty of specific crimes is put to death by the authorities as punishment for the crimes perpetrated.... Whereas the 8th Amendment of the Constitution of the United States restrains the government from cruel and unusual punishments, the ambiguity of the term ‘cruel and unusual' has over the years fuelled the controversy about the constitutionality of capital p...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Critique Based on American Judiciary Laws

Georgia raised an important question of law on whether the imposition and carrying out capital punishment in that particular case and two others constituted cruel and unusual punishment.... In a five to four decision the court decided that the death penalty ruling did constitute to cruel and unusual punishment and thus violated the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendment.... If this was the case then the ruling on death penalty violated the eighth an Fourteenth Amendments....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Roper v Simmons - Procedural History

Executing convicted felons whose crimes were committed prior to their turning 18 years old is a violation of the cruel and unusual punishment clause of the eighth amendment as well as the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.... ReasoningThe Court recognizes the eighth amendment's preclusion of cruel and unusual punishment, and has established the propriety of referring to “'the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society' to determine which punishments are so disproportionate as to be cruel and unusual....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

ESTELLE v. GAMBLE, 429 U.S. 97 (1976)

The most fundamental issue was to determine if at any case the prison officials violated the cruel and unusual treatment clause of section 42 of the eighth amendment to the US Constitution.... In the presentation, Gamble claimed infringement of his right to fair treatment envisioned in the eighth amendment to the US Constitution by the triple when he was subjected to inhuman punishment leading to his back injuries.... Since the plaintiff, Gamble had been subjected to harsh and severe treatment while in prison, the legal principle most applicable is the eighth amendment protection...
5 Pages (1250 words) Annotated Bibliography

Standards in Death Penalty Cases

the eighth amendment shapes some… The impact of the Due Process Clause on the 14th amendment, has made the application of the 8th amendment against the federal government and those of states.... the eighth amendment Here, courts need to look for factors on how to change the standards of community and also come up with independent evaluation if the statutes are reasonable.... Georgia, the jury invalidated the death penalty regulation at that time because they constituted the unusual punishment and cruelty against the eighth amendment....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us