StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Everything for Sale and The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism - Admission/Application Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper 'Everything for Sale and The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism' aims to compare and contrast the main thesis of two pieces of literature - Everything for Sale by Robert Kuttner and The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism by Daniel Bell…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Everything for Sale and The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Everything for Sale and The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism"

The basic arguments, therefore, are based upon the notion that markets have their limits and the economic tasks performed by the government cannot be replicated by private markets. He also argues that private markets fail to engage in pure research and it’s the responsibility of the government to actually finance such research in order to allow private markets to conduct such research. (Lemann, 1997)

Daniel Bell’s book is based upon arguments that rather than creating individualism, modern capitalism has created a strong culture of standardization. Rather than focusing on creating individualism, modern capitalism has created stronger corporate bureaucracies which are as powerful as Church and state bureaucracies were.  According to Bell, this culture created by Capitalism raises the need for personal gratification for those who are successful and resultantly may not be good for overall work ethics in the society. Ultimately, this culture will invariably hurt the same work ethics which were responsible for the success of capitalism in the first place. Bell argues that capitalism’s very fundamental ethics has now turned against itself and there is an inherent contradiction within capitalism now. (Liu, 2010)

Compare and Contrast

One of the key assumptions of both books is the capitalist system as a supreme form of economic organization. By forming a consensus on the assumption that capitalism provides the best form of economic organization in human society, both the others argue about the instances or issues where markets have basically failed to deliver what was perceived by them.

Both the authors argue that as capitalism is heading ahead, it is creating a society that may not be a healthy and constructive society because it tends to create a wider level of shift into the same ideologies based on which it was founded. Both the authors however disagree on the point of intervention in the market. Kuttner views the large role of government in correcting the situation however, Bell only suggests that it is the culture that emerged as a result of the rise of capitalism that is creating these wider level ethical dilemmas in capitalist society.

Bell's arguments however are historically rooted in the Protestant roots of capitalism and how the early writers and theorists focused upon amalgamating individual aspects of human life with capitalism. This argument may not be relatively plausible because capitalism ultimately is a form of human organization and is based upon the notion of competition. In pursuit of competition, the erosion of moral and individual values may be one of the unwanted consequences.

Kuttner has also restricted his arguments on the role of government and how it can critically subdue the structures created by markets.

Criticism

One of the common differentiating points between the two essays is the role of government and how it can intervene in it to correct the situations where markets fail. Both suggest that it is the government that can actually overthrow the unwanted consequences of the market. The overreaching of market institutions can be improved if the government can intervene however, both the authors have basically failed to take into account the inefficiencies and inherent weaknesses of the government itself. Both the works have been criticized on the pretext that government can have its own limitations and therefore leaving market corrections to the government may further worsen the situation rather than correcting it. The basic argument, therefore, is to let the markets work on their own rather than intervening in them either through government or religion. Another important criticism is the lack of empirical evidence behind the arguments presented in both books specifically against Bell’s work. It has been suggested that Bell has failed to provide empirical credibility to the cultural changes in the US due to capitalism.

It is, however, critical to note that historically government has been successful in fulfilling the gaps left behind by the market. On both the occasions when markets failed and created widespread economic decline i.e. Great Depression and Current economic recession, it was the government which has prevented the society from falling out. So the arguments of both the authors seem valid especially in situations where markets fail and when markets fail, the overall consequences to the society are far greater than the impact itself.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Explicate the overall thesis's of Robert Kuttner's, Everything for Admission/Application Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1450464-briefly-explicate-the-overall-thesis-s-of-robert
(Explicate the Overall thesis's of Robert Kuttner'S, Everything for Admission/Application Essay)
https://studentshare.org/business/1450464-briefly-explicate-the-overall-thesis-s-of-robert.
“Explicate the Overall thesis's of Robert Kuttner'S, Everything for Admission/Application Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1450464-briefly-explicate-the-overall-thesis-s-of-robert.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Everything for Sale and The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism

Everything for Sale versus Cultural Contradiction of Capitalism

Name: Course: Tutor: Date: Section 1 everything for sale versus Cultural Contradiction of Capitalism everything for sale is book written in response of laissez faire kind of market in the economy.... Cultural contradiction of capitalism is written to change our thinking about how we relate social change, economics and culture (Bell, 1976).... Bell argues that modern capitalism undermines the moral foundations of the original capitalism....
3 Pages (750 words) Admission/Application Essay

State Capitalism

In it are concentrated all the contradictions of revolution and counter-revolution” (James and Dunayevskaya).... Name of author: State capitalism capitalism refers to an economical system in which production system is owned by private people for making profits.... State capitalism has several meanings and definitions; however, it can be generally defined as a society in which productive elements were controlled by the state in a capitalist manner....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Robert Kuttner's Everything For Sale and Daniel Bell's The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism

Robert Kuttner's “Everything For Sale” and Daniel Bell's “the cultural contradictions of capitalism” One of the most popular and influential books on market economy would be “Everything For Sale” by Robert Kuttner.... On the other hand, Daniel Bell's “the cultural contradictions of capitalism” is one of the most succinct analysis of the Western liberal capitalist society and its effects on people's culture.... On the other hand, Daniel Bell's “the cultural contradictions of capitalism”, holds that Capitalism is no hero in our market society because although it is innately good, the result becomes negative because of how the people react and their attitude to the effects of Capitalism....
3 Pages (750 words) Admission/Application Essay

Influence of German Philosophy and English Political Economy in Marx's Manuscripts

arxian economics evaluates various crunches in capitalism and focuses on the dissemination of resources in terms of surplus product and value generated within the production process among various types of economic systems.... His major contribution in the field of philosophy was based on the integration and unity of mind/spirit among phenomena that were manifested in a set of contradictions without elimination of the other.... When applying the dialectical methods of analyzing the economic history, economic, socio-cultural, or political phenomenon; they should not be viewed separately but on their inner connections as an integrated totality and structured around the basic predominant mode of production (Feuerbach, 1972)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Concept of Capitalism in Marx and Weber

This coursework called "The Concept of capitalism in Marx and Weber" describes the contemporary relevance of their ideas.... This paper provides information about the general characteristics of Max Weber and Karl Marx, a comparison of Karl Marx and Max Weber's Approaches to the Concept of capitalism and contemporary relevance of the ideas of Karl Marx and Max Weber.... According to Max Weber (1864-1920), the core idea of capitalism is that for the sole purpose of increasing the accumulation of wealth, continual investment and reinvestment of capital are undertaken....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework

Socialism Should Be Used in the Resolution of the Political and Economic Problems

Generally, the idea of capitalism as a political, social and economic system that is in entirety based on the promotion of private ownership that is solely noted to be directed at helping individuals and corporations to obtain the greatest possible profits is found to be entirely absurd in this day and age.... From the paper "Socialism Should Be Used in the Resolution of the Political and Economic Problems " it is clear that capitalism has run its useful course and it currently has no rationale to human life, politics or economy as is evidenced by the political and economic turmoil....
16 Pages (4000 words) Coursework

Neo-Liberal Economic Policies

The idea of this present paper "Neo-Liberal Economic Policies" emerged from the author's interest and fascination in what is the neo-Marxist assessment of neo-liberal economic policies and to what extent does the author agree with this assessment?... ... ... ... 'Neo-liberalism' are the words that are rarely heard in the United States, however, in the rest of the world, particularly Asia, Africa, and South America, a new word-'neocon (for neo-conservatives)' too is pretty common in debates and discussions....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Effect of Excess Capitalism on the Global Environment

The paper "Effect of Excess capitalism on the Global Environment" states that excess capitalism is affecting the global environment, and urgent measures are needed to curtail the negative tendencies.... Extreme capitalism characterizes by the desire to ensure that economic growth and development remain constant.... capitalism is an economic as well as a political system where a country's industry and trade are controlled by private owners....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us