StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

American prison system - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
While United States of America has the largest corrections system in the world, the history of its prisons and jails goes back to the British prison system. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
American prison system
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "American prison system"

? Running Head: American prison system American prison system of The American prison system History While United States of America has the largest corrections system in the world, the history of its prisons and jails goes back to the British prison system. However, the corporal punishment was largely absent in the old correction system and “bridewells”, as prisons in UK were called during 18th century. The American colonies had similar correctional system, largely, with the exception of colonial administrators using more corporal punishment in America, than followed by their counter parts in the motherland. This resulted in more death penalties, during that period. However, William Penn had a different viewpoint, as he adopted “The Great Law” in Pennsylvania in 1682, which restricted the use of torture as a punishment method, while it allowed felons paying for restitution of property to their victims. While Walnut Street prison became the first penitentiary, Pennsylvania passed legislation, in 1776, which made way for reforming and rehabilitation of offenders, instead of using torture or execution. However, reformist methods like silence and labor could not help much, as prison authorities were forced to accommodate more than one prisoner in a cell, necessitated by the overcrowding of prisons. The same reason kept many prisoners without work in jails.(Criminal Justice in Action: The Core, Prisons and Jails, pp313) Great Penitentiary Rivalry After gaining from the experience of Pennsylvania prison system, many American states tried to implement the concept of silence and labor, while interpreting the same in their own peculiar ways. In the process, the Pennsylvania Penitentiary and New York prison systems engaged in some sort of debate, over the correct and result-oriented method of prison administration. This gave birth to two known separate systems. The Pennsylvania Penitentiary system was entirely based on the “separate confinement” concept, as the prison had cells for inmates, built in such a manner that no prisoner could come under the influence of other inmate, during the confinement. While the New York system followed the Pennsylvania model of separate confinement, the authorities witnessed rise in sickness, insanity and suicide among inmates. Therefore the system was abandoned in 1822, as Elam Lynds adopted the “congregate system”, during his tenure as warden at Auburn. (Criminal Justice in Action: The Core, Prisons and Jails, pp314-5) Rivalry has influenced American thinking about prison system As America saw progressive movement in criminal justice, it started from the adoption of the “new penology”. This concept was put into practice at New York’s Elmira State Prison, in 1876, which introduced three-grade system for punishment, as well as, rewarding inmates displaying food behavior with early release. The theories adopted by Elmira model were incorporated during first few decades of twentieth century. Working on more reforms, progressive elements in the correctional system operations adopted “medical model” for prisoners, which made way for offering medical therapies to inmates for correcting their “ills”. However, most of the prison administrators did not agree to this level of rehabilitation in their systems. Further, many tough measures, for dealing with incurable criminals, were incorporated; as criminologists and politicians tried to counter the menace of sharp rise in crime, during 1970s. Accordingly, four types of prisons were formulated; depending on the required security level, starting from minimum security to super-maximum security. (Criminal Justice in Action: The Core, Prisons and Jails, reassertion of punishment, pp313 & 331) Comparison between publicly funded and privately funded prisons Privatization, as applicable to goods and service sector may not be completely compatible to the prison system, any where in the world. However, for discussions on privatization, the prison system can come under the purview of “services”. The aim of such service, within the Penitentiary system, is the rehabilitation and reforming of criminals. At the same time, treating human beings, like goods or commodities would not be morally and ethically correct. Hence, critics do not favor privatization of prison systems.(Campbell, 2009) However, there are reasons to believe that running of private prisons is always cost-effective. The arguments, in support of this line of thinking, include lower labor costs, as the private employees are non-unionized and they may not claim health care or other social benefits. The purpose of privatization, in itself, brings the concept of competition, which means operating the whole system at lowest possible cost index. In addition, the interference of politicians and government officials, visible under the public system would be absent in private prisons, which means lesser red tape and quicker decisions. (Criminal Justice in Action: The Core, Prisons and Jails, reassertion of punishment, pp331-2) Privatization debate Apart from the arguments forwarded above against privatization of prisons, the debate continues with certain observers feeling that providing a fee by the state to the private poisons for maintenance of each inmate can serve as an incentive for the management to increase the jail term of prisoners, which may result in a dubious bias. In addition, it is felt that private organizers may resort to cost-cutting measures, there-by jeopardizing the security of inmates. (Criminal Justice in Action: The Core, Prisons and Jails, reassertion of punishment, pp324) WORKS-CITED Campbell J J, 2009, “On the Evils of Privatizing America’s Prison System”, Accessed on 23rd Jan 2011 from: http://blogcritics.org/politics/article/on-the-evils-of-privatizing-americas/page-2/ Criminal Justice in Action: The Core, Part four, Chapter 12, “Prisons and Jails”, reassertion of punishment, pp331-2, Accessed on 23rd Jan 2011 from: http://www.academia-research.com/filecache/instr/r/e/496000_reading_on_jails_and_prisons.pdf Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“American prison system Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1406133-eb
(American Prison System Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1406133-eb.
“American Prison System Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1406133-eb.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF American prison system

Changes in Criminal Justice

The criminal justice system evolved significantly over the years.... However, there are still flaws in the system that could change within the next fifty years.... hellip; Such changes could decrease crime rates, help justice departments catch criminals, and adjust the penal system.... Three specific aspects of the criminal justice system that have the potential to change significantly in fifty years are biometrics, cybercrime protection, and the end of mass incarceration....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Issues In Corrections

American Correctional system The United States of America has the largest correctional system in the world.... Gill (2009) states, “The United States justice system consist of administrative works for adjudicating and processing those who are accused and convicted of various crimes ranging from blue collar crimes up to murder”.... hellip; Although America's correctional system provides a number of considerable benefits to the society, there also exist some key issues, which need to be dealt in order to make the system more effective and beneficial for the society....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

The reaction of Surviving Maximum Security

For an average person like me who has little idea about prison life, especially the American prison system and culture, this documentary entitled "Surviving Maximum Security" has given me a clear picture what it feels like being there on the prison's "inner sanctum" (not that I would want to commit a crime just to experience that).... For an average person like me who has little idea about prison life, especially the American prison system and culture, this documentary en d "Surviving Maximum Security" has given me a clear picture what it feels like being there on the prison's "inner sanctum" (not that I would want to commit a crime just to experience that)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The War on Drugs

This should raise the question in the minds of the american populace as to whether these state and federal billions are being spent appropriately, as it appears that the War on Drugs is not making any significant impact on drug trafficking and consumption.... The War on Drugs represents a significant effort on behalf of the United States to halt the flow of illegal substances into the country, while also attempting to discourage the usage of drugs throughout the world....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Fighting Crime Case Study

hellip; The author states that congestion in the American prison system and the ineffective state of the criminal justice system is also seen to be underpinned by socio-economic factors.... Congestion in the American prison system and the ineffective state of the criminal justice system is also seen to be underpinned by socio-economic factors.... The flipside of this is that overcrowding in the prison system proliferates crime in the same system....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Social Reaction to the Prison System

The paper "Social Reaction to the prison system" discusses that a new equilibrium remains to be forged.... hellip; The modern prison is enmeshed in a crisis of identity.... A prison was once unquestionably an institution geared for punishment, custody, and control.... The prison is a ghetto for its inmates.... A prison is a facility maintained for the confinement of convicted felons.... n mid-2003, of those serving sentences of at least one year in federal or state facilities, there were 480 prison inmates per 100,000 U....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The History of the American Prison System - from Bridewells and the Great Law to Modern Prisons

… The paper “The History of the American prison system - from Bridewells and the Great Law to Modern Prisons" is an impressive example of a term paper on law.... While the United States of America has the largest corrections system in the world, the history of its prisons and jails goes back to the British prison system.... (Criminal Justice in Action: The Core, Prisons and Jails, pp313) - Great Penitentiary Rivalry After gaining from the experience of the Pennsylvania prison system, many American states tried to implement the concept of silence and labor, while interpreting the same in their own peculiar ways....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Prisons and Prison Culture

From the prettiest of thieves to the most dangerous of mass murderers and serial killers, all will spend varying sentences within that prison system.... However, some inmates, according to the Importation Model, bring ideologies and cultural values with them into the prison system.... That is 650,000 people returned to the public who may have spent a few weeks to a few decades within the prisons system.... The paper "Prisons and prison Culture" highlights that today we are seeing more and more prisoners of petty, low-grade offenses are now being released or granted more lenient consequences for the petty crimes that are being committed....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us