StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Obama Healthcare plan vs. Clinton Healthcare plan - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Both Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton have presented good proposals for healthcare plans thereby making argument needless. That notwithstanding, Paul Krugman of the New York Times and John Nichols of The Nation has given their opinion from the Hillary side of the argument even though Obama has presented better arguments…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Obama Healthcare plan vs. Clinton Healthcare plan
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Obama Healthcare plan vs. Clinton Healthcare plan"

Download file to see previous pages

Since Hillary has no mechanism for enforcing the individual mandate she proposes, Obama regards the mandate as a bluff. John Edwards, whose plan includes mechanism for enforcing the individual mandate that he has proposed, supported Obama’s criticism of Hillary and Hillary’s criticism of Obama. In the Edward’s proposal, proof of insurance will be required when income taxes are paid and when health care is provided. Thus, Americans will be compelled to buy health insurance. The Edward’s plans make provision for families without insurance and those that lose coverage.

The former will be enrolled in plans such as Medicare and Medicaid while the later will be enrolled in other plans. The issue is not enrolling people in private health care plan but getting people to participate in the plan. Thus, the Obama plan makes perfect sense given that it resist individual mandate, which may be unattractive to a large number of people and may not easily be enforced. The President’s Medicare Plan: A Trojan Horse to Ration Health Care? Medicare, with $30.8 trillion in long term unfunded obligations, could cease to exist if the runaway cost is not reined in.

The problem is how Medicare cost should be controlled. Two options are available: changing the structure and culture of Medicare through empowering patients to make health care decisions that lead to best results, in addition to forcing plans and providers to compete for the money; and top-down bureaucratic control of the cost of health care services. Of course, these options will reduce the cost but will simultaneously reduce the quality of health care. The first option, which was taken by Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan, has been described to give Medicare patients control over cost of services and freedom to choose how they access these services.

The result according to Heritage’s Robert Moffit and James Capretta is value in return for the dollars. President Obama opted for the second option: tightening the top-down bureaucracy and reducing Medicare payment to doctors and hospitals, in addition to reducing providers’ reimbursement rates. This option leads to reduced senior access to doctors. Under the second option, the Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB) will be strengthened to rein in cost of Medicare while improving the quality of care.

The White House planned to equip IPAB to promote prevention without shifting cost to seniors. Though reducing doctors’ salaries will reduce Medicare cost as envisioned by the second option, according to British Physician Anthony Daniels strengthening IPAB to focus on prevention will be unsuccessful at addressing the fiscal problem The fact that Congress continues to delay in reducing doctors salaries suggests that the second option is not politically attractive. Pursuing health care reforms that put bureaucrats in charges will reduce patient access to care.

The second option should be repealed to avoid such outcome. Will Obama’s health care plan mirror the 1994 Clinton failure? Former President Bill Clinton key policy plan in 1994 was a

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Obama Healthcare plan vs. Clinton Healthcare plan Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419074-obama-healthcare-plan-vs-clinton-healthcare-plan
(Obama Healthcare Plan Vs. Clinton Healthcare Plan Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419074-obama-healthcare-plan-vs-clinton-healthcare-plan.
“Obama Healthcare Plan Vs. Clinton Healthcare Plan Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419074-obama-healthcare-plan-vs-clinton-healthcare-plan.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Obama Healthcare plan vs. Clinton Healthcare plan

Health Care Reform Analysis

A major factor discussed in the paper that one of the major causes of the failure of health plan under the leadership of Roosevelt, Truman and Clinton was political interferences.... Even Franklin Roosevelt at the height of his power and political skill failed to pass a nationalized health care plan.... This paper will discuss various reasons as to why health plans have failed under Roosevelt, Truman and Clinton regime and the reason as to why Obama's plan succeed in getting approved....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

President Clintons and Obamas Healthcare Policies

President clinton's and Obama's health care policies [Name] [Date] Summary Health care policies have often been chosen as key factors in the policies of different governments.... The same attempts have been initiated by another President Bill clinton, who launched his health care program in 1993-94.... Population of America did not accept these attempts of clinton.... clinton placed stake on the nation and the public attention to the phenomenon of the universal health care....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Discussion About Obamacare

Although the president promised that people would get to keep the healthcare plan that they had, enjoyed, and needed, the GOP said that would not be the case because the health insurance costs would skyrocket.... A Discussion About Obamacare When Barack Obama, who is almost a dead ringer for Denzel Washington, was elected president, one of the platforms that helped catapult him to the White House was his program of universal healthcare.... It's main purpose was to reform healthcare insurance and provide near universal healthcare coverage for the American people....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Clinton vs Obama: Campaign 2008

Clinton's plan, the Iraq Troop Reduction and Protection Act of 2007, does not call for a deadline for American troops to be withdrawn (Zeleny and Semrad).... Obama's plan, the Iraq War De-escalation Act of 2007, calls for total withdrawal by March 2008 (Zeleny and Semrad).... ost major polls list healthcare as a close second behind Iraq as the issue Americans feel is most important ("Problems and Priorities").... Add Hillary clinton and Barack Obama to this mix and America is faced with some real decisions to make in the coming year and a half....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Private Healthcare vs Reform Healthcare

ortunately, about most Americans do not have to worry about this too much as they have purchased healthcare plans that have them covered for any eventuality concerning their health.... healthcare is a major industry that operates on profits in order to be able to provide excellent healthcare plans that allow Americans to be able to receive proper healthcare.... There is a general distinction between private and public healthcare, with the former having a reputation for being able to provide higher quality of services and better treatment than the latter (Yamamoto, Neuman and Strollo 8)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Obama's Health Care Reform 2010

This is following decades of numerous Democratic presidents' futile attempts, including Bill clinton and Harry Truman, thereby making the moment very essential in the long legislative combat.... Since the year 2000, there has been a remarkable increase in these numbers of uninsured Americans and even… Research indicates that the United States has been the only major developed country that has not warranted her populace coverage for health insurance Proposals to reform The US' Health Care Legislation have severally failed until March 23, 2010 when President obama and his Democratic party leaders were able to pass and sign the bill....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Health Reform Plan Paper

When Bill Clinton delivered a popular speech in September 1993, the main agenda of the proposed plan entailed an enforced mandate for employers to give health insurance coverage to their employees (Bowman, 1994).... ne critical reason for the failure inheres in the fact that health care is a too big, dangerous, and Running head: Why did the Clinton Health Reform plan in the 1990s never pass?... When Bill Clinton delivered a popular speech in September 1993, the main agenda of the proposed plan entailed an enforced mandate for employers to give health insurance coverage to their employees (Bowman, 1994)....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Compare and Contrast of Affordable Care Act and Clinton Healthcare Reforms

The writer of this paper states that in order to discuss why Affordable Care passed and the clinton healthcare Reforms failed, a comparison has been made between these two reforms.... nbsp;Notably, clinton healthcare Reforms was introduced by Bill Clinton, former US President in the year 1993.... In contrast, the steps followed in the generation of clinton healthcare Reforms.... Steps Wherein Policies Succeeded in FailedIt can be affirmed that the step of communicating the Americans about the message about the affordability of effective healthcare insurance plans eventually contributed in making the failure of clinton healthcare Reforms....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us