StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Theory of Justice Analysis - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Theory of Justice Analysis There are several principles of justice theories and some of them shall be discussed in this section. However, these principles of justice theories differ from traditional utilitarianism in some ways and the contrast between them shall also be highlighted and explained…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Theory of Justice Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Theory of Justice Analysis"

Theory of Justice Analysis There are several principles of justice theories and some of them shall be discussed in this section. However, these principles of justice theories differ from traditional utilitarianism in some ways and the contrast between them shall also be highlighted and explained. It is also pertinent to note that, justice can be explained by the modern Criminal Justice System (CJS) and other entities involved in the criminal justice system and these salient facts shall also be explained in this paper.

Justice as defined by the modern CJS also differs from security in some ways. One of the fundamental principles of justice theories is the one propounded by John Rawls. Rawls’ principle of justice theory is meant to embody the ethical foundation of political government (Rawls, 1971). In what he called, A Theory of Justice, Rawls was of the opinion that humans are in dire need of freedom and liberty in order to fulfill their heart desires and pursue their interests as long as it is not done in any way to harm other people (Rawls, 1971).

Thus, Rawls’ principle of justice theory is based on the premise that every citizen should be given the opportunity to succeed like every other citizen. This principle of justice as propounded by John Rawls could be likened to the principle of equality as every individual must be given equal opportunity to succeed like other citizens of the society. Another principle of justice theory also laid emphasis on the fact that every individual in the society have the right to vote and be voted for into any political office.

Any economic and social inequalities should be equally accessible to any position and ought to offer the maximum advantage to people that have the smallest amount of advantages in the society. This principle was actually propounded by Rawls and could also be referred to as the difference principle. This principle of justice theory clearly stipulates that, no advantage can exist morally, if it is not beneficial to the people that are highly advantageous in the society (Rawls, 1971). These principles of justice theory are different from traditional utilitarianism due to the fact that they only talked about the concept of justice and fairness and nothing else.

Unlike the traditional utilitarianism that discusses other issues like property rights and other issues that are not really related to justice, these principles were only concerned with the issue of justice and this is what separates them from traditional utilitarianism. These principles of justice also differs from traditional utilitarianism due to the fact that it is against the individualistic nature of utilitarianism as it can be seen that traditional utilitarianism was a threat to the right of individuals in the society (Barry, 1989).

It was on the basis of this, that these principles of justice theory can be used as a tool to see the society as a social contract that every individual must be committed to (Barry, 1989). Though the purposes of the modern criminal justice system are in line with the purposes of security, which are to control the rate of crime in the society, avert crime and to give and maintain justice in the society, the fact remains that the modern CJS differs from security in some ways. When it comes to the issue of providing and maintaining justice, it is a very complicated one and this is due to the fact that justice is a very difficult concept to define.

This is due to the fact that, it is not easy to arrive at a universal definition of justice as justice must be fair to all. But, justice can actually be defined by the modern criminal justice agencies and other entities involved as a system that treats all citizens as equals before the law and these individuals are free from any subjective arrest as described by the law. The onus now lies on the shoulders of the courts, corrections and the law enforcement to determine what is really fair. Justice as defined by the modern criminal justice system differs from security in the sense that, while justice gives individual the liberty that is due to them by law, security could take these liberty from the individual all in the name of protecting certain individuals or safeguarding the walls of the country.

Thus, it could then be argued that while justice must be fair to all, security can never be really fair to all individuals. This can be seen in the fight against terrorism, some rights of some individuals have been taken away from them all in the name of security and fighting against terrorism. The problem with security is its inability to really balance between national security and individual liberties and this is where justice differs from it (Roemer, 1996). Thus, the analysis of some basic principles of justice theories shows that justice must be fair to all.

Justice is also closely associated with equality. Through the analyzed principle of justice theories, it was seen that these principles differ from traditional utilitarianism in some ways. The definition of justice as given by the agencies of the modern criminal justice system was also broadly given and the difference between justice and security was also properly elaborated. References Barry, B. (1989) Theories of Justice, Vol. 1. Berkeley: University of California Press Rawls, J. (1971). A Theory of Justice.

Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press Roemer, J.E., (1996). Theories of Distributive Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Theory of Justice Analysis Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1430470-theory-of-justice-analysis
(Theory of Justice Analysis Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1430470-theory-of-justice-analysis.
“Theory of Justice Analysis Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1430470-theory-of-justice-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Theory of Justice Analysis

Justice in Directing Scope of Tort Liability

Corrective and Distributive justice in Directing Scope of Tort Liability A tort suit enables a victim that has been injured due to negligence or fault of a third party to shift his or her problems to the guilty party.... Some theorists believe that justice in tort is a matter of corrective justice.... They believe that tort law is a matter of distributive justice which deals with fair apportionment of benefits and losses of risky activities....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Society and Political Sciences

Cost-Benefit analysis: This relates to how governments set their regulations through the use of measuring up their decisions and options carefully.... This method is called the cost-benefit analysis since each option is carefully weighed out.... When cost-benefit analysis is accurately incorporated in ruling a country or simply making any decision, it automatically becomes effective.... Rights and justice: "All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Justice in Greek Philosophy

The immense dialogue in the Republic is opened by questioning the nature of justice.... Several definitions of justice are proposed which are found to be inadequate except that at least more emphasis is put on Sophist, Thrasymachus' definition.... Plato had quite a different view of justice; he believed that an answer exists that derives basically from reality's nature.... The dialogue also goes further to discuss the role of philosophers, the place of poetry, the theory of Forms, and the soul's immortality....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Theory of Justice Analysis Paper

The aim of the essay is to discuss and explain the theory of justice, specifically addressing the following concerns, to wit: (1) a determination of some of the principles of justice theories; (2) an explanation of how the principles of these theories differ from traditional… itarianism; and (3) an identification of how justice is defined by modern criminal justice agencies and other entities involved in the criminal justice system; and how does this differ from security. The study of ethics has found crucial applications in a wide range of One of the more famous views of ethics is primarily about the rights and duties of agents, which take precedent over individual feelings or inclinations, the wishes of the majority, or utilitarian calculations about what would make most people happy....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Rights Social Justice and Diversity

The factors that are… Leaders and wealthy entrepreneurs within the society have held the determinants that suggest the success needed to progress towards the Social justice is achieved in a system that communist policies are eradicated, and power delegated to the majority who comprises the workforce and opportunists.... Social justice is achieved in a system that upholds human rights and promotes equality with personal dignity uplifted.... In a diverse demographic, social justice is highlighted by the comfort of individuals and their capability to be influenced by the available resources (Clark 2005, p1341)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Content Analysis of the Handsupdontshoot on Instagram

In investigation of these research questions, this research uses cultivation theory to conduct a content analysis of #handsupdontshoot as it appears on Instagram and compares it intended message with the perceptions of Instagram users.... This research study uses cultivation theory in conducting a quantitative content analysis of #handsupdontshoot as portrayed on Instagram.... The results of the study reveal that African Americans and White Americans generally have different experiences with exposure to the criminal justice system and as such generally have different perspectives on the utility of #handsupdontshoot on Instagram....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Just War Theory and Christian Attitude towards Peace and Conflict Introduction

nbsp;… The theory of just war has attracted varied opinions from different groups of people and Christians with the pacifists argue that war cannot be just but the realist believes that moral concepts in Christianity cannot be applied to the concepts of war or foreign policies in a country.... For example, when the United States invaded Afghanistan and Iraq after the 9/11 terror attack, the theory of just war was used to support this course of military action....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Teaching for Diversity and Social Justices

From the paper "Teaching for Diversity and Social Justices" it is clear that it would be magnificent to understand various teachings dedicated to social justice, but the incorporation of social justice ideal into the ordinary, authorized, the prospectus is also pleasing.... hellip; The Teaching of diversity and social justice aids the student to toil on a wider viewpoint.... The educator can similarly convey the debate on the societal justice in the teaching space so as to advantage the scholars....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us