StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

To what extent should we make moral judgments about cultural practices from outside our own culture - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
There are several different cultures in the world and people usually find it difficult to understand the practices from cultures strange to them. As it is essential for human beings to deal with the difficulty in comprehending the various aspects of the other cultures, a system of making good moral judgments about cultural practices from outside one's own culture has great relevance…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
To what extent should we make moral judgments about cultural practices from outside our own culture
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "To what extent should we make moral judgments about cultural practices from outside our own culture"

Download file to see previous pages

Those who recommend this hold that the world is sharply divided into separate societies, sealed units, each with its own system of thought. They feel that the respect and tolerance due from one system to another forbids us ever to take up a critical position to any other culture." (Midgley, 69) According to this perspective, moral judgment is a kind of coinage valid only in its country of origin and the author terms this position ass 'moral isolationism'. Midgley also maintains that it is not forced upon individuals, and indeed makes no sense at all, to make moral judgment about other cultures.

Unlike the general thinking that such an attempt to make moral judgment about other cultures is a respectful attitude to other cultures, the author purports that one cannot respect what is entirely unintelligible to one and therefore it is not respectful attitude. Here, the author comes up with her central argument of the article and there is every reason to realize it as true and rational. As the author argues, it is essential for one to know enough about another person or culture in order to come up with an evenhanded judgment about the culture or person.

Therefore, Mary Midgley makes some essential arguments concerning moral judgment of other cultures in her article "On Trying out One's New Sword" and a reflective analysis of the article helps us in determining to what extent we should make moral judgments about cultural practices from outside our own culture. The article "On Trying out One's New Sword" suggests a moral isolationism which lays down a general ban on moral reasoning with regard to making moral judgments about strange cultures. In order to establish her argument, the author makes use of some remote example from the classical Japanese with a verb which means 'to try out one's new sword on a chance wayfarer'.

According to this example, the Samurai is required to try out this new sword on any wayfarer who was not another Samurai, and this action could injure his honor, offend his ancestors, and even let down his emperor. "Now when we hear of a custom like this, we may well reflect that we do not understand it; and therefore are not qualified to criticize it at all, because we are not members of that culture. But we are not members of any other culture either, except our own. So we extend the principle to cover all extraneous cultures, and we seem therefore to be moral isolationists.

" (Midgley, 70) Midgley also deals with certain fundamental questions about moral isolationism with reference to making moral judgments about strange cultures. First of all, she examines whether the isolating barrier work both ways or people in other cultures are equally unable to criticize others. According to her, outsiders can deliver perfectly good indictments, although it makes more than two weeks to make them demining. "Intelligent outsiders can progress in it, and in some ways will be at an advantage over the locals.

But, if this is so, it must clearly apply to ourselves as much as anybody else." (Midgley, 70) The author also deals with the question whether the isolating barrier between cultures block praise as well as blame. It is important to make immaculate judgments about other

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“To what extent should we make moral judgments about cultural practices Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1512570-to-what-extent-should-we-make-moral-judgments-about-cultural-practices-from-outside-our-own-culture
(To What Extent Should We Make Moral Judgments about Cultural Practices Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1512570-to-what-extent-should-we-make-moral-judgments-about-cultural-practices-from-outside-our-own-culture.
“To What Extent Should We Make Moral Judgments about Cultural Practices Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1512570-to-what-extent-should-we-make-moral-judgments-about-cultural-practices-from-outside-our-own-culture.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF To what extent should we make moral judgments about cultural practices from outside our own culture

Moral Theory of Relativism in the US

In the world of globalization and diverse cultural communication it becomes even more imperative that we tolerate other moralities that may lie outside our own narrow acceptance.... The issue becomes the tolerance of other moral judgments that may differ from our own.... Examining our most fundamental cultural group, the family, we can readily identify inconsistencies in moral judgments.... Individual moral judgments are not modified to accommodate another person's differences or cultural surroundings....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Concept of Creative Social Systems

Csikszentmihalyi's approach to studying Creativity was by considering the interactions between individuals, society, and culture.... “Sense of ecstasy” – It is a state wherein he feels as if he is outside reality.... When Csikszentmihalyi developed his systems view of creativity he turned his attention away from “What is creativity?... To introduce his concept of a creative society, he first identified three important components of a creative system, firstly the individual, secondly the cultural or symbolic component called the domain, and thirdly there is a social or interactive component called the field....
15 Pages (3750 words) Book Report/Review

Factors Necessary for a Successful Multicultural Workplace

The paper "Factors Necessary for a Successful Multicultural Workplace" develops the assumption that understanding front-stage culture at the level of gestures and rituals is easy via observation.... But to really develop an insight into the back-stage in-depth culture different from one's own, takes more effort on an individual's part.... How can we enable excellence at work and leverage on the diversity of culture, given the practical challenges brought about by human differences?...
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Mary Midgleys Moral Isolationism

This poses the question that “if morals are applicable and legitimate only to one's own culture as he or she cannot understand cultures other than his or her own, then how can one appropriately respect and tolerate cultures that he or she is not a member of?...   To put it simply, because an outsider cannot understand other cultures, he or she does not have the right to make judgments about other cultures.... According to Mary Midgley, this is what moral isolationism is as it involves “the familiar position that respect and tolerance demand that members of one culture do not criticize other cultures”… When an outsider criticizes a particular country or culture, most often than not, those who have been criticized would shout out in indignation for the outsiders to show some respect for things that they do not understand....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Ethnorelativism in the Asian Community

By taking a step outside of this situation one has to place their culture and region in the same context as other cultures and religions.... As with individuals, every culture has its own unique characteristics that differentiate them from the rest.... The essay "Ethnorelativism" focuses on ethnorelativism which helps individuals in viewing other religions from a new framework; different from their own.... Christmas in the park is an annual event that brings together all San Jose residents and visiting tourists from all over the world to celebrate the Christmas spirit....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Ethical Tourism Practices in Cancun

nbsp;From this research it is clear that Cancun needs a policy that gels concretized it, with great Mayan culture, to preserve its eco-fragile system and introduce a futuristic model of tourism that becomes a paragon of co-existence of thoughts, cultures, and nature....  … Ever since it has invited large scale investments from the Mexican and the International hospitality industry.... rg fact the gamut of ethical practices is large varying from personal etiquette to macro-environmental factors....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Traditional Beliefs That Are Still Prevalent in Greek Society Today

he paper will look at some age-old Greek traditional beliefs embedded in today's cultural practices and re-examines them with a modern lens in order to reconcile some of the beliefs in a rapidly changing society and with prevailing popular culture.... It will look at Greek society cultural practices in general and how it deals with the questions of race and age in particular, and when it comes to marrying off their daughters.... As culture is about language and beliefs, there is now cultural relativism (Parks, Malveaux & Morial 224)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Morality and Gender Equality in the Past Vs Now

In this sense, the activities of prominent individuals who are entrusted make certain moral judgments that eventually merge with the activities of administrators, both in the form of decision-making, and in the sense of direct contact in the various levels of public enterprise management, business structures, educational institutions, etc.... This paper ''Morality and Gender Equality in the Past Vs Now'' tells that Morality can be defined as the public morals or the most common rules of human society, about which the people of a particular culture living in a society assumes that they are right....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us