StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Philosophy of Hugo Bedau and Ernest vd. Haag - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Man is by nature good as expressed by John Locke's Tabula Rasa Theory that: "the mind of an individual human being is born blank and that their identity is defined entirely by events after birth". Yet, as man journeys through self-discovery he begins to experience the desire to see the unexpected outcome of his deeds…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Philosophy of Hugo Bedau and Ernest vd. Haag
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Philosophy of Hugo Bedau and Ernest vd. Haag"

Download file to see previous pages

Soon he is called to pay for the sins of his nature. The ultimate punishment for man's heinous crimes has continued to raise differing views in the civilized society. Hugo Bedau upholds the American Civil Liberties Union that "death penalty inherently violates the constitutional ban against cruel and unusual punishment and the guarantee of due process of law and the equal protection of the laws". This idea is based on the premise that the state should not usurp the power of taking the lives of human beings especially in a "premeditated and with ceremony" under the guise of law.

The punishment of death for a capital offense is frowned upon as too "harsh, freaky and arbitrary" to be constitutionally acceptable. He believes that this form of punishment is still based on the early days of barbarism when other forms of corporal punishment were acceptable. The killing of a person has no place in a civil humane society because it wastes the resources of the courts, the legal counsels, juries and other correctional personnel. Executions impart to the society the unmistakable message that "human life no longer deserves respect and that homicide is legitimate when justified by pragmatic concerns.

" He has also added: "that threat of severe punishment cannot deter criminals especially ones who are in the drug trade. If however, long term imprisonment is severe enough to cause any rational person not to commit violent crimes. Bedau also demonstrated that "death penalty violates the constitutional guarantee of the equal protection of the law" as it is applied randomly at best and discriminatorily at worst. He also added that "it is imposed disproportionately upon those whose victims are white, on offenders who are people of color and on the poor and uneducated".

He based this argument on the misdistribution of the implementation of the punishment on criminals whose offenses were against white victims because statistics would show that in 2005, of the 60 inmates who were executed, 41 were white and only 19 were black. Ernest van den Haag, for his part believes that capital punishment likely serves as a deterrent factor to the commission of a crime because of the common fear of death. Criminals, although not scientifically supported have a strong and palpable fear of the capital punishment on its severe form.

There are murderers who are not hindered by the threat of imprisonment but death as a finality serves to inflict a sense of foreboding, knowing that after death there is only void. More so, "death penalty certainly deters the murderer who is executed". He further argues that the abolition of this capital punishment "is prayed upon by pro-life activists like Bedau with the argument that there is misdistribution between the guilty and the innocent." He reasoned out that Bedau's argument of misdistribution of punishment is irrelevant to its justice or morality as "punishments are imposed on the person, not on racial or economic groups".

In short, equality in the appropriation of the punishment is less important than justice. The long term imprisonment preferred by pro-life activists is a costly maintenance which cannot inflict the kind of fear that the possibility of death brings. There is a likely chance of escape in prison. In some third world countries, the despicable criminals quite enjoy being afforded food while being

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Philosophy of Hugo Bedau and Ernest vd. Haag Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1520720-philosophy-of-hugo-bedau-and-ernest-vd-haag
(Philosophy of Hugo Bedau and Ernest Vd. Haag Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1520720-philosophy-of-hugo-bedau-and-ernest-vd-haag.
“Philosophy of Hugo Bedau and Ernest Vd. Haag Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1520720-philosophy-of-hugo-bedau-and-ernest-vd-haag.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Philosophy of Hugo Bedau and Ernest vd. Haag

Philosophy of Punishment

philosophy of punishment Name subject Professor Date philosophy of Punishment Abstract The early philosophy for punishment was based on seeking revenge for the crime and ensures social cohesion by implementing such measures in the most subtle manner.... A greater liberal justification of punishment is the sense of isolating and getting rid of all threats in the society so as to achieve social order and to ensure that criminal aggression is kept within control (bedau 2010)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Case study paper on - death penalty both pro and anti capital punishment

On the other hand, the article written by hugo bedau argues that death penalty is a lawful killing, and since it is a form of killing the law should rise above it and condemn it.... hellip; According to Ernest Van Den haag, death penalty is the best form of retribution and deterrence the law can provide to the society.... I am sure ernest van den hag would have reacted hard on this thought.... The final question consists of bedau contemplating that it is immoral and indecent to award death penalty in response to crimes such as rape and kidnapping....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

InThe Importance of Being Earnest, Lady Bracknell

The Importance of Being ernest is one of the finest humorous plays to have premiered at the turn of twentieth century.... Running Head: The Importance of Being Earnest The Importance of Being Earnest University Name In The Importance of Being Earnest, Lady Bracknell says about Algernon in Act 3, "He has nothing, but he looks everything....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Importance of Being Earnest and the US Government

The author also uses the name ernest in the play as a person who is admired living in upscale London.... (Wilde, Pg 13)Lane comes back to the room announcing the presence of ernest Worthing.... ernest is Algernon's friend.... ernest is from the country side but he often comes to visit London.... ernest in their conversation reveals to Algernon about his intention to propose to Gwendolyn, Algernon's cousin.... Algernon is not happy about this and he tells ernest that he would not allow him to propose to his cousin until he explains the incision that he had collected written from a certain Cecily....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Ernest Ludwig Kirchner

ernest Ludwig Kirchner (1880 - 1938) was a German artist, a representative of expressionism of the first half of the 20th century.... He was one of the founders of the artists group "Die Brucke" or "The Bridge.... Although the group of artists lived in a small communal atmosphere in isolation, each artist had different interests and styles perusing in terms of depicting human psych....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Photography: Ernst Haas

The following essay “Photography: Ernst Haas” discusses one of those photographers, who overcame the gap between art and photojournalism.... That time there were few people, who treated photojournalism as art.... Haas was not among these people.... hellip; The author explains that a photographer was born to a family of Austrian officials, and his parents cultivated a love to art in him since early childhood....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Empowered, Traditional Womanly Roles in Wildes The Importance of Being Earnest

Oscar Wilde's The Importance of Being Earnest is a comedic play about creating and protecting masculine and… The power of naming and names is a central theme in identity making where women have particular significance, especially as both Gwendolen and Cecily desire the name ernest for their husbands....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Ernest Rutherford

Furthermore, ernest observed that radioactivity of objects reduced with time ernest Rutherford Born on August 30, 1871, Earnest Rutherford made significant contributions in the field of science, especially physics by carrying out experiments to illustrate the concept of radioactivity (BBC 1).... Furthermore, ernest observed that radioactivity of objects reduced with time (Rutherford 17).... Discovery of nuclear physics is also the basis of modern energy thus useful in my understanding of providing alternatives to non-renewable sources of energy (Henley, ernest, and Stephen 23)....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us