StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Burials, Houses, Women and men in the European Neolithic - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The first view assumes that the megalith monuments of ancient Europe were products of emerging religious ideas at the time. The second view emphasizes the…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Burials, Houses, Women and men in the European Neolithic
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Burials, Houses, Women and men in the European Neolithic"

Burials, Houses, Women and men in the European Neolithic: What does the say is his/her goal in this article or chapter? What is the point he/she is going to make? At the outset, the Ian Hodder tries to make clear the two varying interpretations of neolithic megalith structures. The first view assumes that the megalith monuments of ancient Europe were products of emerging religious ideas at the time. The second view emphasizes the social and economic tensions of the time as the primary factor in the scale and location of many of these structures.

Hodder then goes on to analyse the strengths and drawbacks of these different schools of thought by way of weighing up supportive evidence. For example, the author argues that there is little direct evidence to support the hypotheses forwarded by Renfrew and Chapman. Hence their processual approach to understanding the meaning and importance of these megalith structures still remains unproven. Amid these competing claims and counterclaims regarding the monoliths, Ian Hodder seeks to adopt a more robust framework of analysis for interpreting the importance and functions of these ancient structures.

What archaeological or anthropological examples does the author use to demonstrate the theoretical point he/she is trying to make? Ian Hodder identifies the different forms of tombs and houses by the differences apparent in their architectural styles and construction techniques. The long houses and long burial mounds are given special attention, for these structures are spread across continental Europe, spanning modern day Germany, Poland, Czechoslovakia, Neatherlands and beyond. Based on the shape, size, location, orientation and the likely human population at the time of their construction, the author arrives at the most likely historical and anthropological significance of these structures.

While long houses, long burial mounds and tombs are found all across Europe, no two structures are identical. In fact, the uniqueness associated with each of these archaological sites are what give their broader indication. The other task the author carries out is to ascertain the social and interpersonal implication of these structures. Determining the relation of long houses and tombs with respect to their surrounding environment is much easier when compared to finding the social interactions within these ancient spaces of living.

This is so because the monoliths have withstood the passage of time while the smaller sized household utilities such as pottery, objects that served as furniture and food leftovers have largely been destroyed by the elements. As a result it is very difficult to estimate the number of people who took shelter in these houses, their relation to one another and what other function did these houses serve? Nevertheless, the author tries to deduce aspects of domestic and social life in the European Neolithic from the available pottery fragments and other small artefacts.

The other area of sociology that the author attempts to decipher is the relations between men and women. Questions pertaining to the social hierarchy in the European Neolithic is also considered. And finally, the reasons for the differences between the architectural styles of sites in Western and Central Europe is deliberated. How does this article/chapter build on previous work? The author may tell you or you may have to decide for yourself. Overall, the article is eruditely written by giving due consideration of various theoretical interpretations given by other scholars.

The article satisfactorily places the megalith structues in their broader social contexts. But more importantly, rather than disregarding existing interpretations, the author builds on them and attempts to bring about a synthesis. It is equally commendable that Ian Hodder accepts the limitations of his own analysis and that there is much more work to be done by future generation of archaeologists and sociologists, before one could arrive at a conclusive picture.Is this article/chapter persuasive?

That is, do you agree with the author, were you unconvinced at first and agreed by the end, do you find the article unconvincing or do you downright disagree with the author’s point? Nevertheless, the explanations and arguments made by Ian Hodder do come across as logically sound. What makes the authors point of view persuasive is that fact that he gives proper rationale for discarding a previous scholarly interpretation. This way, the article takes an air of interactive dialogue, as opposed being a dogmatic polemic.

As I completed reading through the article, I got the feeling that its initial promise was well substantiated throughout. In sum, the article in question is a fine piece of scholarship, written in an objective fashion. References:Article: Burials, Houses, Women and Men in the European Neolithic. Author: Ian Hodder Book: Theory and Practice in Archaeology 1992.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Burials, Houses, Women and men in the European Neolithic Essay”, n.d.)
Burials, Houses, Women and men in the European Neolithic Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1559873-burials-houses-women-and-men-in-the-european-neolithic
(Burials, Houses, Women and Men in the European Neolithic Essay)
Burials, Houses, Women and Men in the European Neolithic Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1559873-burials-houses-women-and-men-in-the-european-neolithic.
“Burials, Houses, Women and Men in the European Neolithic Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1559873-burials-houses-women-and-men-in-the-european-neolithic.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Burials, Houses, Women and men in the European Neolithic

Paleolithic and Neolithic civilizations of Europe

Paleolithic and neolithic Civilizations of Europe Life is known to exist on earth for more than 40 million years.... The evolution of primitive man to his present, modern self can be classified roughly into three periods, Paleolithic, Mesolithic (The middle stone age), and neolithic or the 'New Stone Age'.... Consequently during the neolithic period which is roughly from 10,000 years ago to 3500 years ago man mastered the art of carving tools out of stones....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

History of the Women in the UK & USA

The involvement of women in second world war and the role played by them brought changes in awareness and consciousness within the women and the in the society too.... History shows that women is creative source of human life, women are always treated as inferior to men, since olden days.... In USA, the women were felt weaker than men as they couldn't do hard work which requires muscle power.... Irrespective of their race, religion & class women were not seen as women in the society in the beginning of this century....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Paleolithic and Neolithic Art Forms

"Paleolithic and neolithic Art Forms " paper states that while both Paleolithic and neolithic man each depended upon stone for their survival and the expression of their beliefs, there is a definite progression of thought evident in these artifacts from one period to the next.... These ideas first began to manifest themselves during the Paleolithic Period and continued to develop through the neolithic Period.... Paleolithic roughly translates to mean Old Stone Age while neolithic roughly translates to mean New Stone Age....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Paleolithic Societies and Neolithic Revolution

in the european Paleolithic, the chronological succession of epochs chiefly characterized by their industry has been distinguished.... he age of the european Paleolithic civilizations corresponds roughly to the Pleistocene period of the geologists.... The paper "Paleolithic Societies and neolithic Revolution" looks into two aspects of civilization developing.... The first one is the Significance of Art, Magic, and Technology in Paleolithic Societies and the second one is the neolithic Revolution as the Necessary Preconditions for the Establishment of Civilization....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

The Archaeology of the Neolithic

The author examines the neolithic period which starts with the beginning of farming and domestication of animals and ends in the time when metal tools began to be used.... It has to be kept in mind while studying the neolithic period that the ending point of neolithic varies … The neolithic age has thus left behind it's on mementos and pathfinders.... Thus the archeology of the neolithic starts its work from exploring the medium of earth and its numerous expressions in space....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Chronohistory of Europe

In other european countries such as Spain, caves, and rock shelters have been found in the North Coast of the country in areas such as Mount Buciero, Cantarabia, and the Covalanas Cave.... This work called "Chronohistory of Europe" describes the chronic history of Europe in an attempt to unearth various information about the existence of humans over the cultural history of the continent....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Men and Horses

Most archeologists agree that horses must have been domesticated for riding, as well as for their meat during the neolithic, Eneolithic or Early Bronze Age.... This essay "men and Horses" focuses on human relationships or interactions with horses that have varied throughout history depending on human needs, but it is horses' ability to carry a human individual that has had perhaps the greatest impact on their relationship with the man....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Difference between Neolithic to the Iron Age

european neolithic groups are known to have shared certain fundamental characteristics.... The author of the paper "Difference between neolithic to the Iron Age" has identified that the two civilizations went through almost similar developmental stages with the engagement in some form of agriculture contributing much to later developments.... nbsp; … In general, neolithic Europe historically corresponds to the period between 7000BC and 1700BC....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us