StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Mediocre Public Intellectuals - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Mediocre Public Intellectuals" discusses the main connection between Said’s and Ozick’s articles which is the fact that one issue leads to another. Strong academic freedom paves the way for a responsible public intellectual, and the opposite is true…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Mediocre Public Intellectuals
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Mediocre Public Intellectuals"

Mediocre Public Intellectuals The two authors Edward Said and Cynthia Ozick wrote extensively on the issues of academic freedom and public intellectual respectively. Edward Said, expressed his sentiments on the article Identity, Authority and Freedom: the Potentate and the Traveler. While, on the other hand, Cynthia Ozick’s arguments were presented in the article Public and Private Intellectuals. After reading and conceptualizing on works by these two authors, a connection with academic conversation essay came in the form of the topic Mediocre Public Intellectuals. It is evident that some individuals have taken advantage of academic freedom, and the fact that they are public intellectuals to manipulate the members of public for their political gain. This is an academic conversation essay giving a discussion on mediocre public intellectuals. Edward Said reiterates that interpretation of academic freedom is based on different societies also on different curriculum taken up by universities. According to Said, there has been a group taking the position that traditional curriculum entailing the liberal arts is under attack. While the other group, arguing that social sciences and humanities curriculum should focus its interests on people in the society who are ignored, suppressed or papered (Said 7). Academic freedom has been demonstrated in the United States’ universities through adoption of non-Western societies in the academic fields of history, literature, film and mass communication. Unfortunately, Said maintains that academic freedom has been inhibited by controversial issues presented in seminars and lectures such as gender, race, war, slavery and imperialism. Said, further gives an extensive detail on how academic freedom has been suppressed in the countries in the Arab-Islamic world which have been subjected to foreign education. Edward Said concludes his article by stating that academic freedom should take the model of a traveler or migrant. As a traveler, or migrant individuals looking for knowledge should embrace other identities, other varieties and other selves during the adventure (Said 23). Ozick’s article posit on who are the private intellectuals and who are the public intellectuals. He gives a list of intellectuals and state whether they are public or private. For instance, he starts by stating public intellectuals such as Socrates, Maimonides, Emerson and Voltaire. However, he includes private intellectuals his article such as Lionel Trilling and William James. Ozick refers to the author E.M Forster and take a critical look at his works as it relates to public intellectuals. According to Ozick, Forster has an essay featuring the issue of liberty in England, and most importantly Forster attacks censorship while defending freedom of speech. A public intellectual is seen as an individual with a strong mind commitment which are channeled to have positive impacts in the whole society (Ozick 354). According to Ozick, public intellectuals are aware of the essence and impact of history in today’s world. Ozick affirms, public intellectuals’ responsibility is to focus on loyalty and activism in progressing democracy. Public intellectuals strategically formulate out historic and cognitive patterns, which lead to public issues. Ozick commends Forster for his thoughtful way addressing political issues through his art. Ozick concludes by noting that public intellectuals are subject to public contemplation. The difference between public and private intellectuals is from the fact that, if private thinkers do not speak out they are viewed as cowards, however, when they speak out they are seen as bunglers (Ozick 356). The topic that I would develop from the above articles is on the issue of mediocre public intellectuals. This topic came as a result of the following situation; I recently had a political discussion with Vitali Klitschko. He currently holds the heavy weight champion, and he is now contemplating to run for a public office in Ukraine. Since Klitschko holds a PhD and on the public domain, he is active a lot of people consider him as a public intellectual. According to my arguments he is not a public intellectual. That came after I heard his speech, which proved clearly that he does not know what he is trying to express exactly, and he is only a puppet/figure head belonging to a normal political party. Vitali Klitschko is the best example to use when displaying a typical mediocre public intellectual. He hides under the façade of being a public intellectual with the intention of political gain (Ozick 354). Edward Said’s understanding of academic freedom goes inline with native or local people being educated in terms of their own culture without any foreign influence. In the case of Ukraine where Vitali Klitschko comes from, the education is influenced by Russia, and this is a clear indication that Ukraine does not have academic freedom. The influence of Ukrainian education by Russia must have been embedded in Klitschko’s PhD, a clear indication that he does not have any academic freedom. Klitschko’s lack of academic freedom is also a direct indication that he represents Russian policies in Ukraine, and this pushes him further away from the essence of a public intellectual according to Cynthia Ozick. Academic freedom as Said has stated, is very instrumental in building and growth of a responsible public intellectual as Ozick had expressed (Ozick 358). The situation of Klitschko, who in this case is referred to as a mediocre public intellectual is very important to note. Klitschko’s lack of academic freedom shows that he is not informed of the real issues affecting the Ukrainians. Since he does not have the real connection with the people of Ukraine, he is forced to come up with a strategy in which he presents himself as a public intellectual for political advantage. The reason Russia had too much influence on Ukrainian education was because both countries were part of the USSR up to the year 1991. After the termination, of USSR, Russia was still powerful in terms of its energy resources and it continued supporting Ukraine in turn influencing its internal structure. An individual like Vitali Klitschko has Russian influence written all over him. His speech clearly signified that he was a puppet echoing sentiments that had originated from the Russians. Klitschko turns out to be an easy victim of mediocre public intellectual because of the poor academic freedom he has experienced (Said 23). Conclusion The main connection between Said’s and Ozick’s articles is on the fact that one issue leads to another. A strong academic freedom paves the way for a responsible public intellectual, and the opposite is true. The topic Mediocre Public Intellectual exemplifies how an individual like Vitali Klitschko due to lack of academic freedom, can resort to tactics that are below standards like portraying himself as a public intellectual. Mediocre Public Intellectuals come as a result of lack of academic freedom in a country since its education system is influenced by foreigners. Works Cited Ozick C. Public and Private Intellectuals. New York: Random House, 2001. Print Said E. "Identity Authority and Freedom: The Potentate and the Traveler." T. B. Davie Academic Freedom Lecture (1991): 1-54. Print Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Mediocre Public Intellectuals: Edward Said and Cynthia Ozick Essay”, n.d.)
Mediocre Public Intellectuals: Edward Said and Cynthia Ozick Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1435167-conversation-essay
(Mediocre Public Intellectuals: Edward Said and Cynthia Ozick Essay)
Mediocre Public Intellectuals: Edward Said and Cynthia Ozick Essay. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1435167-conversation-essay.
“Mediocre Public Intellectuals: Edward Said and Cynthia Ozick Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1435167-conversation-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Mediocre Public Intellectuals

American Higher Education

This paper “American Higher Education” aims at analyzing the trends of education, both private and public, throughout centuries, alongside with analyzing striking differences between the both.... This reform constituted a land reform system where the pieces of lands owned by the Federal Governments would be allocated to establish public schools for those students who belonged... The author draws analogies between education and power as a recent trend from mediocre backgrounds....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Access to Treatment and Timely Medical Care in Canada

Canadians have continued incurring a higher cost on accessing medical attention due to the problem of accessibility and treatment even after the introduction of historical health insurance According to Roche (1996), 70% of healthcare expenses in Canada are funded through public funds while the rest is covered by sources like insurance premiums and cash payment at the service center by the patients....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Community-Based Corrections, an Issue that is Most Critical Today

"Community-Based Corrections, an Issue that is Most Critical Today" paper gives characteristics and environments of a human service organization, which is the Medicare Program.... The paper thus gives an analysis of how the organization governed and staffed after giving its mission and vision.... ...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Organizing for Success: From Inequality to Quality

arling-Hammonds point in the above statement is valid to a certain extent in that most American public schools today are not providing adequate education to students to develop as intellectuals or even meet the current criteria for real world workplaces.... arling-Hammonds point in the above statement is valid to a certain extent in that most American public schools today are not providing adequate education to students to Organizing for Success: From Inequality to Quality Darling-Hammond reports, "the bureaucratic school created at the turn of the 20th century was not organized to meet these needs for intellectual development or for individual responsiveness....
1 Pages (250 words) Admission/Application Essay

Social Problem in the Canadian Health Care System

The paper "Social Problem in the Canadian Health Care System" states that Canadians have had very low expectations of their national health care system with regards to economic context to the present day.... However, certain factors could be considered in restructuring the Canadian health care system....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

In the Apology, Socrates claims that the unexamined life is not worth living (38a)

The mysterious stuff called mind dwelling in our subterranean realms is so powerful that if we master the art of controlling and building it willfully, then it.... ... ... Where mighty mental powers, if bridled by the soul-force, possible with the knowledge the leads to self-realization, can bring wonders Hence there is the dire need for an individual to work for the goal of self-realization....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Personal Career Strategy as a Financial Consultant

Since this profession requires direct interaction with the public therefore creating and maintaining goodwill is important to retain and grow the business.... It requires a constant level of maintaining good public relations to seek new business and maintain it.... both words are used interchangeably....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The Theoretician and the Experimenter - Eugenics and Francis Galton

This paper "The Theoretician and the Experimenter - Eugenics and Francis Galton" focuses on the fact that F.... Galton is considered as the father of Eugenics, which is a fictitious science that believes that human intellect can be engineered to improve the genetic characteristics of the human race....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us