StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of the Ethics Cases - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Analysis of the Ethics Cases" paper examines the cases concerning ethical egoism and utilitarianism, and the case that describes the most important criticism of utilitarianism that it is not always possible to accurately predict what actions will render the greatest good for the number of people. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Analysis of the Ethics Cases
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of the Ethics Cases"

Ethics Case Studies Case Study A (Ethical Egoism) If Paula follows the dictates of ethical egoism, then she has to find out if the company allows her to make donations as she pleases without anyone questioning her actions or motives. Additionally, she needs to know if she can make donations in secret without the company finding out or even caring about the bribes which she can get from the charities. Fundamentally, ethical egoism asks Paula to work in her own interest and since donating to certain charities is bound to affect her own financial position in a significant way and she has to keep that consideration in mind before she makes any decision to hand out any money (Thiroux and Krasemann, 2006). Of course Paula may feel an intrinsic need to help people and donate to charities which not only help a great number of people but also giver her some benefits in the process. This could be one way in which the demands of both ethical egoism and utilitarianism could be fulfilled. Paula can also take another course of action in which she fully discloses the facts about the charities willing to bribe her to her superiors in the company. She can then show them that she refused to give donations to those charities that are going to bribe her and focused on those who are helping others without bribing anyone. In such a situation, Paula has simply exchanged one advantage to herself for another. Instead of getting money from the charities she would be giving donations to, she has simply gone and established a greater level of trust with her bosses. At the same time, she has shown commitment to her job and to the company’s objective of making the right donations which will certainly improve her position in the long run. It seems that ethical egoism would benefit her regardless of the approach she takes where one benefit is a long term investment to be recuperated later while another is an immediate boost to her bank account (Thiroux and Krasemann, 2006). Case Study A (Utilitarianism) If Paula goes by the rules set for ethics under utilitarianism, she has to make sure that her actions do the greatest good for the greatest number of people (Thiroux and Krasemann, 2006). In this case, the objective of donations and of money being given to others is simple since she has to find out the charity which makes sure that a lot of people are benefited by the money given to them. However, it must be assumed by Paula that giving money to an organization which seeks to help people will do what is best for the people. In some cases, giving people money for nothing may not be the best solution and Paula has to make a careful analysis of which charity deserves money and which has a plan that can be doubted. Of course, by going towards this path, Paula essentially has to ignore her own happiness and advantages which may come from the bribes the charities are willing to give her. However, as per the guidelines of utilitarianism, the greatest good for the greatest number of people is more important than individual benefits (Thiroux and Krasemann, 2006). Case Study Part B The act performed by Edgar was mercy killing or euthanasia which in and of itself is quite a dilemma for most ethical experts. Doctors and medical practitioners in general are supposed to help those in need and the alleviate pain but are not supposed to take active part in ending life. However, in this case Edgar went against the rules given to him and he went against his duties of fighting for the lives of the patients under his care. Moreover, he forged the signature of a doctor, took medicine without permission and administered it to a suffering patient without showing regard for the rules of the hospital. Under the guidelines given by utilitarianism, his actions were certainly going against the concept of doing good since he ended the life of the patient under his care, committed fraud, took part in theft and went against the rules which had been placed by his superiors. At the same time, he certainly acted with good intentions since he wanted to end the suffering of a woman dying from a terminal disease which has no cure. Moreover, he did the woman some good because he ended her pain and suffering. However, it seems that the major reasons a utilitarian would overlook this crime would be the nature of the hospital which is ‘busy’. Rather than use up precious and expensive resources on a dying woman, the same resources could be used to provide life saving services to other individuals who have a realistic hope of being saved by Edgar and his colleagues (Thiroux and Krasemann, 2006). It could be hard to be sure if death is a good consequence for the old woman who had been suffering for a long time but her request was sincere and it sounds like she certainly wished to die. Edgar simply promised to end her suffering and then lived up to the expectations of the old lady. Utilitarianism certainly has problems with it and the situation described in the case study is just one such example where a lot of questions need to be asked and the situation has to be better understood before a decision based on any ethical school can be made. However, since the death of the old lady seems to have resulted in good being done for the old woman and could even be good for her family, utilitarianism might support the actions of Edgar. Similarly, since his actions have freed up the bed and other resources for those who could actually benefit from the hospital services, a utilitarian might actually push for euthanasia to be made an acceptable practice. In fact, it is entirely possible that a utilitarian could actually think that Edgar is behaving unethically if he continues to give care to an old cancer patient while children around him are dying of other lesser but curable diseases. Case Study Part C The case describes the most important criticism of utilitarianism that it is not always possible to accurately predict what actions or decisions will render the greatest good for the greatest number of people in the future (Thiroux and Krasemann, 2006). The judge has to make a decision based on the information that s/he has been provided with and it is clear that one parent will be able to give a life of luxury supported with good health care and private education which might be the best option for the child. On the other hand, the same parent will not be able to provide the personal connection, love and support which the other parent will be able to give. Going with the parent offering a life of luxury also means that the child will have to spend extended periods of time alone or with another caregiver while the parent is away. The parent offering attention and love can not offer money and the financial support which can give the child things such as private school education. It seems that the basic dilemma is between love and money and which would be more important for all concerned parties. The judge might be tempted to put the child in the custody of the rich parent if s/he takes a long term view for society in connection with utilitarianism. A child who has a private school education and is able to excel due to his education may be more beneficial for society as a professional rather than a child who has only received the basics in life. However, a child who has received the basics and has had support and love from the parent could also be a boon for society in terms of how they grow up to be a viable member of society. Additionally, even in present terms, as soon as a decision is made one of the parents is going to be sad while the other is going to be happy which means that the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people is rather difficult to achieve. One solution that does present itself is the idea that the judge can award joint custody to both parents while the parent who provides love and a happy home should retain the child with visitation and support rights for the parent who has offered a life of luxury. In such a case, the child would be able to get the private education as well as the top notch healthcare needed by him/her while being in a house where s/he is given all the attention s/he needs. Of course such a decision may not be possible in which case the judge has to use his best judgment placed with the rules of utilitarianism without knowing the guarantees of the future. Therefore, the parent who can provide a good education and excellent healthcare would be most likely to produce a child who can give something back to society with the education that they have received from being in a home which can afford it. The judge does not know if this decision is going to be good for the future since a child who grows up without love may just become a serial killer and end up costing society a lot more. However, since the good of the people is difficult to ascertain, the judge will most probably be crossing his fingers as s/he makes the decision. Works Cited Thiroux, J. and Krasemann, K. 2006, Ethics: Theory and Practice, Prentice Hall. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Analysis of the Ethics Cases Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Analysis of the Ethics Cases Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/ethics/1706292-ethics-case-studies
(Analysis of the Ethics Cases Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Analysis of the Ethics Cases Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/ethics/1706292-ethics-case-studies.
“Analysis of the Ethics Cases Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/ethics/1706292-ethics-case-studies.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of the Ethics Cases

The Phenomena of Globalization and Liberalization of the Market Economy

Their lending strategies and policies have therefore become the determinants of values, mores, and ethics which are invariably attached to the sphere of commerce.... The dual potential of the lending institutions to create both good and evil in the same measure has placed these institutions under scrutiny by analysis and rights watchdogs for suspected complicity in the geopolitical, and environmental dilemma that has been witnessed in modern times (Weiss, 2005)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Whistleblowers

Even though the number of pursued whistleblowing cases is significantly low, the need to make penalties stricter is critical.... Legal processes do not take word for word when it comes to prosecuting cases.... Combating Corruption, Encouraging ethics: A Practical Guide to Management ethics.... Rather, evidence must be present for evaluation and analysis....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Consultancy Management Techniques for Jaguar Land Rover

In most cases, the information collected must be properly organized.... The present case study "Consultancy Management Techniques for Jaguar Land Rover" dwells on one of the world's renowned car manufacturer shown by research, Jaguar Land Rover.... Admittedly, the Jaguar company has developed and emerged as one of the most recognized brands worldwide....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Why British Petroleum Must Re-Evaluate Its Business Practices

In order to provide a comprehensive discussion of the different ethical dilemmas faced by the firms, it is important to define the ethics and set the broader context for the paper.... ethics is the field of moral philosophy dealing with the questions related to the morality- more specifically ethics deal with the concept of good and bad or evil, virtue and justice.... In a broader sense, ethics, therefore, tend to focus on society's interpretation of what is good and bad and how the idea of justice and fairness should be introduced into society....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Business Ethics - Safety Versus Cost

This case study "Business ethics" concerns the contradiction of safety versus cost that is the main moral issue which features prominently in the Ford and Pinto case study.... It is stated that Ford chose to fend off stiff competition posed by foreign automakers by making a fairly affordable Pinto model....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

BACP Codes of Ethics

Below is a comprehensive analysis of the factors that would impinge the process of counselling, in this case, drawing reference from the BACP codes of ethics and professional behaviour.... This paper "BACP Codes of ethics" discusses the elementary objective of confidentiality that is to protect a client's right to anonymity and privacy by making sure that information divulged to a counselor is not imparted to any other party devoid of informed consent of the client....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

The Use of Memory

Nevertheless, PCB raises its concern with the ethics of these medical procedures.... It raises various concerns regarding ethics violations on the issue, which this paper will reflect.... However, some people and organizations see it as a breach of ethics in society.... It refers to the previous memory analysis as being adaptive....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Services with Respect to Legislation, Ethics, and Globalization in England and Wales

… The paper " Services with Respect to Legislation, ethics, and Globalization in England and Wales " is a perfect example of a case study on the law.... The paper " Services with Respect to Legislation, ethics, and Globalization in England and Wales " is a perfect example of a case study on the law....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us