StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Models of International Human Rights - Statist, Cosmopolitan, and Internationalist - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Models of International Human Rights - Statist, Cosmopolitan, and Internationalist" states that the problems being experienced by a state can be solved using external as well as domestic persons. The question that remains under all the interventions is that who would institute an intervention…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
Models of International Human Rights - Statist, Cosmopolitan, and Internationalist
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Models of International Human Rights - Statist, Cosmopolitan, and Internationalist"

The major issues that the theories seek to address include civil wars, conflict prevention as well as resolution. Humanitarian interventions have not been fully explored as far as human rights models are concerned. However; it is an area that greatly provides strong themes as far as human rights models are concerned.

Statism is one of the models that are very important as far as human rights are concerned in the international regime. Under this model, it is the responsibility of the nation to ensure that human rights are adhered to. This model is similar to that of internationalism and cosmopolitanism. They both hold to the treaties of the universal declaration of human rights universalism. The treaty states that all nations should ensure that the needs of their citizens are met. This model has one weakness; it is the state that takes precedence before any human right can be recognized. Nevertheless, statism is seen as the most appropriate as far as issues regarding politics are concerned. Statism has also resulted in stronger states harassing weaker ones. Therefore, as much as statist is an international regime that looks at the rights of citizens, internationalism and cosmopolitanism looks at the welfare of citizens of a nation with more than statism

Statism is very conservative. As a result, it leads to impassivity in debates regarding humanitarian interventions. In addition, it is inhospitable for persons with just empathy with war victims and other buses of humans. This is because the model has arguments that are in opposition to fellow feelings for other humans. As much as statism rejects interventions that are humanitarian, it is very influential across the world. Statism does not fully oppose international interventions of human rights. The only challenge is that it does not fully support interventions as is seen in cosmopolitanism and internationalism.

The internationalism model on the other hand corresponds to international theory. Internationalism and statists acknowledge that states are central as well as sovereign. Internationalism further focuses on how relations between states are regulated by international communal practices. This aspect is not well manifested in statism. Statists are greatly opposed to states that encourage good relations between member states. As a result, they don’t have feelings for war victims or nations that have witnessed serious crimes against humanity. According to internationalists, if the recipient state authorizes an intervention, they highly encourage it. Statism on the other hand does not fully welcome interventions.

However, both statism and internationalism were used during the First World War and are still applicable today. In exceptional cases, statism allows interventions especially a government collapses. All three models of human rights face major challenges. For example, they have to be approved by a national government of any country before they can be applied to any nation. Thus; the main priority in both cases is the rights the states have as far as any law is concerned. Thereafter, the issues of human rights as far as international laws are concerned then follow later. This comparable conclusion means that there is no major difference in relation to some issues of international contexts.
Cosmopolitanism is also a human rights model that is issued worldwide. Under this model, the international system looks keenly to the factors that affect individual members of a state rather than the state itself. This model is similar to both internationalism and statism.

All of them focus on the states. In fact, internationalism and cosmopolitanism lay great emphasis on the positive aspects of the citizens of a nation. Statism on the other hand looks at the welfare of individuals of a nation with less emphasis on the interventions of victims of war or misfortunes. Thus, in cosmopolitanism, sovereignty is set aside. The major objective is to ensure that needs of citizens of the globe are addressed. Any inhuman acts are grouped along with anyone who opposes international interventions.
In conclusion, the classical view is that sovereignty of all nations should be protected by international law. The major focus should be the sovereignty of citizens but not that of the state. However, there are important themes that people should be knowledgeable about. One of them is that sovereignty of a nation can be interfered with not only by domestic citizens as well as external forces.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare between the three models of international human rights Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1473157-compare-between-the-three-models-of-international
(Compare Between the Three Models of International Human Rights Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1473157-compare-between-the-three-models-of-international.
“Compare Between the Three Models of International Human Rights Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1473157-compare-between-the-three-models-of-international.
  • Cited: 4 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Models of International Human Rights - Statist, Cosmopolitan, and Internationalist

Globalization and Media

"Globalization and Media" paper identifies to what extent is cultural imperialism still a useful conceptual tool for understanding the process of globalization, and briefly explains six political perspectives on Globalization identified by David Held and Anthony McGrew.... ... ... ... David Held and Anthony McGrew identify the different perspectives as viewpoints in the active and ongoing debate about 'whether, or how, to resist, contest, manage or adapt to global forces' (98)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The United Nations and Human Rights

What are the sources of the UN mandate on human rights?... What UN organs and machinery exist to protect and promote human rights?... How important of a role has the UN played in the evolution of human rights?... Despite the utmost efforts, human rights violations are on display.... These violations show up in one form or other ranging from domestic violence to religious extremism, ethnocentric outlook of the societies, exploitation of the weak, human trafficking, poverty, all these make up for human rights violation....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

International Human Rights after WWII

international human rights Number: University: Course: Date: Why Human Rights entered the International Political Process Since WWII and How this was done What are Human Rights?... This section seeks to show what exactly are these human rights, establish why and how they entered into the international political process since WWII, highlight any changes that might have occurred in the character of international relations as well as ascertain the actor that is best suited to pursue international human rights while analyzing the strengths and weaknesses of each actor....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Impact of Globalization on Education

environmental issues or human rights can no longer be determined by national politics alone.... Levitt (as cited in Guillen, 2001, p252) probably based his studies on the consumption of goods across the world when he stated that the consumer of the world has become cosmopolitan.... The governments seek international cooperation since they have problems that can not be solved alone.... It is shared by various forces at national regional and international levels....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice

As the text has it, Jack Donnelly proposes three models of international human rights- statist, cosmopolitan, and internationalist models.... The present essay entitled "Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice" is focused on the internationalist model for international human rights.... Among the three models, the most successful in international human rights is the internationalist model, while the least successful is the statist model because the latter treats international relations as peripheral when it plays an important part in determining and practicing human rights across national borders....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

History of United States Presidents considered Internationalists

Being an internationalist entails a lot of things.... It is critical to note that one may be termed n internationalist on the basis of his positions on a number of things these may involve the position he or she holds towards fighting for the rights of humanity.... Social justice to one's citizens as well as to the whole world is one of the qualifications that can make one become an internationalist.... The other reason that can make one be viewed as an internationalist is the vision, mission as well as he undertakings o that person in order to solve international crises....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Notion of Liberal Internationalism

The scope of the analysis will be grounded on evaluating the background of Liberal internationalism and providing an insight into the aspect of international security.... iberal internationalism within the context of international relations can be traced back to United States 28th president Woodrow Wilson.... The objective of this particular international organization was war prevention through adopting a system of international dispute settlement, disarmament, and collective security....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Must Effective Democracy Be Limited to the Nation States

s a result, democratic theorists of modern democracy according to (Mitrany, 1975) believe in an 'anarchical society' while democratic theorists of international relations either political or economic believe in democracy.... Both Held (1995) and Clark (1999) have agreed that It was only after the end of the cold war era that it became possible for the international relations theory and democratic theory to reflect a common idea of should constitute democracy that is not governed by territorial borders and that has evolved to be termed as transnational or global democracy build on principles of global ethics....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us