StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

What was Socrates accused of and why What can we learn about Athenia the outcome - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Socrates was accused by Meletus of two crimes, namely that he was guilty “of corrupting the young and of not believing in the gods in whom the city believes”. This means that there were both moral and religious reasons behind the charges brought against them…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
What was Socrates accused of and why What can we learn about Athenia the outcome
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What was Socrates accused of and why What can we learn about Athenia the outcome"

Download file to see previous pages

Socrates was accused by Meletus of two crimes, namely that he was guilty “of corrupting the young and of not believing in the gods in whom the city believes”. This means that there were both moral and religious reasons behind the charges brought against them. A closer analysis of the documents written by Plato reveals, however, that these two charges reveal a great deal about the state of Athenian democracy at that time, and they demonstrate how much of a danger Socrates and his teaching represented to those in power.

The first charge of corrupting the young relates to the habit that Socrates had of gathering his pupils around him and engaging in long discussions about a wide range of subjects. His method of teaching was to construct dialogues with his pupils, urging them to question everything and use their minds to think through the issues of the day and their implications. He did not write things down, or require his students to repeat his ideas, but instead he concentrated on helping people to formulate their own ideas.

He taught a method of arguing that led people into illogical conclusions, so that they could learn about how to think and argue. This necessarily brought Socrates and his students into conflict with people who had high status and authority. D’Amato (1975, p. 1082) explains that the type of radical training that Socrates offered was perceived as a way of encouraging young citizens to challenge their elders. This was frowned upon because it caused embarrassment when these supposedly clever elders did not have the counter-arguments to defeat their younger critics.

It seems, then, that Athenian society was not ready for the wit and courage that the young people acquired from Socrates, and that this was one of the main reasons why he was brought to trial. Young people were expected to defer to the wisdom of their elders, and to adhere to the long traditions of the city, whereas Socrates was perceived as a disturbing element who threatened to upset the natural order. The second charge relating to the way that Socrates allegedly did not adhere to the worship of the gods of the city suggests that there was a fundamental issue in the teachings of the philosopher which ran counter to the prevailing ideology of the city.

Socrates attempts to clarify whether he is being accused of atheism (Plato, 2000, p. 29) which he denies, or of teaching students to worship a wider range of gods than the ones preferred in Athenian society. It is confirmed that Meletus accuses him of “impiety” (Plato, 2000, p 37) which implies a denial of the existence of the gods altogether as well as bad behaviour resulting from this alleged lack of respect for the traditional gods. This accusation reveals that it is the practice of philosophy itself which is perceived by the authorities as a crime.

Socrates argues that here have been many different gods in Greek history, and many different thinkers have suggested a myriad outlandish ideas which do not necessarily fit exactly with prevailing opinion (Plato, 2000, pp. 9-10). The dialogues which Plato records show Socrates as a man concerned precisely with “moral virtues like justice, courage, moderation and wisdom (the four “cardinal virtues” of the Ancient Greeks)” (Roochnik, 2004, p. 82). By bringing these matters into a debate, he suggests that the truth is not yet truly known about them, and this in turn can be interpreted as a criticism of the prevailing customs and habits in the world around him.

Greek society was not perfect by any means, and Socrates was trying to encourage reflection, rather than promoting immoral conduct. Socrates taught more than just the obedience to the laws and traditions of Athenian society, or literal belief in every point of the old stories about the gods. He wanted his students to think about what it actually meant to lead a virtuous life and to turn that theoretical knowledge in to practice by changing the way that

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“What was Socrates accused of and why What can we learn about Athenia Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1487307-what-was-socrates-accused-of-and-why-what-can-we
(What Was Socrates Accused of and Why What Can We Learn about Athenia Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1487307-what-was-socrates-accused-of-and-why-what-can-we.
“What Was Socrates Accused of and Why What Can We Learn about Athenia Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1487307-what-was-socrates-accused-of-and-why-what-can-we.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What was Socrates accused of and why What can we learn about Athenia the outcome

A Jurors Perspective in the Case against Socrates

Of concern is the substance of which he enquires about.... He has said that he enquires about the presence and the nature of knowledge in selected persons.... It is an insult to the time-honored belief about the gods and the heroes of our history (Colaiaco 62).... In the evaluation of the evidence brought before the court, nothing can summarily prove that the accused does not pray to our gods.... If his chosen way of life does not harm anyone, and no one can confirm that he harmed anyone by being curious, then I find no fault at that....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Socratic religion: Is Socrates irreligious or impious

what Socrates stated that he was against were the stories that were associated with different Greek gods.... what Socrates stated that he was against were the stories that were associated with different Greek gods.... Socrates hinted at his belief in a unified God who holds a firm opinion on what constitutes as being un-pious or pious.... In the ‘Euthyphro', Socrates adopted a skeptical view of different aspects of traditional Greek belief in the abilities of gods and goddesses even though he still remained deeply religious himself, as was evidenced in the statements “Holiness is what is pleasing to the gods…If you are pleasing the gods with sacrifices, then you are doing what is pleasing to them” (Plato and Gallop 2008)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Socrates Defense of Athenian Law

If we accept Lewis' critique of emotional subjectivism (Gaius and Titus' position) in 'Abolition of Man' like sound, we cannot interpret Socrates' actions as merely the result of his subjective feelings.... Why would Lewis insist that we interpret Plato's Socrates in this way?... what is the most important reasons Socrates providing for this position in defence of Athenian law?... He said this even though he was aware that he had been unjustly accused....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Socrates and His Trial

nbsp; Also, more knowledge about the teachings and life of Socrates is available through the memoirs of Xenophon (Aristophanes, Irvine, and Plato 14).... These citizens usually gathered around him to seek wisdom about how to conduct them justly and right.... nbsp;             These enemies made true their threats and held Socrates accountable for the teachings he gave his followers about justice, virtue, and morality within the society....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Reflective Writing Assignments

This is because free will is an important component of life, and thus without it, life can be sometimes unbearable.... For instance, a person can live without free will but he is properly treated and therefore, exposed to good things.... This is because there are no restrictions on what a person is to do.... This is because there is more suffering in a world with free will since every person does what pleases him or her without considering the consequences of such action to other people within the surroundings (Campbell 25)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Socrates and Meletus reagrading Socrate's trial

Indeed, it indicates the accusations, which were labeled against the socrates and the manner they defended themselves.... The essay is a discussion on the ways the socrates and Meletus reagraded the… During the Socrate's trial, one of the people commented that, the estates belonging to one of the Athenian aristocrats were confiscated by the oligarchy (Doug 29).... Indeed, the remark was meant to spark the tension between the oligarchs and the Athenians, breading assignment is due socrates and Meletus Reagarding Socrate's Trial Introduction The trial of the socrates was one of the interesting occurrences in Athens....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Historical Origins of Mercenaries

The author of the "Historical Origins of Mercenaries" paper states that policing the world and preventing aggressive and horrific acts is the most honorable of professions.... If the world will recognize the benefit of mercenaries, the world will be a better place in which to live for its inhabitants....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Views on Teaching Athenians: Socrates, Thoreau, and the Sophists

hellip; “Know thyself” was the fundamental principle of Socratic philosophy that characterized Socrates' view about the world and the self.... Ironically, few historical documents are kept and scholars rely only on fragmented details describing Socrates since he refused to write about himself and his life as a thinker.... Navia (2007) advised that while we are reading Socratic characteristics from the different sources, we have to questions all of them, though he comments further in the book that the Socrates descriptions are an authentic reflection of the “complex and multifaceted presence of Socrates (91)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us