StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Legal Limitations of Digital Forensics - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The study "Legal Limitations of Digital Forensics" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the legal limitations of digital forensics. Many disciplines are related to cyber security. However, digital forensics closely influences case laws…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
Legal Limitations of Digital Forensics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Legal Limitations of Digital Forensics"

Case Analysis Case Analysis Many disciplines are related to cyber security. However, digital forensics closely influences case laws. The regulatory processes and the ability of digital experts to produce the evidence in a court of law influence the growth and evolution of digital forensics. The conflict between privacy laws and the need to search and seize digital material affects most of the cases (Ami-Narh, 2008). The rulings of the Court have influenced the forensic collection, handling, analyzing and preservation of forensic evidence. Case 1: Daubert vs. the United States Supreme Court Introduction In June 28, 1993, the Unites States Supreme Court passed a landmark ruling that solved a significant contemporary issue (Gostin & Milbank Memorial Fund, 2002). The Daubert vs. Marrel Dow Pharmaceutical Inc. ruling resolved the debate on admitting evidence in the court. As a result, the Daubert ruling is one of the most consequential decisions about the role of forensic evidence in the judicial process. The Case The Daubert case involved a toxic tort case. The court heard that two boys, Jason Daubert and Erick Schuller were born with serious defects because of the negative effects of a drug made by Benedictin. The plaintiff believed that they had been affected because the mother had taken the anti-nausea drug Benedictin while she was pregnant. The two boys decided to sue the organization. The decision placed them among numerous people who were suing for damages. The case got into the public domain because of disputes over the introduction of expert testimony (Gostin & Milbank Memorial Fund, 2002). The ruling would not only affect the case but also determine how forensic evidence such as digital evidence would be allowed in the case. The Supreme Court Decision The Supreme Court accepted the case due to the realization that it needed to set the standard for the admissibility of forensic evidence. The major issue was whether the adoption of Federal Rules of Evidence should get more prominence than the Frye standard that had played a significant role in the case. The Supreme Court ruled that the F.R.E should receive more weight than the Frye standard (Coleman, Swenson, Holloway, & Aulinskas, 1994). The rule shifted power from the Frye test and gave the judge powers of determining which evidence should apply in the case. The ruling implied that judges could determine the admissibility of scientific evidence as opposed to only determining the credibility of a witness. An evaluation of the ruling demonstrates that four criteria should apply when determining the admissibility of evidence. Firstly, the court should consider if the theory or technique has been tested and proved. Secondly, the court should consider if the theory or technique has been subjected to technical review. Thirdly, the court should evaluate the potential errors that may result from the application of the theory or technique. Fourthly, the court should determine if the theory or the technique in question has got in its scientific community. The 1999 Kumho Tire vs. Carmichael expanded the scope of the Daubert requirement to include technology expertise (Simon, 2010). The ruling established a precedent that determines the evidentiary application of scientific and technological evidence (Coleman, Swenson, Holloway, & Aulinskas, 1994). For example, the introduction of computer evidence must meet the four criteria established by the Supreme Court. Conclusion The Daubert ruling settled a significant debate about the role of expert testimony in judicial proceedings. In addition, the ruling is applicable in computer forensics. Consequently, the legal community should now focus on determining if the digital forensics industry is establishing the requisite standards that will meet the Daubert threshold. Case 2: Mapp vs. Ohio Introduction The United States of America courts would suppress the use of evidence obtained through illegal seizure. The principle applies to all forms of evidence including digital evidence as established in Mapp vs. Ohio 367 U.S 643(1961). The case extended an existing federal precedent to State courts. The Case In May 23, 1957, Cleveland police intended to search the home of Dollree Mapp. They believed that she was harboring a bombing suspect. Dollree refused to open the door before she saw a warrant. However, the police returned a few hours later and claimed that they had obtained a search warrant. However, they did not allow her to see the warrant. Although the police failed to find the bombing suspect, they found pornographic material and subsequently arrested her. In the first court case, she was found guilty for violating laws that prohibited the production or use of pornographic material in the state at that time. Dollree Mapp decided to appeal to the Supreme Court on the basis that the Cleveland police had violated her First Amendment right to exercise freedom of expression (McInnis, 2009). Losing her appeal of the Ohio Court ruling forced her to appeal to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court accepted her case because it wanted to establish if her constitutional right to freedom of expression was violated. The implications of the Ruling The Supreme Court decided to ignore the question of whether or not she was guilty of possessing obscene material. Instead, it decided to focus on the freedom of expression. The ruling demonstrated that the Supreme Court believes that the prosecution of suspects should not undermine the freedom of expression. As a result, digital forensic experts should ensure that the process of identifying and gathering the digital evidence does not undermine the rights of a suspect (Ami-Narh, 2008). For instance, computer equipment or files are only obtainable when the police have a search warrant. However, the ruling raised many concerns over the application of the exclusionary principle. In addition, it set a high standard for the admission of forensic evidence. As a result, the digital forensic community should focus on ensuring that the evidence meets the required threshold. Conclusion The Mapp vs. Ohio Supreme Court ruling determined the management of digital and physical evidence. A Weeks vs. United States Supreme Court Decision in 1914 stated that the evidence received in an illegal manner should not get in a Federal court. Consequently, the Supreme Court decision in the Mapp case focused on whether that precedent applied to the states. The 6-3 ruling in favor of Mapp demonstrated that the Supreme Court believed that the evidence that both state and federal courts should not admit evidence whose source is illegal. As a result, digital evidence must be gathered within the established legal frameworks in order to be admitted into the case. The growing adoption of technology in both individual lives and the society are set to increase its application in court proceedings. As a result, the establishment of standards that guide the evidentiary application of forensic evidence is a significant measure. However, technology changes at a faster rate than the law. Consequently, there should be a sustained effort to ensure that the standards that have been established by the Supreme Court enhance rather than inhibiting the application of the rule of law. References Ami-Narh, J. T. (2008). Digital forensics and the legal system: A dilemma of our times. Retrieved from http://ro.ecu.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1040&context=adf Coleman, H., Swenson, E., Holloway, D., & Aulinskas, T. (1994). DNA in the courtroom: A trial watchers guide. Seattle, Wash., USA: GeneLex Corp. Gostin, L. O., & Milbank Memorial Fund. (2002). Public health law and ethics: A reader. Berkeley, Calif: University of California Press. McInnis, T. N. (2009). The evolution of the Fourth Amendment. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books. Simon, R. I. (2010). Study guide to forensic psychiatry: A companion to the American psychiatric publishing textbook of forensic psychiatry. Washington: Amer Psychiatric. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case Analysis Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 3”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/information-technology/1664450-case-analysis
(Case Analysis Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 3)
https://studentshare.org/information-technology/1664450-case-analysis.
“Case Analysis Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 3”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/information-technology/1664450-case-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legal Limitations of Digital Forensics

Criminal Profiling And Remote Monitoring Of A Computer

Due to this, the sector of digital forensics investigation has been opened and is in continuous development, in order to come to date with the digitally advanced types of crimes.... To monitor different computers, various Internet or computer management tools were introduced, which have now developed into mechanized practices used by forensics experts to find evidence from computers during an investigation.... Both the types of criminal profiling help in the digital forensic investigations....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Computer/ Digital Forensics

Scope of digital forensics: Digital forensics is not just limited to mere study of the physical devices that may have been used, such as the computer, hardware in particular rather it entails a long section.... This report "Computer/ digital forensics" sheds some light on the fact that computer has become an integral part of our social and private life, but it is the most vulnerable form of communication and is prone to all kinds of challenges and obstacles.... any element that may have been used to achieve the nefarious objectives entails the scope of digital forensic science and investigation, any I....
10 Pages (2500 words) Report

Digital Forensics and Digital Investigation

The paper " digital forensics and Digital Investigation" tells that with the fast growth of technology, it is not easy for law enforcement and computer experts to be ahead of the technologically knowledgeable criminals.... Usually, EEDI is a superset of the whole thing about digital forensics.... It presumes that one can take care of the forensics of a computer's hard drive and also can gather the logs from a firewall and manage all the evidence appropriately as per the standard practices, for instance, the Association of Chief Police Officers (ACPO) 'Good Practice Guide for Computer-based Evidence'....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Digital Evidence: Understanding The Process and Challenges

Physical evidence is the computers and its peripherals while digital evidence is the visuals on a monitor, the materials printed using a printer and any other form of digital storage medium (Tipton & Krause, 2007, p.... This paper outlines computer forensics, the lifecycle of computer crimes, digital information, juridical and legal issues, problems and safety.... omputer forensics is a comparatively new branch of the crime investigational system and involves collecting digital evidence from the crime scene by the analysis of the computers systems, networks, and servers in addition to numerous other digital devices (Sahu, 2008, p....
13 Pages (3250 words) Assignment

Peculiarities of Digital Forensic

This coursework describes the peculiarities of digital forensic.... This paper demonstrates the importance of computer forensics, the process involved with it, data collection, admissibility of digital forensic evidence and detection of hidden data.... Since computer forensics is a fresh discipline, there is less consistency and reliability across the courts and industry.... Computer forensics may be defined as the discipline that merges fundamentals of law and computer science to gather and study data from computer systems, networks, wireless communications, and storage devices in such a way that is acceptable as proof in a court of law....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Challenges in Mobile Forensic Technologies

esides problems in carrying out investigations on mobile devices, there are problems that have been associated with general digital forensics.... These differences bring about technical difficulties in mobile forensics.... The last challenge with mobile forensics is that there is not one specific software tools that are used in data extraction.... The acquisition and presentation of electronic evidence from desktop or laptop computers are surrounded by more technology-oriented difficulties than traditional forensics, which used to be based on paper....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Cyber Crime and Forensic Investigation

lectronic crime is very difficult to investigate and prosecute, mainly due to the fact that investigators have to build their cases based on artifacts left on computer systems (Pajek and Pimenidis, 2009) Nowadays, computer criminals are aware of computer forensics methods and techniques and try to use countermeasure techniques to efficiently impede the investigation processes.... The methodologies used against the computer forensics processes are collectively called Anti-forensics....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

The Digital Forensic Process

The limitations of the reactive digital forensic process overcome the proactive forensic process with a good overview of proactively collecting, preserving data, detection, analysis of the extracted evidence and reporting the incident as it occurs.... igital forensics is a set of tools, techniques, and methods utilized to collect, preserve and analyze digital data obtained from digital sources such as media, in an incident with the objective of extracting valid evidence to be presented to the court of law....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us