StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Comparative Analysis of Impeachment of American Presidents - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Comparative Analysis of Impeachment of American Presidents" discusses that in everyday language “politics” in a democratic nation like the United States is the subject of who gets elected to office and what they do with the powers granted to them by voters…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Comparative Analysis of Impeachment of American Presidents
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparative Analysis of Impeachment of American Presidents"

Download file to see previous pages

It is befitting to introduce this paper with the excerpt from the book, Checking Executive Power: Presidential Impeachment in Comparative Perspective (Baumgartner& Kada, 2003):
Presidential impeachment is the equivalent of a political earthquake. It convulses, disrupts, and in many cases, polarizes the body politic as few political events can…Presidential impeachment is, in short, an extraordinary political event (1).
Further, it is important to mention that only two elected presidents of the United States of America __Andrew Johnson, and Bill Clinton have and faced and won the Senatorial trial of an impeachment, while Richard Nixon resigned before the proceedings began, in the United States of America’s over two hundred years political history. In addition, this paper implicitly deals with the ethical as opposed to political dilemmas each president faced while in office.
Before we get into the discussion it is necessary to make clear to the reader the meaning of the word/term__ impeachment.
…, before Clinton’s impeachment in 1998, many U.S. citizens understood “impeachment” to mean removal from office. But there are other questions about the process as well (Baumgartner& Kada, 2003,p1-2).
In fact “impeachment” is the worst-case scenario a president can find himself in while in the Oval Office. It can spell the end of the political career of the man who has spent the majority of his life to achieve the presidency of the greatest country in the world. Impeachment can not only hurt him constitutionally but economically, socially and morally/ethically as well. For example, the impeachment of Andrew Jackson, “…was an extraordinary drama that held potentially important constitutional implications…” (Stewart,2009,p252).
The hypothetical questions that are posed in this paper are:
1. If you were a member of the Senate, which ethical charge would you bring against each president?
Personally, I would charge Andrew Jackson of being a racist; Richard Nixon of perjury and invasion of privacy, and Bill Clinton with perjury and grave sexual misdemeanor.
2. Should each president be impeached? Removed from office? Tried and convicted?
Yes according to me each should have been impeached, that is certainly each should have been tried and convicted.
3. In each case were the actions of the Senate ethical? Were they politically motivated?
Yes, the actions of the Senate were ethical, viewed from a high moral ground but there is no doubt about the fact that they were politically motivated.
4. What arguments do these ethical dilemmas bring up? For example, where should the line be drawn between personal issues and the issues which affect a President’s ability to govern?
The main ethical argument that these impeachment movements bring does the constitution allows the Senate or its Judicial Committee to act as a moral policeman.
5. Are criminal proceedings in any of the cases? Why or why not?
In the case of Richard Nixon and Jackson criminal proceedings were the appropriate case while in the case of Bill Clinton, the line between a crime and a misdemeanor is blurred, still, the situation warranted the initiation of criminal litigation in a competent court of law.
It is an endless contest…in which ambitious spend their lives struggling to come out on top (Davis & Peltason, 2007, p vii).

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“In a 3-5 page paper, compare and contrast the impeachment trials of Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1587877-in-a-3-5-page-paper-compare-and-contrast-the-impeachment-trials-of-andrew-johnson-richard-nixon-and-bill-clinton-identify-ethical-dilemmas-presented-by-each-be-sure-to-focus-on-the-trial-proceedings-in-the-senate-and-political-aspects-of-the-impeachm
(In a 3-5 Page Paper, Compare and Contrast the Impeachment Trials of Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/law/1587877-in-a-3-5-page-paper-compare-and-contrast-the-impeachment-trials-of-andrew-johnson-richard-nixon-and-bill-clinton-identify-ethical-dilemmas-presented-by-each-be-sure-to-focus-on-the-trial-proceedings-in-the-senate-and-political-aspects-of-the-impeachm.
“In a 3-5 Page Paper, Compare and Contrast the Impeachment Trials of Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1587877-in-a-3-5-page-paper-compare-and-contrast-the-impeachment-trials-of-andrew-johnson-richard-nixon-and-bill-clinton-identify-ethical-dilemmas-presented-by-each-be-sure-to-focus-on-the-trial-proceedings-in-the-senate-and-political-aspects-of-the-impeachm.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparative Analysis of Impeachment of American Presidents

Comparative Analysis between Japan and Brazil Economies

This paper will provide in depth comparative analysis of the two countries since the rise of Keynesian theory to the current economic and political standing of the two countries.... Instructor Date comparative analysis between Japan and Brazil Economies Introduction Japan and Brazil are two countries that have stable and fast growing economies and political systems....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Search and Seizure: 1700s Reasoning and 2000s Technology

The researcher of this term paper takes a look into the historical background of Fourth Amendment that provides an insight into the way the modern analysis today does work.... This term paper dscribes the United States Constitution Amendment Four, that was written in the year 1791 and stipulates that people have a right to be always secure in their houses, persons, or papers....
15 Pages (3750 words) Term Paper

History and International Relations

american datelines: major news stories from colonial times to the present.... Print This book highlights landmarks and milestones in american history, based on news stories from the colonial period until the present.... his book helped me gain a general perspective of various landmark events in american history.... It provided an account of the fall of the Berlin wall which was written from an american perspective.... This book features newsworthy additions on the accounts of the fall of the Berlin Wall, as well as the Clinton impeachment and the OJ Simpson trial....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

A New Democracy: Parliamentarism versus Presidentialism

A thorough comparative analysis of presidential and parliamentary reveals that all things considered, the latter is more advantageous to established democracy than the former.... This argument is substantiated by an analysis of Angola's case, a country struggling to finally establish a truly democratic government.... Parliamentary regimes may consist of presidents who are chosen through direct popular election, but they generally do not have the capacity to vie forcefully for authority with the Prime Minister (Diamond, Plattner, & Costopoulos, 2010)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Critical Review of Juan Linz's 'The Perils of Presidentialism'

There is also a risk that presidents personalize the power that they have and a danger that if they drop out of the role in the middle of the term, an unsuitable and unelected running mate whom no one seriously would have considered for the top job can be thrust into power.... sh parliamentary system and the american presidential system as the best known examples, Linz argues that both can be successful but that the parliamentary system is both more widespread in the modern world and more likely to lead to a stable democracy....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

The Rules and Grounds for Impeachments

Some of the more recent and he highly controversial amongst all times was the impeachment of Chief Justice Samuel Chase, impeachments of President Andrew Johnson, Richard Nixon, and President Bill Clinton.... The author states that the grounds of impeachment are all most same in all the countries with a trivial disparity like in Philippine Constitution the grounds for impeachment include bribery, graft and corruption, betrayal of public trust, and culpable violation of the Constitution whereas in US constitution the grounds are treason, bribery....
17 Pages (4250 words) Research Paper

Writer Choice - Ahmed

Different geographers have made contributions through observations of climates and weather and what influences them, display as well as analysis of data that are related to field research practices.... This paper looks at the geographical aspect of Uruguay as well as other important factors that factors that have been as a result of the geographical aspect of the country, as well as that, have contributed to the geographical features of Uruguay....
50 Pages (12500 words) Research Paper

World Politics, Department Of Government And International Relations

The main focus of the paper " World Politics, Department Of Government And International Relations" is on american society and the U.... decision to retreat from Vietnam, the american anti-Vietnam War movement: why the Americans were against the Vietnam War, why the US retreated from Vietnam?... The opposition to the war by american society began to manifest itself as early as 1968.... disengage from Vietnam without causing defeat to the american troops....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us