StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Legal Reasoning and Writing - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
With consideration of the constitutional provisions for rights and liberty under the Fourteenth Amendment, together with other constitutional provisions that limit personal rights and grant states legislative authority, would Mr. Russell Dalrymple have a viable argument in court…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.8% of users find it useful
Legal Reasoning and Writing
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Legal Reasoning and Writing"

Memorandum Re: Question presented With consideration of the constitutional provisions for rights and liberty under the Fourteenth Amendment, together with other constitutional provisions that limit personal rights and grant states legislative authority, would Mr. Russell Dalrymple have a viable argument in court that the norovirus vaccination requirement failed the public health necessity holding of Jacobson? Short answerMr. Russell lacks a valid argument in the case because even though the Fourteenth amendment protect private rights and liberty, the constitution also restricts such rights at the public’s interest and recognizes states’ legislative authority that the courts would uphold based on the precedent that the case of Jacobson v Massachusetts’ (1905) set.

Statement of factsFacts to the case identify an epidemic, viral gastroenteritis, in the nation, which is also significant in the capital of South Caledonia. There has been a series of the viral infection that affects groups such as people in schools, apartment complexes, and has been reported in large emergency shelters. Viral gastroenteritis causes fever, abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea, and affects people by limiting their ability to go to work when they are sick or by forcing people to stay at home to take care of the infection’s victims.

There are however only few cases of hospitalization and two reported fatalities. A vaccine was developed a year ago and the FDA approved it for its proven effectiveness and limited adverse effects that is only realized as a sore at the point of injection. State Legislature of South Caledonia then passed a law requiring all people to receive vaccination with a fine of $ 750 for non-compliance unless a person receives state approval for exemption. Even though Mr. Russell does not qualify for exemption under the statute, he does not wish to apply for exemption and does not want to receive vaccination.

Instead, he wishes to sue the state for protection of his liberty. DiscussionThe constitution, statutes, and case laws are some of the sources of law for guiding judicial decisions and the case of Jacobson v Massachusetts (1905) offers a basis for interpreting conflicting provisions of the constitution and the statute of South Caledonia. While the constitution provides for protection of individuals rights and liberty, Fourteenth Amendment, it also restricts such rights based on rights of other citizens, the Ninth Amendment, and grants states legislative power (Schultz, 2009).

The facts of the Jacobson v Massachusetts’ case in which Jacobson declined to receive vaccination for chicken pox, arguing that his son and he would react to the vaccine, are consistent with Mr. Russell’s case and therefore establish the Jacobson v Massachusetts as a precedent. In the case, the courts held, at different levels that the plaintiff’s autonomy was limited to the interest of the public and he was liable for failing to receive vaccination (Gostin, 2002). ConclusionJacobson v Massachusetts’ case identifies with the facts of the case and would therefore be used as a precedent for interpreting the various provisions of the constitution and the statute of South Caledonia.

The courts are therefore likely to uphold public interest and the statute against Russell’s argument for autonomy. Russell would therefore lack a valid argument because constitution restricts his autonomy and the statute is constitutional. ReferencesGostin, L. (2002). Public health law and ethics: A reader. New York, NY: University of California Press. Schultz, D. (2009). Encyclopedia of the United States constitution. New York, NY: Infobase Publishing.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Legal Reasoning and Writing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Legal Reasoning and Writing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1630605-legal-reasoning-and-writing
(Legal Reasoning and Writing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Legal Reasoning and Writing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1630605-legal-reasoning-and-writing.
“Legal Reasoning and Writing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1630605-legal-reasoning-and-writing.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legal Reasoning and Writing

Lord Chief Justice Sir Edward Coke: The Greatest Defender of the Common Law

Coke was dynamically involved in the legal system for more than four decades.... Ultimately, in the concluding phases of the Elizabethan period, he started publishing a variety of legal writings that showed a broad understanding of past English legal references and an unmatched capacity to consolidate the multiple components of English common law; and, alongside his extensive legal experience and his politically powerful status, they finally recognised him as the most important legal expert of his time....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Comparison of Night by Elie Wiesel and The Shawl by Cynthia Ozick

This means that any major similarities or differences that are noticed in the two passages selected shall be discussed from the perspectives of the themes used by the writers, style of writing, themes covered in the writings, as well as any identified problems.... Style of writing Reading through “Night” and “The Shawl”, readers get a sense of feeling that two different forms of writings are presented.... This is rooted in the general approach used by the two writers, manifesting in the style of writing they used to present their work....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The importance of writing skills

writing has always been a profound, visceral experience for me.... writing has always been a profound, visceral experience for me.... Evaluating my works from the past year gave me a fresh perspective on my writing and made me see some faults that I haven't seen before.... As I matured and acquired more experience, the quality of my writing also took the same direction.... I have developed my own writing style and idiosyncrasies....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Death of Reasoning

In the essay “The Death of reasoning” the author analyzes the poem, I felt a Funeral in my Brain, which speaks of a funeral in the literal and imaginative sense.... This "dropping down" and "hit a world at every plunge" conveys that the persona because of her failure to understand brought about by constant rationalizing and reasoning suddenly identifies what has died in the end, "And Finished knowing then_....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Brief Facts about Legal Cases

legal reasoning: Referring to the Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, the appellate court ruled that experts may testify to any fact or opinion based on “specialized knowledge that will assist the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue” provided the expert is “qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education” (Rule 702).... legal Issues: Delatorre appealed his convictions on the grounds that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate the conviction on each of the counts....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Law and the Constitution in Canada

Due to the aforementioned concepts and functions of legal reasoning and scholarship, the Canadian society have accepted Aboriginals rights and title as outlined in section 35 (1).... legal reasoning and scholarship remained integral in making ruling over aboriginals rights based on Delgamuukw case.... legal reasoning is essential in explaining the inherent difference between partisan and impartial legal decisions.... legal reasoning remains indispensable in arbitration of varied beliefs and values of the Canadian society towards acceptance of legal decisions2....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Operational Plan for a Company

This paper ''Operational Plan'' tells that since our business aims to provide numerous products spiced up with the Old Bay seasoning, a contract will be reached with McCormick and the company to allow us to purchase and use their final product.... hellip; The Old Bay Seasonings will include old bay seasoning, hot old bay seasoning, and old bay crab cake classic mix, among other McCormick Company products that will be rebranded as per Bay Delight requirements and sold at Vanilla Bay....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Jan - Content Writer

Strong writing skills, Problem-solving, Attention to details, Time management, Service excellence, Strong interpersonal skills, Strong communicative skills, Reasoning skills, Decision-making Senior Content Specialist - TrueAccordSan Francisco, CA - 2017 - PresentManaged and organized multiple projects simultaneously from start to finish and actively metstrict deadlines for routing projects internally and externallyTrained new team members and colleagues on internal products and best practicesMeasured and tested new content through experiments and A/B tests, reviewed performancemetricsProvided feedback for new internal products and enhancementsPiloted company's first content program and provided a feedback loop to the source....
2 Pages (500 words) Resume/CV
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us