StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of the Illegal Storage - Case Study Example

Summary
The paper "Analysis of the Illegal Storage Case"  describes a leading case on adverse possession as that of J.A. Pye (Oxford) Ltd v Graham.1 In this case, the Grahams occupied fields that were owned by Pye, but to which they had been granted a grazing right…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Analysis of the Illegal Storage Case
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of the Illegal Storage"

Adverse Possession Introduction: The leading case on adverse possession is that of J.A. Pye (Oxford) Ltd v Graham In this case, the Grahams occupied fields that were owned by Pye, but to which they had been granted a grazing right that expired in 1984, which had never been renewed. Since Pye showed no further interest in the property, the Grahams continued to graze the land and claimed their rights over the land by virtue of their long undisputed possession. However, a challenge has been posed to the concept of adverse possession, when Pye was granted unanimous permission by the European Convention of Human Rights on 8th June 2004 to do so on grounds of incompatibility with Article 1 of Protocol No: 1 to the ECHR2. This Protocol provides that “no one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by the general principles of international law.”3 Recent legislation such as the Land registration Act of 2002 has also brought about significant changes to legislate against squatters, by clarifying that no matter how long the land has been adversely possessed, it will not bar the paper owner’s title to the registered land.4 Moreover, the negation of overriding interests under the Land Registration Act of 2002 also provide an indication that the new legislative provisions are averse to adverse possession, largely due to the need to protect the needs of the owners. However, public interests could sometimes favor adverse possession. Adverse possession: Pre conditions to invoke such impregnable possession included physical occupation of the property5. As stated in the case of Powell v McFarlane, “Factual possession signifies an appropriate degree of physical control…….. ……broadly, I think what must be shown as constituting factual possession is that the alleged possessor has been dealing with the land as an occupying owner might have been expected to deal with it and that no-one else has done so.”6 Another condition that may invoke such possession right includes an intention to possess the land7 without the consent of the actual owner8. One of the salient points noted by Browne Wilkinson in allowing the judgment for the defendant in the case of Pye was the issue of whether the defendant squatter had “dispossessed the paper owner by going into ordinary possession of the land for the requisite period without the consent of the owner.”9 On the basis of earlier legislative provisions, such as the Limitation Act of 198010 those who had been in adverse possession of land for a period of twelve years had the right to apply for the title of the land with no action possible against them by the actual owners, as per Section 15(1) of the Limitation Act of 1980. As a result, this subordinated the rights of the actual paper title owner, giving the squatter “a title superior to all others.”11 However, with the revised position of Parliament and the Law Commission as reflected in the Land Registration Act of 2002, as well as the decision of the European Court of Human Rights, the existing principle on adverse possession is under attack. However, what needs to be noted in this context is the fact that the rights of those in possession of land for long periods are now being undermined. The old law was geared towards providing the right of title to those who openly possessed the land and against whom the paper owners has not bothered to take any action. In some instances where the owners may not bother to maintain or attend to the upkeep of the property, it would be in the larger public interest to ensure that the land title is provided to those adversely possessing it, who are doing all the work of maintenance and upkeep. For example, in the case of Topplan estates Limited v Townley12, the Court held in favor of the defendant and stated that the law of adverse possession was justified when the paper owner made no effort to oversee the property. This was also the case in Purbrick v Hackney where Neuberger J stated that “A period of 12 years is a long period during which to neglect a property completely.”13 On the one hand is the issue of the squatters who have maintained full possession of the land without the owner’s consent with the intention to hold on to the land14. The issue of neglect of a property owner is a vital one in allowing adverse possession to accrue to those who are able to prove the owner’s eschewing of his rights to his land.15 Those who have thus gained title through adverse possession will be entitled to retain their possession. Moreover, one important aspect that must be noted is that adverse possession is not of itself adequate to ensure ownership of land, rather the squatter should have done work on the land and maintained it in the manner a true owner of the property would, thereby earning the right to the title. However, compulsory registration under the Land Act of 2002 has made it more difficult than ever for unlawful occupiers to be able to obtain possession of title to the property. Conclusion: As may be noted in the case of Pye16 the position of the Government was that the reality of unopposed occupation of land leads to an inference of legal ownership. On this basis therefore, there arises a legitimate public interest in maintaining adverse possession, since the alternative is costly litigation in the Court over age old claims that could drag on for ever. However, the position of the Law Commission and the verdict in this case have eschewed the earlier legal position of favoring squatters and now favor landowners. This could potentially result in owners taking advantage of the stricter requirements to also prevent public use of easements to appurtenant land. As pointed out by Potter, the impact of the Human Rights Act in terms of preventing a landowner from exercising his full rights could mean that prescriptive easements could be the next under attack17, thereby severely undermining the public interest and the rights of the public to the use of easements, which could also include roads through private property. On this basis, it must therefore be concluded that the revised position of the Government and the EU does not appear to take into account the significant public interests in favor of adverse possession. Bibliography * Adverse Possession: Land Registry Act of 2002.” [Online] Available at: http://www.landregistry.gov.uk/assets/library/documents/fact_sheet002.pdf at Sections 96-97 * “Limitation Act of 1980” [Online] Available at: http://www.swarb.co.uk/acts/1980LimitationAct.shtml * Potter, Caroline, 2005. “United Kingdom: Acquiring title by adverse possession in breach of human rights.” [online] available at: http://www.mondaq.com/article.asp?articleid=36268&hotopic=1 Cases cited: * Buckinghamshire County Council v Moran [1990] Ch 623, 635, CA). * JA Pye (Oxford) Ltd v Graham [2002] UKHL 30 [2003] 1 AC * J A Pye (Oxford) Ltd and J A Pye (Oxford) Land Ltd v UK (2004, ECHR App no 44302/02) * Neuberger J in Purbrick v. Hackney LBC [2004] 1 P & CR 553 at 560 * Powell v McFarlane (1977) 38 P&CR 452 * Topplan estates Limited v Townley, 2004] EWCA Civ 1369 Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of the Illegal Storage Case

Analysis & Discussion about gold

Thus in case of banks peoples' gold investments are more protected because in the case of any theft they get their value of the investment in the form the insured amount.... The declining results in terms of gold storage has placed the gold price to the level it is now and since it's a demand and supply law for gold with the supply being from the past storage rather than yearly production that is why it is so highly priced.... The supply side is weak because it is based on the past storage of gold and is affected by the capital intensive production costs....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Impact of Illegal Immigration

Of late, the federal law has brought in many restrictions to keep a check on the illegal immigrants; this also ensures a strict check on the money spent on the public welfare.... There are many other facilities given to the illegal immigrants and there is so much spent day in and day out in providing these services to these people.... There are lapses in the security which is why the illegal immigration is constantly on the rise and the most worrying factor is that the government, in spite of knowing this, has been unable to take appropriate steps....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Phase 4 Individual Project

n the case Olmstead v.... This case occurred in 1928, and involved the legality of producing wire tapped private conversation as pieces of evidence by United States law enforcement officers.... Garland (2006) observes that best evidence rule requires reproduction of original duplicates of photographs, written materials and recordings of materials that are produced in a trial court....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Online Pizza Security

This paper covers the detailed analysis of security aspects regarding the project of the online Pizza shop.... The paper 'Online Pizza Security' seeks to evaluate online security, which has become the biggest challenge for businesses.... Before we start the discussion on security issues related to online Pizza shop we should be familiar with security and privacy issues involved in online businesses....
28 Pages (7000 words) Research Paper

Gold & the Modern World Economy

Thus in case of banks peoples' gold investments are more protected because in the case of any theft they get their value of the investment in the form the insured amount.... The supply side is weak because it is based on the past storage of gold and is affected by the capital intensive production costs.... The declining results in terms of gold storage has placed the gold price to the level it is now and since it's a demand and supply law for gold with the supply being from the past storage rather than yearly production that is why it is so highly priced. ...
6 Pages (1500 words) Report

The Battle against Illegal File Sharing on the Legal Front

If the industry adopts an industry wide iTunes style of merchandizing music most users would desist from using the illegal file sharing sites.... [2005] FCA 1242 and uses the issues raised in the case to explore the historical context of illegal file sharing.... [2005] FCA 1242 and uses the issues raised in the case to explore the historical context of illegal file sharing.... ustralian Legislation and case Laws on illegal file sharing 11 ...
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Gold Storage Facility Surveillance Design

A complete analysis of the area surrounding the facility, called global analysis; macro surveillance of specific areas within the site of the facility and micro analysis, which involves a smaller area of interest (Doktor, 2010).... The recording should be automatic and be recorded on a video tape to ensure their use in case of a criminal act or attempt.... In case of unrecognized number plates, or when the number plate is not matching with the online stored employee profile, an automatic alarm should be sent to all the relevant authorities immediately....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Business Intelligence Strategy

In this case, the organization wanted to add controls and reduce the risk of offsite storage records yet they had various challenges ranging from poor methods of storing and retrieving methods, limited controls for adding new users, inconsistent data requirements for the records, lack of clear ownership for records.... In this case, the organization wanted to add controls and reduce the risk of offsite storage records yet they had various challenges ranging from poor methods of storing and retrieving methods, limited controls for adding new users, inconsistent data requirements for the records, lack of clear ownership for records....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us