StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Border Patrol in the USA - Thesis Proposal Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "Border Patrol in the USA" tells that the politicization of immigration and partisan politics is doing more harm than good to border patrol. We live in a heavily polarized political landscape, a divide that has always been the source of balance and political control.
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Border Patrol in the USA"

Border Patrol in the USA Thesis: The politicization of immigration and partisan politics is doing more harm than good to border patrol I. Border patrol should not be seen as an isolated activity that happens at the country’s borders. Instead, it has to be approached from a wholesome immigration policy perspective A. Immigration trends affect border patrol B. Policies passed in Washington, and/or the opposition to those policies, often tend to curtail border patrol II. We live in a heavily polarized political landscape, a divide that has always been the source of balance and political control. A. It is understandable that the left would want to check the policy suggestions of the right when it comes to border patrol, and the right would rightfully do the same B. Politics, however, affects the actual jobs and tendencies of the border patrol agents and officers. They deal with dangerous and organized criminal groups, and the political grandstanding often ends up affecting how (effectively) they do their jobs III. Politicization of the issues has made progress difficult A. Border patrol should not be partisan, but should be issue based B. Public opinion and anti-immigrant sentiment complicates a job that should always be straightforward, protecting the country from intruders and outside threats Name # December 4,, 2018 Grade Draft Border Patrol in the USA One of the biggest immigration and border patrol related stories in recent weeks arose from the photos of immigrants being dispersed using teargas and pepper spray. It was a shocking image to those that are new to the border patrol debate, but surprisingly not a new thing. A caravan with Honduran immigrants had to be dispersed at the Ysidro border crossing after allegedly attacking the border patrol agents with various objects[Rob18]. This, as one would expect, saw critics of the administration come out strongly in condemnation. Celebrities criticized the move, going as far as comparing President Trump to Hitler. One senator even went as far as accusing the border agents of war crimes and being in violation the chemical weapons convention of 1993[Rob18]. The politics of asylum notwithstanding, if indeed these immigrants, who have faced violence and clashes with police even in Mexico on their journey to the US border charged at the border patrol agents, this seems a justified response. That this has now been reduced to a partisan argument, one full of rhetoric and the usual comparisons with what the former administration did shows just how much politics and the partisan polarization has affected border patrol. Meanwhile, the actual problem of the migrant caravan is still very much alive. It is this political back and forth at the expense of focusing on the real issues that makes border patrol a much more difficult job than it already is. Partisan Politics One of the strengths of the American political system is the presence of checks and balances, especially considering the two party system. This system has been described as compatible with the societal and cultural nature of the country as well as the structures of government. It is a system that has offered the country the benefits of legitimacy, accountability and policy moderation[Dul00]. There is a school of thought, though, that believes the days of ideological parties ruling are over. The American winner-takes-all electoral system used to reward and encourage parties that had a broad national appeal, and no party could win with just half of the electorate and give up on the other half[Dru18]. The dynamics seem to have changed, though, especially with the election to office of Donald Trump. In the past, it was widely believed that no party could win by courting extremist anti-system candidates or ideas. Today, both parties regularly seem to forsake half the electorate, and are rewarded for it[Dru18]. The worst of this, though, is that the political elements often end up affecting real life policy, and one of the areas that has suffered the most has been border patrol. Recently, the president decided to employ national guardsmen to stem the tide of drugs, illegal immigration, criminal cartels and violence. Again, this was a move applauded by one section of the country, with the other side heavily opposed. It is not difficult to work out the partisan alignments of majority of the people on either side. The truth is that past deployments of national guardsmen to the border have been very successful. National guardsmen act as a force multiplier, and are often a welcome addition to a border patrol workforce that struggles to contain illegal immigration, drugs and violence[Agu18]. That the framing of these issues and frankly their motivation, is mainly politically motivated does not help. For instance, the April move to send the National Guard to the border came after a series of characteristic tweets from the president[Vil18]. The political angle/ motivation is difficult to ignore, and invites criticism which then fails to take into consideration and mostly ends up getting in the way of the true value of such a move. For instance, even in busy places like Texas, the National Guardsmen are not allowed to be in the public eye, in observation or in lookout posts, where they might be most helpful[Hen18]. The deployment of these troops was either a face value policy to please a political base more desperate for immigration reform, or is being restricted by a very critical opposition. Either way, politics is actively getting in the way of effective border control, effectively wasting money and resources. The often polarized wall debate is another case in point. The wall was made a symbol and metaphor for the Trump administration, and, at least in some respect, allowing him the liberty to build it would have been seen as a symbolic win/loss and endorsement of the messages sent during the campaign[Nak18]. Very few people debated the actual merits, or lack thereof, of the wall or even considered the opinions of the very people tasked with protecting the border, the actual border patrol agents, who have in many instances come out in support of a wall[Din18]. Conclusion The country and the political class by extension, is much divided today along partisan lines. This makes the usual compromises that made things easier in the past more difficult to arrive at. People would rather have a hard stand and appease their support base, instead of approaching an issue with rationality and considering the weight and effectiveness of the policies they take. One of the issues that should never be caught up in this political debate is that of border patrol. In today’s globalized world, immigration will always be a huge political issue. There will always be sides taken, but on the issue of border patrol, politicization of the actual processes protecting the border do more harm than good. Public opinion, political loyalties and nationalist anti-immigrant sentiment, justified as they might be to either side, complicate an already pretty complicated job of policing the border, places agent and border town lives in danger and results in such situations as the one recently witnessed, where border patrol had to teargas and pepper spray an immigrant caravan. References Rob18: , (Robbins), Dul00: , (Dulio and Thurber), Dru18: , (Drutman), Agu18: , (Aguilar), Vil18: , (Villagomez), Hen18: , (Hennesy-Finke), Nak18: , (Nakamura and O'Keefe), Din18: , (Dinan), Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Border Patrol in the USA Thesis Proposal Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Border Patrol in the USA Thesis Proposal Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/law/1893710-border-patrol-in-the-usa
(Border Patrol in the USA Thesis Proposal Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Border Patrol in the USA Thesis Proposal Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1893710-border-patrol-in-the-usa.
“Border Patrol in the USA Thesis Proposal Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/law/1893710-border-patrol-in-the-usa.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Border Patrol in the USA

Emergency Services in the USA

The essay “Emergency Services in the usa” analyzes the services of the 911, which have come a long way from the times when people in trouble alone had to wait for an operator to pick up the phone and answer.... he use of mobile phones while dialing 911 in the United States posed a problem because the call was first directed to the state police on highway patrol who would then pass on the details to the right PSAPs, but now with the cellular boom it is difficult to gauge the right location from where the call had been made....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Racial Profiling Issues in the US

At the US Mexico border, Latinos are mostly stopped by the border patrol in suspicion of being illegal immigrants.... At the US Mexico border, Latinos are mostly stopped by the border patrol in suspicion of being illegal immigrants.... the usa receives thousands of immigrants from other countries and regions, but Latinos and blacks are the majority of deportees.... Law enforcement and security agencies in usa use an individual's race as a key factor when deciding whether to arrest the persons or stop them for questioning....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Why Firms Have Different Pricing Strategies and React Differently to a Price Change by a Rival

Use The Concept Of Elasticity As Applied To Demand, Supply, And Income To Explain Why Firms May Have Different Pricing Strategies And Why They May React Differently To A Price Change By A Rival?... Use Real World Examples to Demonstrate Your Answers The changing nature and… ent of the modern day business has forced companies or firms to develop various noteworthy strategies in order to sustain for a longer period in the markets wherein they operate....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Cuban Missile Crisis

The origin was a result of usa failure to overthrow Cuba regime.... Castro and his counterpart from Russia, Krushchev were ready to invade US if usa invaded Cuba, which the Soviet saw as their only option to spread communism in Latin America (Allison and Zellikov 112).... fter the confrontation had ended, Soviet Union dismantled the missile systems it had placed in Cuba; on the other hand, usa agreed never to invade Cuba....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Liberal and Academic Approaches to US Immigration Policy

The government in essence must take additional steps to increase border patrol security.... mmigrants in usa has not been treated with Justice according to some thinkers.... mmigrants in usa has not been treated with Justice according to some thinkers....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Accounts of Inhumane Acts in America

This wall has also been described in the border patrol state “it is SHORT WRITING Essay The articles describe accounts of inhumane acts that individuals moving across the border of Mexico and the United States of America undergo.... This wall has also been described in the border patrol state “it is ironic that the U.... government and its border patrol are constructing a steel wall ten feet high to span sections of the border with Mexico”(Silko, 2013, p....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Property ownership, oral evidence (parole)

Contract law in the usa.... Parole may also include verbal information that accompanies a written agreement.... Parole law prevents parties from altering the information that was agreed orally before and… On normal occasions, before signing any contract, the parties involved engage into long discussions that prompt a party to either enter or fail to enter into the contract ....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Performance of the US Democratic Party

I have confidence in the party, that if given another 20 years, the usa economy will be very powerful.... My family has always been supporters for the party We have always believed that the Democratic Party government is the only one that could take usa back to where it used to be and make it even better (Lantis 43).... Another way which usa was going to boost the economy was through attracting investors through having good policies.... usa had been having a problem of unemployment ever since its economy plunged in 2008....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us