StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Not Just Dependent Beings: A key premise in The Cosmological Argument - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Tutor Course Date NOT JUST DEPENDENT BEINGS: A KEY PREMISE IN THE COSMOLOGICAL ARGUMENT Introduction The Cosmological Argument argues on the existence of God. It is a posteriori argument (an argument depending on principle which can be known only by means of our experience in the world as opposed to a priori argument which bases on understanding and reflection on principles which are independent of our world experience)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Not Just Dependent Beings: A key premise in The Cosmological Argument
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Not Just Dependent Beings: A key premise in The Cosmological Argument"

Download file to see previous pages

The first three of the five arguments are versions of the Cosmological Argument. The first is the argument from the fact that there are things that are undergoing change in the world. He conclusively reasoned that there must ultimately be a causative of the change, which is itself unchanging. Secondly, he started from the fact that the existence of some things in the world is a cause of others. He conclusively reasoned that there must be an ultimate cause of existence; the existence of this cause is uncaused.

Thirdly, he started from the factual existence of some things in this world, but we can with ease, imagine that they might not be existent; that they need not have at all existed. He reasoned to the conclusion that there must be a being that had to be that exists and could not have failed to be in existence (Rowe 21). These arguments from Aquinas undoubtedly prove the existence of a changer that is unchanging, an uncaused cause and a being that could not have failed to exist. They, however, fail to show proof for the existence of an omniscient, creator, omnipotent, supremely good theistic God, who is independent of the world (Rowe 22).

The Cosmological Argument thus answers the objection in its two parts, by giving prove of the existence of a being, which could not have failed and seeking to prove that the special being who exists and could not fail to do so, must posses qualities such as omnipotence, perfect goodness, omniscience e.t.c. Aquinas’ argument conclusively gives the assertion that the uncaused cause of existence, the unchanging changer, and a being that had to exist are one and the same. This being possesses all the attributes that the theistic God has (Rowe, 22).

A Dependent Being For a dependent being, others’ casual activities account for its existence; another being explains its existence. It forms a concept, which combined with the Self-existent being concept (its existence explained by itself), form the first part of the Cosmological Argument. This first part of Cosmological Argument entails these concepts: 1. Every being that exists or ever existed is either self-existent or a dependent being. 2. Not every being can be a dependent being, thus, 3.

There is a self-existent being (Rowe 24). The arguments in support of the premise describe an existent being as either dependent or self-existent. The Principle of Sufficient Reason (PSR) gives a justification to this argument as opposed to the somewhat controversial Anslem’s three cases of existence of a being explained by category 1. Others 2. Nothing and 3. Itself. Anslem explains that the existence of beings falls more in category 1 and 3, than 2 (Rowe 24). Leibniz and Samuel Clarke through put forward the PSR which is an ascertainment that there must be an explanation of whatever existent being.

PSR gives a demonstration to highlight the argument, that if one comes across a man in a room, then there must be an explanation that the particular man exists. A reflection in a moment, however, shows that the fact of the man being in a room, is mere, compared to other facts about the same man e.g. the fact that he is thinking about being in Paris rather than Canada, the fact that his health is good. PSR goes beyond scrutiny of the mere fact of the man

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Not Just Dependent Beings: A key premise in The Cosmological Argument Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1462968-not-just-dependent-beings-a-key-premise-in-the
(Not Just Dependent Beings: A Key Premise in The Cosmological Argument Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1462968-not-just-dependent-beings-a-key-premise-in-the.
“Not Just Dependent Beings: A Key Premise in The Cosmological Argument Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1462968-not-just-dependent-beings-a-key-premise-in-the.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Not Just Dependent Beings: A key premise in The Cosmological Argument

The Argument from Different Sides about the Existence of God

he cosmological argument in Favor of Existence of GodThe cosmological argument states that since there is a universe so there has to be someone who caused this universe.... The paper "The argument from Different Sides about the Existence of God" tells that scholars and philosophers have made varied arguments in favor and against the existence of god time to time.... A teleology argument is also addressed as a design argument....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Cosmological Argument. The forms of cosmological arguments

the cosmological argument usually asserts that God is the final uncaused cause of all things.... A cosmological argument attempts to prove the existence of God.... … cosmological argument.... A cosmological argument attempts to prove the existence of God.... The most successful cosmological argument is Thomas Aquinas' argument of contingence.... The argument attempts to do this by showing that an infinite number of regressions that caused things to exist, is not there....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Major Answers to Philosophy of Religion Questions

A “person-relative view of proof” means that the argument should be sound with accurate premises and a valid conclusion should be drawn from the premises.... A person should know the argument to be sound for it to function as a proof.... On the other hand reflective persons are those who responsibly look at all relevant arguments, clarify key ideas and carefully trace the implications of beliefs....
50 Pages (12500 words) Assignment

Meta-Criticism and Metacritical Thinking

The first one, derived from the argument of motion, stipulates that for bodies to be in motion, they have to be moved by other bodies.... (Kilbourne, 116-7)However, it should be noted that there various schools of Meta-critical thought process and they are generally associated wit cosmological criticism and arguments.... Meta-criticism, or key critical concept, such as 'criticism', 'critical', 'critic', 'ctitique', seeks to solve problems by subdividing them into smaller sections that are consequently dealt with accordingly....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Concept of Mythic Mentality

This was achieved by the attainment of wisdom, and in its pursuit they cultivated music, science and mathematics-especially mathematics in its cosmological applications.... They were the first philosophers of the West.... They found a way to break out of the reigning mythic mentality and required to explain nature rationally by means of speculative principles of various kinds generated on the basis of critical observation of the world....
22 Pages (5500 words) Essay

Kant's Theory of Religion

The researcher states that in what has been grouped as his philosophy of religion, Kant gives an extensive discussion on the immortality of the soul, arguments for the existence of God and his attributes, the 'moral argument' for God, moral principles' relationship to religious practice and belief as well as the problem of evil.... Furthermore, Kant uses the critical philosophy as a locus for addressing more explicitly other key aspects of the concepts of God and religion than he had done in his former writings....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Basic Principles of Life Philosophy

This paper "Philosophy of Life" focuses on the fact that the word philosophy is the composition of two Greek words, 'Philo' meaning 'love' and 'Sophia' meaning wisdom that literally translates to love of wisdom.... In literal meaning, it refers to the study that is pursued the love towards wisdom....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Cosmological Argument for the Existence of God

Of these, the cosmological arguments are based on empirical evidence, and proceed from the fact of the world as it exists, in order to arrive at a logical conclusion that there must be a cause behind this world.... These are:the cosmological arguments, which are further examined in this paper, are based on an analysis of actual experiences, rather than on concepts.... The word “argument” refers to a formulation of the premises and the conclusions derived from them (Jeffcoat, n....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us