StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Critical Assessment of Martin Wights Why Is There No International Theory - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Martin Wight’s seminal article in 1960 professed to show the (perceived) paucity of international theory as a guide to the international system, unlike the rich heritage of political theory explicating the complex processes of domestic, i.e. national, politics. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
A Critical Assessment of Martin Wights Why Is There No International Theory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Critical Assessment of Martin Wights Why Is There No International Theory"

Why Is There So Much International Theory A Critical Assessment of Martin Wight’s “Why Is There No International Theory?” Martin Wight’s seminal article in 1960 professed to show the (perceived) paucity of international theory as a guide to the international system, unlike the rich heritage of political theory explicating the complex processes of domestic, i.e. national, politics. Wight claims that this paucity is compounded by “intellectual and moral poverty…[due to] the intellectual prejudice imposed by the sovereign State, and the belief in progress” (1960/2000, p. 30). He argues that there is no body of knowledge in international theory, understood as “speculation about the society of states, or the family of nations, or the international community” (Wight, 2000, 28), to match the successes of political theory, understood as “speculation about the state” (Wight, 2000, p. 27). The “theory of the good life” (Wight, 2000, p. 39), political theory’s central concern, was deemed incompatible with the study of international relations (IR), since the latter is understood to be primarily engaged with survival. In this essay, we shall evaluate Wight’s criticism of international theory and shall attempt to show his damaging claim failed to take into account the changes in the international which were already evident at the time. For conceptual clarity, we henceforth use international theory and IR theory interchangeably. The sources of international theory which Wight identifies form an eclectic mix of international law (Grotius and Prufendorf), writings of “irenists” such as Erasmus and Sully, Machiavellian elements, the “parerga” of political theorists, philosophers and historians (Hume, Rousseau, and Burke), and the speeches, despatches and other documents of statesmen of old, like Gentz and Bismarck (Wight, 2000, pp. 28-30). To reiterate the paucity of IR theory, he maintains that most of these works remain penetrable only by the scholar, making the international somewhat of an ivory tower. But, contrary to his belief, Wight falls prey to his own device: he traces the germ of the international in such locales which were gradually becoming obscure. By the time his article was republished in an edited volume in 1966, some of the ‘classics’ of IR theory had already been penned, discussing the causal analysis of war (Waltz, 1959; more on this later) and decision-making and deterrence theory (Schelling, 1960). The central challenges to IR theory posed by Wight are tow-fold: sparse theorization of the international and its incompatibility with progress. However, it must be understood that international theory and political theory are inextricably intertwined in the political discourse of our times. To the first challenge, there are three distinct responses which are not purported to be interconnected. Firstly, the study of IR as a serious academic discipline (or sub-discipline) emerged out of the scourge of the First World War. Thus, no matter what its influences and scattered linkages with the past, IR theories’ tenure of less than one half century would obviously compare unfavorably with the vast theoretical tradition of political theory. Secondly, the “intellectual prejudice imposed by the sovereign state” did not necessarily impede theoretical endeavors in IR. Kenneth Waltz provided a systemic understanding of the international by arguing that the structure of the international system was anarchic, meaning not chaotic but devoid of a central organizing agency (1979). This theory, known as neo-realism, offered a structural explanation for the behavior of nation-states. Though Waltz’s ideas were published in 1979 – a singularly salient year with regard to this assessment – the formative ideas were all present in the earlier work. Thirdly, the decade of the 1970s steadily saw the rise a variety of theories, responding to the current of world events. The Cold War détente increased interest in theories of interdependence, while the oil-supply shocks invigorated the curiosity in the international political economy. Soon after, Charles Beitz published his groundbreaking treatise on international distributive justice, cementing the place of international political theory within the broader spectrum of international theory (1979). International political theory now consists of the study of three distinct binaries – inside/outside, universal/particular, and system/society – while also raising normative questions about the ethical foundations of international life (Brown, 2006, pp. 34-51). Since the 1970s, there has been an explosion in IR theories; realism, liberalism, and social constructivism remain the most dominant traditions today amid other persuasions such as critical theory, Marxism, rational choice, postmodernism, ‘green’ theory, communitarianism and cosmopolitanism, to name a few (Walt, 1998; Snyder, 2004). In fact, the poverty of international theory has now turned to an overwhelming opulence, with rich methodological debates between empiricism and normative theory, and ontology and epistemology (Jackson & Sorensen, p. 301). Wight’s other charge against IR theory is that it is not progressive; however, it has been argued that international theory implicitly employs philosophical issues in its claims and assumptions (Kurki & Wight, 2006, 15-17). Moreover, the purpose of IR theory is clarification and explanation which its many variants provide regardless of the priority the nation-state imposes on them. Theoretical progress does not always follow a normative goal. Wight’s rejection of IR theory as a circular, repetitive and sometimes tautological process (2000, pp. 35-36) fails to perceive the changes which the international system experienced since the start of the Cold War. He speaks of the superpower arms race but fails to take into account that that particular conflict was without historical precedent. Yet, an almost innumerable number of IR theories have forwarded propositions based on observed data to explain the same. The use of evidence to adjudicate between truth claims indeed makes international theories progressive, while making sure that the evidence does not follow the conviction. A reappraisal of Wight’s argument, thus, finds that IR theory has blossomed into a vigorous field of research, sometimes more dynamic and radiant than contemporary political theory. Either Wight’s article served as the call for theorists to respond, or he did not expect to see such a rich outpouring of theoretical energy so soon after his pessimistic statement. As we have found, international theory and political theory are contiguous, if not cognate, academic pursuits, each complementing and reinforcing the other. The autonomous creation of a theory of IR was never necessary, and Wight’s essay, in the end, fades in the light of the history of ideas in international theory. Reference Beitz, C. R. (1979). Political Theory and International Relations. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press. Brown, C. (2006). International Relations as Political Theory. In T. Dunne, T. Dunne, M. Kurki, & S. Smith (Eds.) Theories of International Relations: Discipline and Diversity (pp. 34-51). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Jackson, R., & Sorensen, G. (2007). Introduction to International Relations: Theories and Approaches [3rd Edition]. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Kurki, M. & Wight, C. (2006). International Relations and Social Science. In T. Dunne, T. Dunne, M. Kurki, & S. Smith (Eds.) Theories of International Relations: Discipline and Diversity (pp. 13-33). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Schelling, T. C. (1960). The Strategy of Conflict. Cambridge, MA.: Harvard University Press. Snyder, J. (2004). One World, Rival Theories. Foreign Policy, November/December 2004, 53-62. Walt, S. M. (1998). International Relations: On World, Many Theories. Foreign Policy, Spring 1998, 29-46. Waltz, K. N. (1959). Man, the State and War: A Theoretical Analysis. New York: Columbia University Press. ______ (1979). Theory of International Politics. New York: McGraw-Hill. Wight, M. (2000). Why Is There No International Theory? In A. Linklater (Ed.), Critical Concepts in Political Science: International Relations (pp. 27-42). London: Routledge. [Original published in 1960.] Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Critical Assessment of Martin Wights Why Is There No International Essay”, n.d.)
A Critical Assessment of Martin Wights Why Is There No International Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1548704-a-critical-assessment-of-martin-wights-why-is-there-no-international-theory
(A Critical Assessment of Martin Wights Why Is There No International Essay)
A Critical Assessment of Martin Wights Why Is There No International Essay. https://studentshare.org/politics/1548704-a-critical-assessment-of-martin-wights-why-is-there-no-international-theory.
“A Critical Assessment of Martin Wights Why Is There No International Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1548704-a-critical-assessment-of-martin-wights-why-is-there-no-international-theory.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Critical Assessment of Martin Wights Why Is There No International Theory

Strategic Management: Barclays Premier League and Manchester United

The last decade has seen has radical transformation of the UK football industry, with economic indicators pointing to football has a viable business model (Johnson et al, 2008, p.... 0).... A prime example of this is the Barclays sponsorship of the Premier League, who has recently… President of Barclays PLC commented that “Football is the world's favourite sport bringing pleasure to hundreds of millions of people across the globe, out sponsorship of the world's most popular league creates a positive emotional link between our brand and football fans everywhere” (www....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Implentation of effective youth justice practice

The youth justice practitioner is trained to develop a discerning and critical attitude towards their area of expertise as well as ensure that the same is fundamentally ethical, sound and based on correct and accurate knowledge.... In order to understand the process we must take into account the complexity of rehabilitating and restoring young sometimes chaotic lives....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Foundations of scholarship&research

However, most businesses fail to live up to their ethical expectations when they operate on the international This paper examines the basis for business ethics and zooms in to examine the realities in the international markets and why organisations fail to honour the high ethical standards they observe in their home countries (especially in Europe and North America) when they operate in poorer nations like Latin America, Africa, Eastern Europe and Southeast Asia....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Analysing the External Environment

The external environment is able to determine a business's success or failure; that is why it is extremely important for businesses to carefully analyze it.... The function of business is fundamental in that it is a vital establishment that greatly benefits society in the production of products as well as services, the generation of job opportunities, and the overall development of the nation's economy (martin, 1990:95)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Hidden Curriculum as Educations Side Effects

Such side effects are learned lessons even though they were not openly intended to be taught or learned and they include the transmission of beliefs, values and norms that… As Ball (1986) observed in the UK, the sociology of education has mainly concerned itself with analysing the relationship between social class and educational opportunities since the 1930s where social theorists advocate that However, on the other hand, Giddens (2006) argues that schools reproduce and perpetuate social inequalities that already exist in social class and race....
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

Mathematics and Gender: Are Boys Really Better than Girls

Attempts to measure attitude, achievement and affect across the international arena has given two main approaches that deal with large-scale recurrent assessments.... These assessments are the Trends in international Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) and PISA.... TIMSS is basically a method of international assessment tackling mathematics as well as science for students on their eighth grade.... This assessment is usually carried out on a four-year cycle by the international Association for the Evaluation of international Achievement (IEA), assisted by the Canadian Educational Testing Service and Statistics....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Critical Importance of Materiality in Auditing

The paper "critical Importance of Materiality in Auditing" highlights that academic researches on materiality have proven Mock et al.... Materiality is of critical importance to auditors, which academic research findings have demonstrated and linked to its nondisclosure treatment by auditors.... Porter said the word 'material' is of critical importance to auditors because it often refers to strategic and planned choices essential for conducting an autonomous audit....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Intangible Assets Management and Evaluation

It also looks into reporting entities most affected by the standard, academic or non-academic research relevant to the standard and a critical evaluation of the standard.... This paper discusses the IAS 38 intangible asset accounting standard and theories applicable to the standard....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us