StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Care - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article "Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Care" believes that intuition and analysis should be employed in decision-making to avoid the demerits of each being used separately. The research proposes documentation of intuition for passing this decision-making knowledge from experts to novices…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Care
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Care"

The method used in this research was appropriate and informative. Quantitative data dominated qualitative data and was critically analyzed and evaluated after its collection. The researchers met psychotherapists in an in-service training where they raised the issue of clinical intuition. Participants were given questionnaires to fill in 10 minutes. The psychotherapists were 20 in number, 17 female and 2 men. One of the twenty did not give consent to the use of his or her answers in the questionnaire. This questionnaire had 3 questions relating to their view on clinical intuition, the role of clinical intuition in their diagnostic process, and how they used their intuition.

Another questionnaire (Diagnostic Decision Making (DDM) questionnaire) was included. It contained 18 scenarios about intuition and DSM use. Here, participants were asked to show their use of intuition and DSM on a range of between 1 (never) to 5 (always). A focus-group interview was afterward conducted. The group was divided into two. Each group had a discussion leader to moderate and control the discussion which was audiotaped. After one hour and fifteen minutes, the two groups were rejoined. Conclusions were drawn out and summarized (Witteman, Spaanjaars, and Aarts 4).

Results
Though not significantly, participants scored lower in on Intuition than on Self-monitoring, 19.47 (SD = 2.63) versus M = 22.21 (SD = 3.17). DSM use was in between, M = 21.42 (SD = 3.42). The subscales identified different decision-making styles by clinicians and also that they could self-assess their use of intuition. The answers to the open question (What is clinical intuition?) were dominated by the word ‘feelings’ and additions such as experience and textbook knowledge. Intuition was therefore defined by the participants as a combination of how a patient makes one feel and verifiable data. The question about when intuition plays a role was answered by: at first sight, during uncertainties, and always. Always means both during diagnosis and in treatment. In the focus group, it was concluded that intuition is considerably less often used in behavior therapy compared to client-centered therapy where it is popular. On how intuition is used, the research found that the participants discussed their intuitions with colleges during group supervision sessions. The participants also communicated their gut feelings with their patients or clients to seek their opinion. They then combined intuitions with other information before making final clinical decisions (Witteman, Spaanjaars, and Aarts 4-5).

Conclusions
The study concludes that practitioners can make their use of intuition explicit. The study also identifies that intuition can be learned. All but one participant agreed that intuition can be learned more so in practice than in college, and through supervision in client-centered training. One can learn how to use intuition properly by incorporating its risks and merits. Intuition should be trusted when complimenting information and consultations with both supervisors and clients (Witteman, Spaanjaars, and Aarts 7). For verification of the myth about the use of intuition, there is a need for intuitions, which are naturally used implicitly, to be made explicit.

This is important in order to change intuition to be a worthwhile, knowledge-based, decision-making platform trainable to novices. This would help them make more expert-like judgments in their clinical practice. The finding of the research does not imply that expert judgment and intuition are better than evidence-based decision-making criteria. However, the research shows that intuition, besides being unavoidable, is considerably used in practice and should complement evidence-based decision-making criteria. There is a need to demystify the above myth since the research shows that intuitions can be made explicit in order to equip novices with skills closely as perfect as those of experts. Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Review of the Research Article Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Essay”, n.d.)
Review of the Research Article Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1451454-expert-judgment-and-intuition-are-the-best-means
(Review of the Research Article Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Essay)
Review of the Research Article Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Essay. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1451454-expert-judgment-and-intuition-are-the-best-means.
“Review of the Research Article Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1451454-expert-judgment-and-intuition-are-the-best-means.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Clinical Intuition in Mental Health Care

Rapid Sequence Induction and Intubation. Incidence Reflection

In this reflection I have ensured that I maintain confidentiality in line with the health Professional Council code of Conduct that demands the observance of the same, under code number two that states “You must respect the confidentiality of service users.... I will give a reflection of this incident as was performed on an obese patient during my clinical placement.... First is that as a student ODP doing my clinical placement, it was my first time to come across such a major incident and therefore it made me curious....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Importance of Decision-Making in Advanced Critical Theories

Changes in technology development, health care settings, and new methods of patient care have increased the importance of clinical decision-making.... Critical care is filled with uncertainty, variability, complexity, and numerous constraints.... It is very difficult to use controlled trials to obtain the required evidence for making good decisions regarding critical care capacity and organization (Buckingham and Adams, 2000).... The key to good decision-making is the understanding of existing demands of critical care and the ability to predict the likely effects of changing capacity and organization (Montgomery, Lipshitz, and Brehmer, 2005)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Risk Assessment and Management in Forensic Mental Health

This essay "Risk Assessment and Management in Forensic mental health" is about an understanding of whether incarcerating are able to stay out of trouble once they leave incarceration, and how should be decided by who works with the individual outside of jail or prison.... Risk for a mental health patient generally means an assessment of whether the individual will become violent against themselves or against others.... Unstructured professional often comes under scrutiny because it is based on a clinician's intuition and therapeutic experience with the incarcerated individual....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Healing in Primary Care

Critical evaluation: Healing in primary care: A vision shared by patients, physicians, nurses and clinical staff Healing is a fundamental part of medical science, yet its role is insufficiently understood in the modern health care system (Brody, 1992; Lown, 1996; Cassell, 1991).... Critical literature review: Healing in primary care Introduction The field of medicine is insufficient without the use of evidence based practices.... As we are critically analysing two articles-Healing in Primary care: A vision shared by patients, physicians, nurses and clinical staff and Understanding healing relationship in primary care, it is more appropriate to define healing, which is defined as a multidimensional process with emotional, physical and spiritual dimensions (Hsu et al....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review

Development of Clinical Supervision

The author states that health care providers like clinics have been a focus on quality for quite some time.... One service industry that is facing continuing pressure to improve quality and has the fastest growing interest in quality is the health care industries.... Clinical supervision sits at the heart of the UK Government's agenda for improving the quality of service delivery (Department of health, 1997, 1998, 1999)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Term Paper

Reflective Analysis of a Clinical Decision

The implications for future role development are: developing specialized nursing care for various departments of the healthcare system with greater guidance.... 5), unlike in the past, the practice nurse is now becoming recognized as an accessible health professional.... The National Institute for Clinical Excellence had commissioned the National Collaborating Centre for Women and Children's health to develop a clinical guideline on long-acting reversible contraception for women for use by the National health Service (NHS) in England and Wales (Web site of National Institute for health and Clinical Excellence)1....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Self Assessment in Clinical Environments

Van Manen defines reflection in terms of a means of mental action that distances the person from events in the order that they may be viewed in a more objective manner (as cited in Moon, 1999).... The paper "Self Assessment in clinical Environments" discusses that self-assessments that done by practitioners in clinical environments are truly helpful in student learning, as individuals who assess themselves either through reflective practice or test-taking, find ways to be better learners....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Coroners Reporting on the Mental Care Continuity and Assessment

Two mental health care providers, continuity of care can be perceived as the provision of services that are seamless through coordination, integration, and free sharing of information through the providers that are involved in the mental health care provision process (Wierdsma, Mulder, de Vries &Sytema 2009, p.... Many people perceive continuity of care as the state of having a caring relationship with a health care professional.... This paper 'Coroners Reporting on the Mental care Continuity and Assessment" focuses on the fact that continuity of care comes in relation to the quality of care provided over time....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us